Author Topic: How much financial support are you going to provide for your adult children?  (Read 34816 times)

livinglife

  • 5 O'Clock Shadow
  • *
  • Posts: 9
This thread has been a very interesting read! We are pondering these same questions as we try to figure out what our expenses will be as they get older.

Re: Vehicles

When I first got my license in high school, my parents provided me with an old beater vehicle to drive (hand-me-down), but I had to pay for gas. They covered insurance until I graduated high school. After that it was on me, so I opted not to take the vehicle to college.

I'm not sure what we'll end up doing. Our current vehicles are old enough that they do not have a lot of the safety features that I would like our kids to have in their vehicles. So we may opt to get vehicle instead of just giving them our current cars. I think at a minimum I want them to have a backup camera. My oldest is 12, so we've got a bit of time.

Re: How much financial support after they become adults

Right now we're leaning towards the approach my parents took-- They told me they would provide 50k (in 2002 money). They explained that their hope was it would be used for college and living expenses, but how far it went would be totally up to me and anything remaining was mine to keep. I'm a maximizer by nature, so this was very incentivizing. I began attending college while in high school (PSEO), allowing me to get two years of college for free. Then, I opted to go to an in-state school where I received hefty scholarships. I worked throughout college and took as many credits per semester as I could (because the first 12 credits were the most expensive each semester, and any beyond that were discounted). In the end, I graduated with my Master's Degree at age 21 and had only $15,000 in loans.

That 50k was it. They didn't pay any of my bills, buy any clothes, take me on vacations, or what have you. I was fully financially on my own the moment I had access to the 50k.

I really appreciated this approach in part because of how clear-cut the line of financial separation was. There was no ambiguity over who would be paying for what anymore. This is in contrast to DH's parents who never had the conversation with their kids, and as a result still end up footing the bills for his sister (who is mid thirties and earns more than both of them combined). They grumble to us about this all the time, but of course the one they need to be talking to is the sister.

Re: Have you accounted for this in your FIRE budget

This is exactly where I am right now. I'm trying to figure out what/how/how much support we'll provide over the years. I like the idea of doing a clear cut total, similar to what my parents did, since that seems to be the easiest to budget.

Re: Do you feel like your parents should have given you more financial support

No, with a caveat. I think they way my parents managed those early years of adulthood really worked out well. It encouraged me to be mindful of spending and aware of the true cost of each of my choices.

Fast forward to the present, and I am nearing 40 and they are mid to upper 70s. My parents were solidly middle class earners, my mom working in education and my dad held a blue collar job. They were frugal and intentional, managing to retire at 57, and have now accumulated quite a sizeable nest egg that continues to grow each year. At their request, my sibling and I have attended their financial estate planning meetings so we know just how dandy they're doing. They could double their annual spending and still have a growing portfolio.

With this in mind, there have been some times I have wished they would do an early inheritance. The money would be far more helpful to us now than it will be in (hopefully) 20 years when they pass. By that point, I sure as heck hope we're already FI. Sure, it'll be nice to know there is a cushion for us in the future, but it sure feels like it would be more useful to us right now.

We'll see how things are going when the time comes, but right now I am envisioning meting out my inheritance to my children once I receive it. I hope to be in a position to no longer need it for myself. But I don't plan for or say anything of this to my kids, as it'll totally depend on if I feel like they're making smart choices or not at the time. I'm not interested in helping them to buy a bigger house than they need or a fancy boat.

Kay-Ell

  • Stubble
  • **
  • Posts: 156
  • Semi-retired in 2017
I have an 11 year old with ADHD who likes school but struggles sometimes. At her current age she isn’t sure she wants to go to college which I feel is a fair topic to really evaluate before dropping that kind of time and money. Motivation to do hard things can be a struggle for neurodivergent people. I want to make sure I’m helping motivate her to do hard things, but not forcing her down a specific path that may not be rewarding for her. My current plan is to have 100k available for her to utilize, under my direction, in her early adult years. That number is based off of 4 years of in state, state school, but I’m not married to her going down that route. I also want to encourage her to get various part time summer or after school jobs as she gets older. She’s one of those people who has to experience the rewards of her effort first hand before she finds the internal motivation to apply herself. Which can put her in a difficult chicken/egg situation. But I do think she’d gain a lot of confidence and motivation through earning her own money, having her own financial goals and keeping her own schedule.

Providing her with a hand-me-down car feels like a given. Giving her the option to stay at home or come back home in the early part of adulthood also feels like a given. I understand not all parents are in the position to do that but I am, and can’t think of a good reason not to help my literal child when she needs it.

One of the areas I’m actually really concerned about for young people in general, not just mine, is how they will ever be able to afford a home. Even rent is so outrageous compared to wages, I don’t understand how young people are supposed to manage it. My first apartment was $1000 in 2007 and the same apartment is $3000 now. My first full time, entry level job was paying $14/hr in 2007. That same job starts at $16-$18/hr now. Make that make sense. So while I wouldn’t normally consider myself someone who thinks parents should buy a first home for their adult children, I can absolutely see myself finding creative ways to invest in real estate sooner than later on her behalf. I can even imagine a scenario where I downsize into something smaller and let her and her future family live in our current home. It’s just hard for me to see how anyone, no matter how intelligent and hard working they may be, works and saves for a home without some huge strokes of luck from somewhere. As long as I’m in a position to be one of those strokes of luck for my daughter, I don’t see why I would choose not to be.

MaybeBabyMustache

  • Walrus Stache
  • *******
  • Posts: 6744
    • My Wild Ride to FI
@Kay-Ell - as the parent of a 19 year old with ADHD, I can say that your approach makes sense, and plan to have more ups & downs, trials & errors than you might expect of a neurotypical kid. I think DS19 is going to transfer from the four year school he was at, and try a community college in the fall, which is okay with us. They do really need to try things, fail & then learn how they can adapt themselves & their learning to do things differently next time. Sometimes more than once. It can be hard, and frustrating, but we have definitely spent a lot more on DS19 than DS18, between tutoring, therapy, etc. We will continue to pay for therapy for as long as he wants to go.