For diversifying, and for getting high dividend, why not pick a high dividend focused index fund, instead of only 5 stocks? This is a good post on the MMM blog that talks about it:
http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2012/01/02/guest-posting-the-dividend-aristocrats/It specifically mentions SDY. This fund specifically picks only stocks that have increased their dividends for the past 25 years, every year. I think that's pretty good. The vanguard equivalent looks to be the high dividend yield index (VYM), or VIG as already mentioned.
If you still want to just do a few stocks, and not an index fund, I'd simply look at the holdings of these funds, and find the ones that overlap, such as johnson and johnson, chevron, at&t, etc., and go with those.
@brewer12345 STON has a 10% yield?! Sounds great, but how sustainable is that? Or how long has it been that way? Or rather, why is it that high? Curious.