Well, you asked for thoughts, so here goes -
I find younger men (I assume everyone here is younger than I am, and at 58 it's probably true in most cases)
get enamoured of doing things "Old School". I suppose there is a certain pleasure in reviving lost arts. I know some younger men who are very charged up about their old timey shaving paraphernalia. If it brings you pleasure, then great.
Neither my father or grandfather ever used s straight razor to shave (except the occasional barbershop shave) Even in the 1930s the straight razor was technologically obsolete and the safety razor was king (Literally, King Gillette). I started shaving in the 1970s, using a safety razor. I quickly changed to the "newer" cartridge razors when they came out. As far as close/smooth shaving goes, I'll take a multi-blade cartridge over a safety razor any day. I have never tried a straight razor, but I see little reason to do so.
If you enjoy the process, that's fine. I don't. Shaving for me is a daily chore and it's best to deal with it as efficiently as possible. I'm not overly concerned about how much time it takes, though again I get no special charge out of lathering etc. etc. My main efficiency concern is the cost of blades.
So, a moth ago I bought an electric razor (Wahl) I put it on the charger overnight as recommended and have not had it on the charger since. The shave is not quite razor blade close, but it's close enough. No shaving foam/creme/gel/soap. No replacement blades (though the head will have to be replaced in time at a cost of about half the price of the shaver itself). Takes about 2.5 minutes to shave and I don't have to wet my face.
I assume the shaver will last several years, so the cost will just keep amortizing. The head will last, I'm estimating, 2.5 years and then will require replacement at about $25. Shaving daily my cost per shave (not including the shaver itself) is less than 3 cents per shave.
Another thing I like about the electric is that I only need a miror (and then only near the sideburns). So, if my wife is hogging the bathroom I can still shave in the living room, or wherever there is a mirror.
So, for me, please, no shaving mug, no strop, no shaving soap, no badger hair brush, let me shave in the moment, and let the moment not last beyond 3 minutes and then no clean up.