I watched two movies about dysfunctional marriages this week, and both suffered from a lot of the same problems, mostly due to the spotty writing.
The Nest: A lot of talent marshaled in service of a very unfocused script that couldn't decide if it was a psychological thriller, domestic drama, or straight up horror movie. I kept expecting things to elevate and get really bonkers, which would have made it interestiing, but the movie kept teasing and copping out and it never really adopted a strong pov. However, it was very watchable...beautiful cinemetography, oustanding performance by Carrie Coon (who I am fairly unfamiliar with), and Jude Law competently reverting to his mid-career staple of charming narcissist. Had promise, but fizzled out in the end.
Similar problems with Marriage Story. Extremely watchable and enjoyable (maybe b/c I've had a happy marriage for almost 30 years, with very little conflict...I suspect it might not be a fun watch if it cuts closer to home), but not quite worth all the rave reviews.
The script was a strange combination of overwritten silliness (that ridiculous fight scene wtf? Johansson's family wtf?), great individual scenes or details (e.g., Driver and the knife), and generic. The performances (except for Alan Alda, who was great) were spotty, probably b/c of the weird writing. Scarlet Johansson and Adam Driver were absolutely phenomenal in some scenes, and pretty bad in other scenes. Laura Dern, Julie Haggerty, and Merritt Weaver were ridiculous caricatures (though enjoyable ones) and all three of them over-racted in the extreme. It's a bit of a bummer that Laura Dern won an Oscar for this, when she's been so much better in so many other movies. Maybe one could view it as a 'career achievement award'.
Very strange. Not actively bad but not deserving of its accolades, either. Soft recommend if you like talky character dramas b/c it is a very diverting two hours.