What does she need to use them for?
I'm not clear quite what you're looking for, but if the toes aspect isn't important, you may want to search for "robeez" on ebay. They are lightweight leather shoes made for little ones that provide a bit of protection and anti-skid without being heavy, clunky, or hard to put on.
I kept my kid in rubber-footed "sleepers" at that age and don't think he wore shoes much, but I may misremember. Our first shoes were the robeez (which we really didn't use much, but lots of kids/parents love them) and a pair of little Crocs (the traditional style), which got a TON of wear. I've given away the robeez, but I still have the Crocs :) .