Well the problem is that it isn’t going to be all the stimulatory. Because higher income earners don’t spend it, they’re more likely to invest it in shares or property.
So not only will there be higher debt/deficit, it won’t do that much for the real economy. Austerity will basically double down on that bad bet (see Europe).
We might celebrate a bigger personal bank balance with those tax cuts, but there’s not a lot of point to that right now at least not from my perspective. The past 6 months I’ve had pay rises and net worth growth of over $100k. People like you and I are doing it just fine in comparison to everyone else. Privilege is the word you don’t want to hear but it does apply.
Please stop seeing yourself as persecuted for paying tax. Most people would happily trade places to pay tax instead of collecting unemployment measures because the government has closed their industry.
I don't think I'm persecuted, Marty. I'd just like a bit of fair analysis from the media and from politicians. I don't envy the poor or the ones who lost their jobs but I do think the lazy middle class in this country has it so fucking good and yet they don't even appreciate it.
Coronavirus hits? Oh, let's throw away some money as "stimulus". Yeah, don't just give it to the poor, give it to the un-deserving middle class too. Give everyone a bit of stimulus. But not those who pay the most tax.
But then when tax time comes around, god forbid we proceed with the tax cuts that we'd already planned. The ones that address bracket creep, the elephant in the room.
But you know what, maybe it's infecting me too. I dropped my hours and income this year so that I'm just about hovering at the top tax bracket. I'm happier for it and I can still scrape by on a measly $180k a year.
If I could design a tax system I'd put a 90% estate tax (no need to transfer wealth to your kiddies - they never earned it), use the receipts to make 16 years of education free for everyone who wants it, and drop income tax down to a flat 15% rate. I reckon it could all be easily funded by the big punitive estate tax :-) And that'd be damn fair. Fairer than the current system which punishes enterprise and also, strangely, rewards intergenerational laziness.