Author Topic: Can someone help me understand tax implications of wife quitting job?  (Read 1907 times)

pnw_guy

  • Stubble
  • **
  • Posts: 139
The preface for this post is that I know I am incredibly naive about taxes. I really gone out of my way to not learn about the tax code and always dread tax season. Just gives me a headache thinking about it.

Anyhow, my wife is considering reducing or quitting her job due to covid concerns. Overall, we're high income and make about $400K per year, with her making about $70K of that. We own a home with a mortgage and have a young child.

What we're trying to understand is the tax consequences of her quitting her job or reducing her hours. I've heard people say things like "At our tax bracket it doesn't make sense for my partner to even work" given that their tax bracket is so high, but I've never really understood this. However, I'm wondering if due to our tax bracket if having my wife reduce her hours wouldn't be as painful to our overall income because it would reduce our tax bracket.

Can anybody help me figure out what the implication would be of her cutting her hours? Please help because I'm really clueless about this topic even though I feel like we're savvy in other aspects of personal finance!

terran

  • Magnum Stache
  • ******
  • Posts: 3876
Re: Can someone help me understand tax implications of wife quitting job?
« Reply #1 on: January 21, 2022, 10:46:39 AM »
With $330k income for your and $70k income for your wife you'll likely have federal taxable income of $374,100 after the $25,900 standard deduction, or less if you itemize. That puts you in the 32% bracket, so: ($374,100-$340,100)x32% + ($340,100 - $178,150)x24% + ($178,150 - $83,550)x22% +  ($83,550 - $20,550)x12% + $20,550x10% = $80,175 federal income tax.

If your wife stops working dropping income down to $330k your taxable income will be $304,100 after the standard deduction. That puts you in the 24% bracket, so: ($304,100 - $178,150)x24% + ($178,150 - $83,550)x22% +  ($83,550 - $20,550)x12% + $20,550x10% = $60,655 federal income tax.

Your wife is also likely paying $70,000 x 7.65% = $5,355 of FICA tax.

So all together, you'd save $24,875 in federal income tax and FICA taxes, meaning you'd have $45,125 less take home if she stops working. Given your username I assume you live in WA without a a state income tax, but if I'm wrong that could be a factor too.

If the income numbers you provide are before deductions like 401(k) and health insurance then the tax will be less in both scenarios, but the difference will be smaller if she contributes to a 401(k).

By no longer paying FICA her social security will be lower unless she's already worked 35 years at the same or higher income after adjusting for inflation. As long as you've been or stay married for 10 years and she doesn't remarry if you get divorced she'll get at least 1/2 of your social security, so it might not make a huge difference. After 5 or so years of not working she'll no longer be eligible for social security disability payments if she becomes disabled.

I'm sure there are things I'm missing, but that's what I can think of in terms of tax or related considerations.

You might find @MDM's case study spreadsheet useful to plug in both scenarios with more exact numbers to see what the effect would be. It looks like it hasn't been updated for 2022 yet, but not much should change compared to 2021.


MDM

  • Senior Mustachian
  • ********
  • Posts: 11691
Re: Can someone help me understand tax implications of wife quitting job?
« Reply #2 on: January 21, 2022, 11:12:47 AM »
You might find @MDM's case study spreadsheet useful to plug in both scenarios with more exact numbers to see what the effect would be. It looks like it hasn't been updated for 2022 yet, but not much should change compared to 2021.
Thanks terran.

pnw_guy, see the last post (as of now) in that thread for comments on 2022 update timing.  If you had no children (and thus neither Child Tax Credits nor Child/Dependent Care Credits), using 2021 tax calculations would almost certainly be accurate enough for your purposes.  The presence of a child might complicate things tax-wise somewhat, and of course if dependent care would no longer be needed, that non-tax effect could be significant.

If you don't like spreadsheets, but use tax software to do your own taxes, when you do your 2021 taxes create a dummy return with everything the same except for changing/deleting her W-2 and compare.

Any questions on that spreadsheet, feel free to ask here or PM me.