Part of your decision should figure in your work vs what you get back.
Likely, you'll be going to the place to clean/repair between rentals. I have friends who did this thinking "oh, I get to have a nice place on Cape Cod to vacation for free and renters will pay for it" which became "all the times I'd like to be there are rented and I really can't afford to let the rents go if I want to pay for it so I guess I'm going to sun myself on the beach in November when it's 38 degrees out". Since you already own it, you don't have the buy in costs. But you also don't have to go at all between times you're there for vacations. Figure the extra tax figuring work into all of this. For either tax or cleaning/repairs, if you don't do it yourself, they are expenses. Some you can write off, I guess.
I like to compare to a complete sell off. Now you have money you can put into index funds. You no longer have to go clean after someone else, chase rent payment or puzzle over taxes (or higher insurance costs....or re-mortgage to a rental).