Author Topic: Case Study - $3M Investment bucketing plan for 49yo.  (Read 2568 times)

Much Fishing to Do

  • Handlebar Stache
  • *****
  • Posts: 1141
Case Study - $3M Investment bucketing plan for 49yo.
« on: September 04, 2020, 09:05:01 AM »
I will likely FIRE in the next year or so at the age of 49.  I work from home (even before Covid) and prob average about 15 hrs/wk now, but its not a consistent 15hrs but rather fluctuates a lot anywhere from 0 hr week to the occasional 40 hour wk (there are variable projects that I need to manage when they are running, and there’s not a lot of heads up as to when they begin and end).  The pay is great (the 15 hrs/wk average after taxes is about $10k/mth, which is pretty equal to what we spend), and I like the people I manage and the person directly over me, but there is plenty of aggravation that comes with it, and the unpredictability of the day to day does retract a lot from the benefit of the reduced overall hours.  My wife (47) has been a stay at home mom for about 15 years now and will likely not seek full time work in the future.  As the kids got a bit older she got into community stuff and currently has an elected part-time position that pays about $5k per year.  I’m sure she’ll try to keep that position or similar one as long as she can as it’s the right amount of work for her and she really enjoys it.

My investment & spending plan in FIRE has developed a lot over time, and it has morphed into mostly a kind of bucket approach that I like.  I just thought I’d throw it all out there for any thoughts/concerns/input/suggestions etc anyone cares to share.  Thanks for your time.

Overall Net worth is about $4M. 

Outside of the investment portfolio is:

$320k -- Paid for house. We’ve been here for almost 20 years now and I doubt we’ll move, though I can imagine becoming snowbirds once all the kids have left the nest.  Made a lot of improvements on it since we bought it to turn it into a very nice and comfortable home in a nice “medium” COL area.  We checked out some of the most expensive homes in the area a couple years back to see what was available (and for me to see if I needed to factor a larger home into the FIRE plan) and we just weren’t that impressed with what we saw out there that would cost twice as much or more than our current home is worth.  Its hard to beat having wonderful neighbors, which we currently  do.
$380k – 529s for my 3 kids.  Each had $130k in their accounts, which is the price of the state flagship university Tuition Room and Board for 4 years.  The first has started college.  The deal I made with him when he started looking at schools was that the money in that account I consider basically his, that this is probably the only real money he’ll get from me until he gets his inheritance which is hopefully when he’s old and grey, and that any money left over in the account he could have when he holds a degree and a job and no debt (other than a mortgage).  He made some smart choices and got some scholarship money etc, so is on a track to have a marketable bachelors and masters degree and should still have about $40k or so left over in his account.  I don’t know if I’ll just distribute that to him from the 529 or pay it to him separately and get the 529 money in there.  Only about a third of that money is earnings so the tax + penalty hit would only be about (15%+10%)*(1/3rd $40k) = ~$3k, so I’m not really that concerned about having ‘oversaved’ in these accounts.  I do need to look into the whole scholarship thing that has reduced his need and see if that means I can take some of this out without penalty to make the hit even less? And do I need to do each year of the scholarship, etc?
$110k – Donor Advised Fund – I set this up and funded during a huge profit year I had in my business.  Between that tax bracket and the fact I contributed some of my highest gaining equities, and that the charitable deduction is likely worthless to me in FIRE, I feel like I’ve doubled my future giving on that one move.  Our charitable donations in FIRE will come from this.  We’ll probably spend about 6%-7% of its actual balance each year so we spend it down over time but not too quickly or completely.
$150k – Half share in wife’s childhood home that she recently inherited.  Currently rent it out, and it pays for itself, but not a lot more, which is why I just put it in this ‘non-investment’ area to pretty much ignore it for income/asset purposes.  She and her sister own it and this just seems a good set-up for now while they figure out what they want to do with it.

Investment Portfolio

$3.1M Total with overall about 75/10/15 equities/bonds/cash allocation I just finished migrating to.  My plan is to just move $10k each month into our spending account (our current average spending, we could definitely maintain a happy SOL on less and adjust our spending downward if need be at any point, I just don’t see the need to at the start).  Again this has kinda naturally morphed into a bucket type plan, or at least that’s the easiest way for me to visualize it, and I do a lot of modeling in FIRECalc and the like on both the whole of investments and each part.

Ages 49-51 – First 3 years of FIRE I plan to just spend from the big pile of cash in the taxable account.  $240k should cover it as the dividends thrown off by the taxable account would add the other $120k required over the 3 years.  I really like the idea of not worrying about touching the investments during these first few years as I get situated with RE, how this kinda creates a sorta reverse equity glidepath going into RE by spending down half the cash in my portfolio, and I did a ton of modeling that just showed how little affect having this additional cash for a few years would affect my overall success rate, end balances, etc.  I also think this will make it easier for me to see what I can do to get my AGI down for both ACA and FAFSA reasons.  I’m researching that now and see neat things like how you can contribute to a HSA and get the above the line deduction even without earned income, etc).  I think with the ACA subsidy in RE I could cut as much as $1k/mth off of my current healthcare expenses.  I do need to also look at moving money into a Roth from traditional tax free, which will be a competing interest with this AGi reduction plan, so I think it’ll be interesting figuring out best overall strategies.

Ages 52-65 – So due to most of my career of me not having access to a 401k at work, and then having a couple huge years self-employed at the end where I was able to save many many times more than what my solo 401k would take, most of my investments are in a taxable account.  I envision this being the main source of income for this period, though if it makes sense at some point in it to sell/draw something from the retirement accounts I’ll of course do that.  Not including the $240k in the above starting cash bucket, its about $1.9M.  So hopefully that’ll at least grow with inflation or more until I start using it, and unless markets are extremely horrible and I net a loss, there should be investments still left in it when I hit 65 and probably a significant amount.  The $240k of cash in this bucket I intend to be used as the income source whenever markets are down over 20% from their highs, as at least in my life that’s been long enough for big market drops to recover fairly well, and given this is a 14 year period I expect at least one drop to happen that is large enough to concern me.  Not sure but I doubt I’ll balance back into the cash after it gets used for this purpose, so again it’s kinda another small reverse equity glidepath.

Ages 66+ -- I kinda see this as a different financial time in life.  I’d probably collect SS around this time, for the two of us it would be around $35k/year, though once we get to this point we’ll of course consider the options of waiting, etc.  We’d now be on Medicare.  The kids will all be fully grown and I assume any money we’d be giving them at this point would be because markets did well and we have excess.  I have about $575k in IRAs and $350k in Roth stuff that of course hopefully will grow a lot in real dollars by the time I get to these.  The allocation of these investments are currently about 90/10 equity/bonds, and fairly small & mid cap overweighted (esp. the Roth).

Even though I know I should, given our good health, and that there is the both of us, it’s really hard for me to picture us still being around past 80, as we don’t see evidence of that in our family history.  Whenever I run calculations and see failures after this age I don’t really take them seriously, but I think probably the more justifiable reason to not be concerned is given we have so much ‘extra’ in our planned budget we could always cut at any point if need be, and that maybe our spending will naturally reduce over time.  If our 52-66 bucket does well and we still have a lot of that available for 66+, maybe we’ll just wait to 70 to take SS as a kinda of longevity insurance. I had looked at so-called “longevity insurance” products in the past, but given current interest rates they sure are costly so I haven’t really considered them.  There is also just the fact that the kind of horrible market returns that would make longevity insurance necessary also seem to be the kind of conditions that would make them potentially fail lead me to not consider them.  I guess at some point we should get LTC insurance, let me know at what age that seems smart to do given costs and length of time before need.

LightTripper

  • Handlebar Stache
  • *****
  • Posts: 2433
  • Location: London, UK
  • Rural Londoner. Lazy workaholic. Confused.
Re: Case Study - $3M Investment bucketing plan for 49yo.
« Reply #1 on: September 04, 2020, 09:57:13 AM »
Hi!  I'm on a similar age/plan/stache to you, so keen to follow along (even though I'm in the UK so all the tax, SS and health stuff is a bit different, and have younger kids).  I'm considering going to what sounds like a rather similar working arrangement to the one you have now, and anticipate all the problems you have with it (plus a work environment that is rather toxic - which sounds like is not a problem for you!) so I am wondering about just ramping down to zero rather quickly.

Anyway, look forward to following along as you work things out.  I am currently probably under-invested (so like you should be able to live off cash for the first few years of retirement) and have also been starting to read about the equity glide-path stuff you mentioned - though I want to do some more research on that in the next few months - but plan to do most of my retirement investment planning in retirement (when I have time!) so that feels a bit hairy ... but it's a big enough pot that hopefully I have wiggle room to make a few mistakes.  Your pots plan sounds like a good approach!

terran

  • Magnum Stache
  • ******
  • Posts: 3806
Re: Case Study - $3M Investment bucketing plan for 49yo.
« Reply #2 on: September 04, 2020, 02:40:52 PM »
It kind of sounds like you're conflating asset allocation/glide paths, spending/withdrawal, and tax strategies in ways that might be suboptimal with your bucket approach. I think this is pretty common with bucket strategies as it creates a kind of mental accounting that ignores the fact that money is fungible (doesn't matter where it comes from since a dollar is a dollar). For example, while you might want to spend from taxable that doesn't mean your cash/bonds should be in taxable rather than tax advantaged, and while you might not want to spend from tax advantaged that doesn't mean you shouldn't do Roth conversions to at least fill the standard deduction.

Here are some resources I would suggest you take a look at (I'm sure you're familiar with at least some of it, but we could all use a refresher):

Much Fishing to Do

  • Handlebar Stache
  • *****
  • Posts: 1141
Re: Case Study - $3M Investment bucketing plan for 49yo.
« Reply #3 on: September 05, 2020, 06:33:21 AM »
@LightTripper - Thanks, I've seen some of your posts before and have enjoyed them and found them interesting as we do seem to be similar in path.  I'm sorry your current place is a toxic one, you're tougher than me because back when I was in more toxic environments I was planning to LeanFire just to get the hell out, but as things changed it made it easier for me to keep earning and saving.  I have no doubt if my immediate supervisor or my no. 2 left the company tomorrow I would 'virtually' follow them out the door, so that's obviously how big a difference that support makes to me continuing.

@terran - Gotcha.  For the most part I think I've allocated things in the accounts I've intended to, and the fact they've fallen into the chronological spending buckets they have is just kinda a coincidence.  But your point is taken and I'm sure this is not always the case.  I admit the bucketing visual can distort the whole and has made me make assumptions and then mistakes before in modeling (e.g. I was one time modeing the $1.9M taxable bucket as its own entity for that age range to determine success rates/median ending portfolios etc with different allocations, and I only then realized that the results were not gonna be accurate because I am using the dividends from that bucket to fund the previous all cash bucket), so I'll make sure to give this all a clean view without the buckets as well.  These are some great resources, a couple I don't think I've hit upon before, thanks!

reeshau

  • Magnum Stache
  • ******
  • Posts: 2566
  • Location: Houston, TX
  • Former locations: Detroit, Indianapolis, Dublin
Re: Case Study - $3M Investment bucketing plan for 49yo.
« Reply #4 on: September 05, 2020, 08:28:48 AM »
I, too, am in a similar position, although I was just "retired" from my job, so taking time off but not sure if I am well and truly done, and just turned 49.  We have one young one, so quite a bit more to go before an empty nest, but similar stache, even down to the paid-for house.



I do need to look into the whole scholarship thing that has reduced his need and see if that means I can take some of this out without penalty to make the hit even less? And do I need to do each year of the scholarship, etc?
Yes, this is a thing.  I am still some time away from the consideration, so I don't know what sort of time limits or withdrawal matching may be needed, but do look into it.

Quote
Ages 49-51 – First 3 years of FIRE I plan to just spend from the big pile of cash in the taxable account.  $240k should cover it as the dividends thrown off by the taxable account would add the other $120k required over the 3 years.  I really like the idea of not worrying about touching the investments during these first few years as I get situated with RE, how this kinda creates a sorta reverse equity glidepath going into RE by spending down half the cash in my portfolio, and I did a ton of modeling that just showed how little affect having this additional cash for a few years would affect my overall success rate, end balances, etc.  I also think this will make it easier for me to see what I can do to get my AGI down for both ACA and FAFSA reasons.  I’m researching that now and see neat things like how you can contribute to a HSA and get the above the line deduction even without earned income, etc).  I think with the ACA subsidy in RE I could cut as much as $1k/mth off of my current healthcare expenses.  I do need to also look at moving money into a Roth from traditional tax free, which will be a competing interest with this AGi reduction plan, so I think it’ll be interesting figuring out best overall strategies.

I was confused reading through this section.  You talk about AGI reduction, but also talk about living off the cash.  So, you could have an AGI of zero--which is not a good thing.  In addition to managing the ACA subsidy cliffs, you also don't want to fall into Medicaid territory (If such is your wont) or particular the gap between the two, if your state did not expand Medicaid.  I know you said you expected dividends, but what income do you really have to reduce?  I say this because I, too,, have a large cash float for living expenses for the next few years and plan to use Roth conversions to generate the AGI to get me up into ACA territory.

Much Fishing to Do

  • Handlebar Stache
  • *****
  • Posts: 1141
Re: Case Study - $3M Investment bucketing plan for 49yo.
« Reply #5 on: September 05, 2020, 03:01:36 PM »
I, too, am in a similar position, although I was just "retired" from my job, so taking time off but not sure if I am well and truly done, and just turned 49.  We have one young one, so quite a bit more to go before an empty nest, but similar stache, even down to the paid-for house.



I do need to look into the whole scholarship thing that has reduced his need and see if that means I can take some of this out without penalty to make the hit even less? And do I need to do each year of the scholarship, etc?
Yes, this is a thing.  I am still some time away from the consideration, so I don't know what sort of time limits or withdrawal matching may be needed, but do look into it.

Quote
Ages 49-51 – First 3 years of FIRE I plan to just spend from the big pile of cash in the taxable account.  $240k should cover it as the dividends thrown off by the taxable account would add the other $120k required over the 3 years.  I really like the idea of not worrying about touching the investments during these first few years as I get situated with RE, how this kinda creates a sorta reverse equity glidepath going into RE by spending down half the cash in my portfolio, and I did a ton of modeling that just showed how little affect having this additional cash for a few years would affect my overall success rate, end balances, etc.  I also think this will make it easier for me to see what I can do to get my AGI down for both ACA and FAFSA reasons.  I’m researching that now and see neat things like how you can contribute to a HSA and get the above the line deduction even without earned income, etc).  I think with the ACA subsidy in RE I could cut as much as $1k/mth off of my current healthcare expenses.  I do need to also look at moving money into a Roth from traditional tax free, which will be a competing interest with this AGi reduction plan, so I think it’ll be interesting figuring out best overall strategies.

I was confused reading through this section.  You talk about AGI reduction, but also talk about living off the cash.  So, you could have an AGI of zero--which is not a good thing.  In addition to managing the ACA subsidy cliffs, you also don't want to fall into Medicaid territory (If such is your wont) or particular the gap between the two, if your state did not expand Medicaid.  I know you said you expected dividends, but what income do you really have to reduce?  I say this because I, too,, have a large cash float for living expenses for the next few years and plan to use Roth conversions to generate the AGI to get me up into ACA territory.

Thanks.  My taxable account throws off $40k per year in dividends, and in some years also throws off LTCG distributions and the like that have driven it to more like $60k, so it seems like that would be amounts that go to AGI I think, and already getting into areas that might reduce my FAFSA and ACA help (I've noticed things like for the FAFSA not having to include your assets if below a certain income that I seem to be getting close to with just this).

I could be wrong with all this, as I obviosuly haven't looked into a lot of it.

ysette9

  • Walrus Stache
  • *******
  • Posts: 8930
  • Age: 2020
  • Location: Bay Area at heart living in the PNW
Re: Case Study - $3M Investment bucketing plan for 49yo.
« Reply #6 on: September 05, 2020, 04:33:55 PM »
Are your dividends qualified?

Much Fishing to Do

  • Handlebar Stache
  • *****
  • Posts: 1141
Re: Case Study - $3M Investment bucketing plan for 49yo.
« Reply #7 on: September 06, 2020, 06:53:57 AM »
Are your dividends qualified?

Around half.  My understanding is though those get the cap gains tax rate they still count toward the ACA MAGI, etc.

ysette9

  • Walrus Stache
  • *******
  • Posts: 8930
  • Age: 2020
  • Location: Bay Area at heart living in the PNW
Re: Case Study - $3M Investment bucketing plan for 49yo.
« Reply #8 on: September 06, 2020, 09:47:46 AM »
Are your dividends qualified?

Around half.  My understanding is though those get the cap gains tax rate they still count toward the ACA MAGI, etc.
According to a random article I found online, qualified dividends don’t count towards MAGI.

I found an online tax calculator to estimate what our federal taxes would be and just played around with different Roth conversion amounts and other income.

terran

  • Magnum Stache
  • ******
  • Posts: 3806
Re: Case Study - $3M Investment bucketing plan for 49yo.
« Reply #9 on: September 07, 2020, 07:25:30 AM »
Are your dividends qualified?

Around half.  My understanding is though those get the cap gains tax rate they still count toward the ACA MAGI, etc.
According to a random article I found online, qualified dividends don’t count towards MAGI.

I found an online tax calculator to estimate what our federal taxes would be and just played around with different Roth conversion amounts and other income.

No, I'm pretty sure all dividends would be included. In fact, even some investment income (like tax exempt interest) that isn't included in AGI is added back in for ACA MAGI: https://www.healthcare.gov/income-and-household-information/income/#magi

One thing you need to be careful of is that MAGI can be different for depending on the context (ACA subsidies vs IRA contribution eligibility for example).

EscapeVelocity2020

  • Magnum Stache
  • ******
  • Posts: 4824
  • Age: 50
  • Location: Houston
    • EscapeVelocity2020
Re: Case Study - $3M Investment bucketing plan for 49yo.
« Reply #10 on: September 07, 2020, 08:48:44 AM »
Very brave of you to put this all out there!  I’m in a similar position except maybe 2 years younger and one less child.  I have what you have in taxable in my 401k’s / pre-tax, so I’ll be doing more conversions .  Having that chunk in after-tax gives you more constraints (dividends and interest as income), but also more options around capital gains.

I’m on vacation and typing on a phone so I can’t get too technical.  Maybe have a look at I-Orp and fiddle with scenarios in Turbo Tax.  I’m planning on higher taxes (and enjoying the boost to after tax income in the near term), but that’s more of a gotcha for 401k/traditional and RMD’s.

Do you have any muni bonds or TIPS (inflation protected bonds)?  Might be worth a small allocation for added protection.
« Last Edit: September 07, 2020, 12:16:18 PM by EscapeVelocity2020 »

ysette9

  • Walrus Stache
  • *******
  • Posts: 8930
  • Age: 2020
  • Location: Bay Area at heart living in the PNW
Re: Case Study - $3M Investment bucketing plan for 49yo.
« Reply #11 on: September 07, 2020, 09:00:48 AM »
I am by far an expert on the MAGI calculation. I am going off of this article.

https://www.fiphysician.com/magi-calculation-deep-dive-for-irmaa-and-premium-aca-tax-credits/

“Next, line 3b include ordinary dividends. Qualified dividends are not included in MAGI calculation!  They stack on top of your ordinary income  when you are paying the Capital Gain and qualified dividend taxes, but let’s not worry about that right now.”

terran

  • Magnum Stache
  • ******
  • Posts: 3806
Re: Case Study - $3M Investment bucketing plan for 49yo.
« Reply #12 on: September 07, 2020, 09:12:52 AM »
I am by far an expert on the MAGI calculation. I am going off of this article.

https://www.fiphysician.com/magi-calculation-deep-dive-for-irmaa-and-premium-aca-tax-credits/

“Next, line 3b include ordinary dividends. Qualified dividends are not included in MAGI calculation!  They stack on top of your ordinary income  when you are paying the Capital Gain and qualified dividend taxes, but let’s not worry about that right now.”

From that link:
Quote
Next, line 3b include ordinary dividends. Qualified dividends are not included in MAGI calculation!  They stack on top of your ordinary income  when you are paying the Capital Gain and qualified dividend taxes, but let’s not worry about that right now.

This seems to be a misunderstanding of how ordinary and qualified dividends work. Technically they're correct that you wouldn't add qualified dividends from line 3a to the other income sources when calculating AGI, but that's only because qualified dividends are already included in ordinary dividends on line 3b. Ordinary dividends are made up both qualified and non-qualified dividends, so you would subtract line 3a from line 3b to find non-qualified dividends (which happens on the Qualified Dividends and Capital Gain Tax Worksheet). So qualified dividends are included in AGI (by virtue of ordinary dividends being included). Only if qualified dividends were later subtracted from AGI to arrive at ACA MAGI would they be excluded (which doesn't seem to be the case from what I found).

EscapeVelocity2020

  • Magnum Stache
  • ******
  • Posts: 4824
  • Age: 50
  • Location: Houston
    • EscapeVelocity2020
Re: Case Study - $3M Investment bucketing plan for 49yo.
« Reply #13 on: September 07, 2020, 10:55:29 PM »
So, once upon a time on the internet, there was a site called 'Bobs Financial Website' which had a series called 'Retire at the Pie Shop'.  Instead of these insipid monthly articles from bloggers, it was a real life retired guy that detailed out his withdrawal strategy and updated it annually.  This was back before pop up ads and people wanted to make money off of 'retirement'. 

Unfortunately, the tax and income game has changed significantly, but what I gathered in a general sense was that you, of course, take all of the dividend and interest income thrown off that covers your spend, then you sell any non-taxable (either equities that have small gains or bonds).  If you need more, sell long term capital gains, etc.

It was much more interesting seeing it in 'real time' (YOY) from an ER that does all his work in one day, and was very convincing that the 4% rule works.

These blogger guys and gals that do monthly updates are typically making 30+k/yr which skews their advice.
« Last Edit: September 07, 2020, 10:57:33 PM by EscapeVelocity2020 »

reeshau

  • Magnum Stache
  • ******
  • Posts: 2566
  • Location: Houston, TX
  • Former locations: Detroit, Indianapolis, Dublin
Re: Case Study - $3M Investment bucketing plan for 49yo.
« Reply #14 on: September 08, 2020, 07:49:10 AM »
So, once upon a time on the internet, there was a site called 'Bobs Financial Website' which had a series called 'Retire at the Pie Shop'.  Instead of these insipid monthly articles from bloggers, it was a real life retired guy that detailed out his withdrawal strategy and updated it annually.  This was back before pop up ads and people wanted to make money off of 'retirement'. 

Unfortunately, the tax and income game has changed significantly, but what I gathered in a general sense was that you, of course, take all of the dividend and interest income thrown off that covers your spend, then you sell any non-taxable (either equities that have small gains or bonds).  If you need more, sell long term capital gains, etc.

It was much more interesting seeing it in 'real time' (YOY) from an ER that does all his work in one day, and was very convincing that the 4% rule works.

These blogger guys and gals that do monthly updates are typically making 30+k/yr which skews their advice.

@EscapeVelocity2020 , this post seems more like a response to the "FIRE bloggers fizzling" thread.  But, to follow you down the rabbit hole, the Internet Archive does have Bob's archived.  Looks like it went dark in 2012.  Here was the latest version they grabbed:

https://web.archive.org/web/20120611031033/http://bobsfinancialwebsite.com/

EscapeVelocity2020

  • Magnum Stache
  • ******
  • Posts: 4824
  • Age: 50
  • Location: Houston
    • EscapeVelocity2020
Re: Case Study - $3M Investment bucketing plan for 49yo.
« Reply #15 on: September 08, 2020, 08:33:58 AM »
Yes, that was the site I was thinking of.  I don’t see the documentation of his strategy in action, but the bit that was interesting was how, after a good year in stocks say, he took those gains to rebalance his AA and fund his next year’s spending.

It was true ‘living off of passive income’ versus a lot of ER bloggers that never take money out and are ‘surprised’ that their net worth goes up after ‘retirement’.  Yes, it can go up, but if you are living on blog or earned income, it ‘should’ go up over time.

Not sure if there are any sites now like this one that go in to detail on truly living off of a portfolio.

Much Fishing to Do

  • Handlebar Stache
  • *****
  • Posts: 1141
Re: Case Study - $3M Investment bucketing plan for 49yo.
« Reply #16 on: September 08, 2020, 06:39:13 PM »
Very brave of you to put this all out there!  I’m in a similar position except maybe 2 years younger and one less child.  I have what you have in taxable in my 401k’s / pre-tax, so I’ll be doing more conversions .  Having that chunk in after-tax gives you more constraints (dividends and interest as income), but also more options around capital gains.

I’m on vacation and typing on a phone so I can’t get too technical.  Maybe have a look at I-Orp and fiddle with scenarios in Turbo Tax.  I’m planning on higher taxes (and enjoying the boost to after tax income in the near term), but that’s more of a gotcha for 401k/traditional and RMD’s.

Do you have any muni bonds or TIPS (inflation protected bonds)?  Might be worth a small allocation for added protection.

Thanks!  I've never tried I-Orp so will give it a spin.

A few years ago I looked thru all the bond/bond fund/TIPs options and just didn't like a lot of what I was seeing and why currently it was much of an advantage over just having cash, so I ended up with just a 10% bond allocation, a fair amount of cash and none of this other stuff.  I really should take a another look, esp. now that it seems likely cash will pay zero for quite some time.

EscapeVelocity2020

  • Magnum Stache
  • ******
  • Posts: 4824
  • Age: 50
  • Location: Houston
    • EscapeVelocity2020
Re: Case Study - $3M Investment bucketing plan for 49yo.
« Reply #17 on: September 08, 2020, 07:33:34 PM »
Very brave of you to put this all out there!  I’m in a similar position except maybe 2 years younger and one less child.  I have what you have in taxable in my 401k’s / pre-tax, so I’ll be doing more conversions .  Having that chunk in after-tax gives you more constraints (dividends and interest as income), but also more options around capital gains.

I’m on vacation and typing on a phone so I can’t get too technical.  Maybe have a look at I-Orp and fiddle with scenarios in Turbo Tax.  I’m planning on higher taxes (and enjoying the boost to after tax income in the near term), but that’s more of a gotcha for 401k/traditional and RMD’s.

Do you have any muni bonds or TIPS (inflation protected bonds)?  Might be worth a small allocation for added protection.

Thanks!  I've never tried I-Orp so will give it a spin.

A few years ago I looked thru all the bond/bond fund/TIPs options and just didn't like a lot of what I was seeing and why currently it was much of an advantage over just having cash, so I ended up with just a 10% bond allocation, a fair amount of cash and none of this other stuff.  I really should take a another look, esp. now that it seems likely cash will pay zero for quite some time.

I have VAIPX and VWIUX.  Not great returns, but decent yield, and more correlated with equities than I would like, but still somewhat helping diversification and cash flow.  The nice thing about being 'ahead of the game' is that you can stop swinging for the fences and focus on staying on base.

Much Fishing to Do

  • Handlebar Stache
  • *****
  • Posts: 1141
Re: Case Study - $3M Investment bucketing plan for 49yo.
« Reply #18 on: September 09, 2020, 06:33:21 AM »

The nice thing about being 'ahead of the game' is that you can stop swinging for the fences and focus on staying on base.

Yep, I completely agree with that and is my only real answer when someone asks why in the world I have a half-million in cash.  I'll definitely look into these other products.