Call an Independent Agent. I don't know your state, but in mine, 80% of insurance is sold through an Independent. They can write insurance from lots of companies and can price compare and probably can tell you without even checking who will be cheapest.
My son did the online quoting when he got his first car. Then he called Geico to "spend 15 minutes and save 15%". Then he called my independent who recommended the same company I'm with. His rate with them is exactly 1/3 what Geico is. I'd love if you bought Geico as I hold a bunch of Berkshire Hathaway stock.
And no, I'm not an insurance anything. I'm an engineer.