We were just in an almost identical situation. I just turned 51, DH just turned 52. We both made over $100K per year and both of us had at least parts of our job we liked (maybe even loved). We knew we were walking away from a LOT. However, it wasn't too difficult to decide it was worth it just for the freedom to do whatever we wanted to do with no internal politics involved (because that was a big part of what we both hated about our jobs).
We had sold our house about a year and a half ago in anticipation of retiring and were leasing a condo (fully furnished) in our hometown. We already owned our retirement place in another state (at the beach even!) We just paid the last semester for our son's college. Right after we got here, we paid off our condo here so we are mortgage free!
DH is already retired from the AF so we have his pension and health insurance from that already. That's what we'll live off until we turn 59 and can both access our 401Ks penalty free. At that point, we'll have more money than we'll know what to do with.
Loss of status? Well, maybe moving to a new state where nobody knows us already did that for us. I'd much rather be known for who I am rather than what I do for a living.
We were also in our peak earning years. I know it seems crazy to be willing to walk away from such high paying jobs when so many people can't even imagine making that much money... but money isn't everything. All we need it enough and we have enough.
I can honestly say that in the 10 days we've been retired, I haven't been bored once. I haven't been terribly active all day every day but still, the days don't drag on like they used to when I was in the office. That doesn't mean I won't ever be bored but I love the idea of always being able to choose what I do... so, if I'm bored, well... I can choose to do something that's not boring. The possibilities are endless.
DH could easily go back as a contractor with his company and even work remotely from here. I think I've convinced him not to even consider it. :) There's no going back for me but honestly, now that I've been away from it for 10 days, there's no way I'd consider that anyway.
It was an easy decision for us and from what you said in your post, it sounds like it's shouldn't be too difficult for you. My advice would be to just do it.
Here's something I posted on Facebook early last week, just a few days into our retirement. This is what it's been like for us so far:
Just a few days in and thought I'd share some of my favorites things about retirement so far...
Waking up with no alarm. Even if that means getting up at 3:30 a.m., it's because I woke up and wanted to get up, not because I had to get up. That's pretty cool. It may take awhile to stop waking up at 5 a.m. but I'm pretty sure that will come.
Eating when I want to eat, not because someone else says it's time to eat. We just finished a wonderful lunch on the balcony and it's almost 2 p.m. We probably won't eat dinner, just snack. We didn't have to eat 2 hours ago just because that's when our lunch break was.
Cooking in the middle of the day, not just in the evening after a long day at work when I'm tired and cooking is really the last thing I'd like to do. I just made a wonderful lunch for us - tempeh tacos. They were delicious and there's enough leftovers that I won't have to cook anything else tonight if I don't feel like it. And made oatmeal peanut butter squares yesterday just because I could.
Making appointments for things like haircuts without regard to what day or time the appointment is. Thursday at 10 a.m.? Sure. I can do that.
And an afternoon margarita (that went really well with the tempeh tacos I made for lunch!) on the balcony while I'm finishing up a really good book on a Tuesday afternoon. Ahhhh, yeah. That's the ticket.