I called to downgrade my account before the first anniversary and got a prorated refund of the $450. It actually seems slightly more generous, as they prorated it back to the end of last month by my calculations, so I didn't get charged for October membership even though I had it more than half the month. I went with the Chase Freedom card. I didn't like that I'm missing the new sign up bonus for the freedom, but I didn't want to close the CSR account, I just wanted an account with no annual fee. I also applied for the Chase Freedom about 9-10 months ago but was denied, so I don't know if I'm eligible to open new chase accounts or not. I'm not planning to open any new chase accounts right now.
My wife however is probably eligible for another Chase account and is going to need to cancel/downgrade her CSR asap. I'd rather her sign up for the chase freedom and get the sign up bonus (plus we will actually use the chase freedom for the rotating 5% categories) and transfer her account to something else, like the freedom unlimited. The freedom unlimited seems useless though with only 1.5% cash back. Every purchase either falls into a high reward category for some other card, or worst case I have the citi 2% cash back card, so we will never use the 1.5% cash back unlimited card.
Should she transfer her CSR into an unlimited and then complete a new application for the freedom card? Or should she apply for the freedom card first, then call to transfer her CSR to the unlimited? Or is there an even better option that I'm not thinking of right now?
EDIT: I was under the impression the sign up bonus was greater for the freedom vs the unlimited, but it looks like they are both $150 when you spend $500, so I guess it doesn't matter which one she gets the bonus on.