Thanks for the feedback! We currently have TIAA-CREF and Fidelity. I have TIAA-CREF, in part because it was the only option when I started my career. Its performance has been lackluster, which is probably one of the reasons a lot of universities and colleges are getting rid of it.
Jenny, you mentioned a link to MMM recommended funds; could you point me to where I might find that?
And yes, more choices do sometimes create confusion and discomfort. Some of our faculty are completely unhinged that we're getting rid of TIAA-CREF, even though the reason is, in part, because we want to go to a single monitor and TIAA-CREF won't allow monitoring from another company. I suspect some of the angst is due to fears of being overwhelmed with choices.
At any rate, thanks again! We should actually be getting the list today, so this is perfect timing!