"But is lower retail spending and decreased energy consumption an effect of mustachianism slowly pervading culture, a sign of overall sluggish if not depressed economic activity, or a combination of the the two? I would say a combination, with much more weight being put on sluggish to depressed economic activity."
Of course, it's maybe 95 percent the economy, and 5 percent that people are "getting it" about finances. Still, the "getting it" needle is definitely off the zero mark, which is probably because of the sluggish economy. If economic and job growth stretched forward as far as the eye could see, heck maybe I too might buy that Macbook Air gizmo on a charge card or what not. Instead, I'm relentlessly paying down what's left of my mortgage debt, as I think that's the best thing I can do at this time.
It's probably a good thing not too many of us are getting it all at once, or the economy would crater.