We bought this condo 3.5 years ago in a HCOL area. Just finished fixing up a few things and getting it ready to rent. We close on a new property in mid-September; looking for a renter to move in October 1.
Market Value: 160,000
Original Purchase price: 150,000
Original Mortgage Amount: 120,000
Interest Rate: 3.875
Mortgage Term: 30yr
Term remaining: 26.5
Amount remaining on mortgage: 109,856.93
Deferred maintenance notes: Furnace is 17 years old -- have been saving since moving in for a replacement; have $700 set aside for this currently.
Anything else special or unique in regards to the numbers of the property: Had two special assessments already this year totaling $2,427. Located in an area I fully believe will gentrify/appreciate in the next 5 years. We replaced the washer/dryer at the beginning of 2019 ($2,250).
Monthly outflows:
P&I: 564.28
Taxes/Ins: 275.82
HOA: 268
CapEx: 25 (300/yr)
Repairs: 16.67 (200/yr)
= ~1,134
Projected monthly inflow: 1,500
Cash flow: 366
I'm able to afford this condo's outflows plus my new property without adjusting my other savings rates/spending -- I've heard the horror stories in this tenant-friendly city of tenants who don't pay and can't be evicted for a year so this was a crucial data point for me as a new landlord. We're moving a few blocks away so plan to self-manage. I've sort of overestimated this rental market right now. I've had ~12 showings, 6 of which were good options, but zero people have actually put in an application. The number of respondents I'm getting makes me think the price is okay but I still lowered it to 1,450. We're thinking of dropping it to 1,400 to be 100% sure that we'll have someone in by October 1, but this starts to get close enough to "break even" per month that it worries me.
At $1,400 per month as the first year's rent, does that push this to "bad deal" territory? Was it to begin with?