New York is among the highest state taxes.
I would say, if you are in a super low tax situation now, you should go Roth.
If you are in say, Texas now, then you would have Zero state tax. So 15% and 0% state = awesome.
If you then plan to live in New York later, and have plenty of income from your gigantic investments, then Roth is looking good.
But if you are in New York right now, but will move somewhere lower later, like retiring in Texas, that would not be the case.
How old are you now?
This matters because if you are very young, then post FIRE, your stash has a very long time to grow. Which increases your chances of hitting 70 1/2 with a boat load of money (when you need to start taking mandatory withdraws; "RMD").