Yes this seems rather ignorant and bigoted honestly. @Manchester
I’ve spent time living in China, the healthcare is within the range I’ve seen in the USA (not as good as the best in the US, but a lot better than the worst), contrary to your statement the people have good standards of hygiene and the average person appears healthier and more fit than in the USA (in part people people walk a lot more, eat on average a healthier diet than the standard western diet).
In addition because the different demographic profile in China vs the USA and Europe, there are fewer old people, those most as risk from this virus, as a percent of the overall population of people who could potentially be infected.
You'll be in a better position than me to judge China, but my company does a lot of overseas work.
We've recently had staff in China and the horror stories sounded appalling.
Admittedly, this is all second-hand information. I can only go off what I've read and been told though. I know there are good and bad examples in every culture and country. My post was far too simplified and I was generalising points.
Oh I have chinese horror stories, just not about any of kind of issues you mentioned. When I was over there the air quality was horrible (and this could play a difference in death rates since there are a lot more people walking around mild to moderately compromised respiratory systems even before they get sick).
But in particular I don't know where your statement about people in china having low standards of hygiene came from. That's the one made me really cringe.
If you know China well, do you not think it's fair to assume they're less likely to be able to contain a pandemic when compared to the majority of western countries?
Actually I would argue quite the opposite, for a rather dark reason.
China is able to order and enforce lockdowns over cities and provinces just like that. And they have the security and military apparatus to enforce those lockdowns.
They already have the infrastructure in place to trace the travel patterns of every cell phone user on a nationwide scale and no legal or logistical problems sending out police or the military to yank those people out of their apartments, jobs, or buses to lock them up in quarantine just because they traveled from a city where the virus was active, or cell phone location data show they rode a bus with someone to tested positive for the virus.
In western countries we don't have that kind of surveillance infrastructure and our governments have more checks and balances on what they are and are not allowed to do. Which make us much nicer places to live, but also means we're at a disadvantage relative to China when it comes trying to stop the spread of a novel disease.