My fear in this case would be trying anything that doesn't end up matching well or blending in with what you already have. Seems like something that will be difficult to "get right" and going from "pretty cool look" to "nice try, but..."
We have used Eagle Supreme sealer, and it leaves a nice, shiny coat. But if it can't be absorbed consistently across the whole surface, it won't look good at all. Seems to me that no matter what you use, that consistent absorption is going to be key, and that will be hard to achieve if the "dullness" isn't consistent. I'm guessing you already know this and that's why you're posting, though, so I will quietly back away and see what others suggest.