My Mustachian people problem- DH won't let me start prepping our taxes since we may be modestly over the upcoming stimulus check income limit if it is decreased to 100k. I typically enjoy doing taxes (it's a nice way to do a formal check-in on our income and look at the progress we've made career-wise and personally). Getting a refund early in the year is pretty nice too! So... I will exercise patience this year.
Our understanding is that if we file our 2020 taxes now, the gov't will base our stimulus check on the AGI reported therein, while if we receive a check based on our 2019 income we will not owe it back even if our 2020 AGI is higher than the income limits. At least, based on the previous stimulus bill rules...? Is that correct or are we misinterpreting?
I was under the impression that either way, when you file taxes for the year it will all be tried up. That is, you might get a stimulus check with this method, but if your are over the limit you will pay it back with your 2021 taxes. I could be wrong, I am not close to any cut offs and so have only gleaned what has been mentioned here and there, I haven't looked into any of it.
For the first stimulus you are indeed wrong. I haven’t checked the second and we can’t know for the third until the bill is passed but I’d be surprised if they changed the approach
Dragoncar is correct. From
https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/i1040gi.pdf:
Subtract line 16 from line 15. If zero or less, enter -0-. If line 16 is more than line 15, you don’t have to pay back
the difference
Where line 16 is the Economic Impact Payments already received, and line 15 is the calculation of the Recovery Rebate Credit you would've earned.
I personally think that it's likely that any new stimulus will require people to file their 2020 taxes and not be based on 2019 or prior years. When the first round of stimulus was being debated, a lot of places had suddenly shut down with little to no plan to offer distanced or virtual services, but since we've had a year to plan, that's not really the case anymore. (For example, the VITA site where I do volunteer tax prep shut down completely last February, but this year there's a whole virtual infrastructure built out so we'll be doing returns again starting this week.)