Wenchsenior wrote :
<< It is ironic how much critics disliked it...before anyone actually SAW it, it has a lot of Oscar buzz (b/c of the source material). They had all kinds of complaints, but most related to the lead performance and the 'unfilmable' nature of the novel (adaptation missing all the richness and character complexity). A lot of them also objected to its structure. So when it actually came out, the Oscar buzz stopped like a switch turned off. And then it bombed at the box office, too, though audiences seemed to respond to it better than critics.
ETA: I was skeptical that I would like any adaptation of it b/c I couldn't fathom how they could do justice to the INCREDIBLE character of Boris, but I was excited when Ralph Fiennes was initially cast as the art dealer (later replaced by Jeff Wright, I believe). I'll probably watch some of this if I ever happen across it on cable, just as a matter of curiosity. >>
I plugged my DVD player into my other VCR and it now works properly!
I watched the rest of The Goldfinch. I still liked it. I must say there were some unbelievable scenes where the good guys escape from the Russian Mafia in NYC.
Other than that, no big complaints.
You mention the character Boris. In the movie he is portrayed as a selfish but intelligent lout when young, then a caring and guilt-ridden person a few years later, when he meets the main character again unexpectedly, after having stolen the painting. I found him to be unlikable throughout.
One of the reasons I liked it is that it tied together all the flashbacks logically. Things made sense.
I thought the acting was very good, but there weren't any memorable scenes, any 'terrific' scenes, for me.
I think my favorite character in the movie was the main character's fiancee. She is duplicitous, but I liked her character anyway, since she is believable, and well acted.
My next movie, this one on videotape, will be 'The Clearing' with Robert Redford and Willem Dafoe, which I have seen before. I know there are some great scenes in that movie!