PTF, as I have a second property we are considering renting in the future - renting it wouldn't have been considered before MMM - now I am considering it. (DH is not mustachian.) I will answer the questions as best I can.
1. Owned for 5 1/2 years - we go 1-2X per month (long weekends in the winter), 3-4 weeks in the Summer (Memorial Day week, 4th of July week, Last week of July, and One week mid August). We also do a few other 3 day weekends in the Summer.
2. Put 20% down, 4.6% interest rate. Completely paid off last April. Currently cash flowing a basement remodel this Spring.
3. No (but I'm sure we would if we rent it).
4. Craigslist for most other than mattresses....those we got new ones at our regular house and took the old ones out there.
5. 4 bedrooms/2 bathrooms
6. Lake community
7. Annual expenses - $7,500 including boat, boat dock, club fees (many amenities). Future rents only expected to cover 1/2 of expense.
8. It was a foreclosure - less than the price of a car $55K...and came with 2 buildable lots. The house had previously sold for over $160K. It has required $25K of renovations. Expecting another $15-20K for the basement renovation which we will cash flow. Recent appraisals are $145K for the house, and $10K for each of the lots.
9. Distance from main home is 1 hour and 45 minutes with a bathroom break.
For what it's worth, I feel like so far ours has been a money pit. When you consider the $7,500 annual expenses (=$40K of carrying costs for the past 5 1/2 yeras) and all the sweat and tears that have gone into the place (and it still needs more work). But we look forward to this being our eventual "FIRE house" in 4-6 years and at that point $620/month for housing sounds extremely affordable as a main home and hopefully $300/month after rentals, so we are keeping it for now. We plan this for our FIRE home for the first 10-15 years of early retirement - after that being closer to better medical facilities will be more important.