What part of the paid tradelines process is fraudulent?
The part where you claim the AU is personally known to you. It's a tiny white lie, but it's still a lie.
Its going to a take a lot of money for a tradeline company to provide all of their AU cardholders and forfeit their future income streams. This could also have potential legal implications due to a third party sharing private information without consent.
I'm sure their privacy policy is sufficiently broad to allow them some wiggle room. I don't trust anybody anymore.
And they don't even have to turn over their books. If I was a tradeline company and VISA offered to pay me the equivalent of one tradeline sale to check whether or not I had added a specific name to a specific card in the past month, I'd be tempted. It's a yes/no question. You're not revealing any information not already known to VISA. It's a potential revenue stream.
Do they actually do it? I have no idea. I'm just saying that these people are all running businesses, and money talks when you're in business. Ethics kind of goes out the window, as I think we've already established in this thread. It's not like they have any shortage of cardholders, mustachian or otherwise, to require protecting their valuable cards. They literally can't sell 90% of the available slots they already have. Converting another 10% of those into one-time cash payments from VISA (who will probably close the card if you answer yes) in order to double your revenue would be a tempting offer, I think. All of those unsold slots aren't doing anything for you otherwise, so why not get paid for them?
This whole business model exists in a sort of moral gray area, like payday loans and creative accounting, where there is money to be made if you're willing to be a little fast and loose with the rules. I'm not exactly confident that any of these companies would take the moral ground of refusing VISA if they offered to pay for an AU name check. This whole thread is a treasure trove of examples. They seem to routinely delay payments, or pay lower amounts than promised. They offer you advice on how to lie on the phone to the credit card reps. There is no transparency around why some of us are making $25k and some $300 per year on the same number of cards. Prices appear to be secretly negotiable. The tax reporting is kind of on the honor system. We know that some of the AUs are buying slots with stolen credit card numbers. The whole thing is very slightly shady, right? I mean I'm still doing it, I'm just not ignoring the warning signs here.