The Money Mustache Community

Learning, Sharing, and Teaching => Ask a Mustachian => Topic started by: LovinPSDs on March 20, 2018, 07:27:38 PM

Title: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: LovinPSDs on March 20, 2018, 07:27:38 PM
So we're thinking about moving very close to my work... Current drive is 31 miles each way.. I know I know.  The place we'd move to is a relatively rural small community with not a ton of houses available, especially in the 175-250K range where we'd likely be.  So we've thought about building a house, trying our best to keep it reasonable 3/2 + a nice garage for tinkering.

My real question is, what type of mustachian things would you put in a new house.. assuming you had a clean slate.  I'm thinking like Tesla solar roof, attic fan, high efficiency AC, on demand water heater... Perhaps wood burning fireplace for ambiance that also adds heat in the winter.  Just want to kick ideas around!! What do ya'll think?! 

Ps. If the move happens I'm total getting an E-Bike!
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: Laura33 on March 20, 2018, 08:40:39 PM
I would think design before “stuff to add” - things like designed for the climate, oriented for solar gain (or not), designing the structure to maintain a tight envelope, excellent insulation, etc. 

On the fun stuff, I’d want radiant floor heating where possible, but especially in bathrooms, because I find I feel warmer with radiant heat - forced air just never feels as warm (she says, snuggled next to her radiant space heater).  And a pellet stove for heating + flame + a little of that wood smoke smell - again, very efficient heating.  Definitely a whole-house fan if the climate supports it (when we were in CO, I almost never had to turn on the AC, because it would cool off so much at night that the fan would just cool it down in about 15 minutes).  I would also love to design a water reuse system, like they do in the earthships, so I could reuse grey water appropriately. 

And, yeah, some version of renewable energy suited for the climate.
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: affordablehousing on March 20, 2018, 08:45:39 PM
If I wanted to keep it mustachian, I would definitely avoid gizmos like tesla, high efficiency ac, stuff like that. On demand water heaters are useful depending on your usage style, number of people, water condition, etc. Good for small households making infrequent water uses, not great for large households, continually using water, with old pipes or hard water that will wear out filters constantly. A truly smart mustachian setup I think would anticipate that you would live there for 100 years, and do all the maintenance yourself, so work hard to make all the systems serviceable, i.e. don't bury pipes in concrete that might break, don't run electrical in inaccessible tiny crawlspaces, in general, futureproof your house so you know and can easily, fix everything yourself. Also, way cheaper than any gizmo stuff is insulation. A high end furnace is expensive and fragile, lots of insulation is cheap and durable.

And to make it mustachian, get all the materials for rock bottom, starting with the most size particular, i.e. buy leftover windows first, design openings to their size later.
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: Lady SA on March 20, 2018, 09:51:16 PM
These are my favorite ideas:

--wainscoting removable wall panels so you can get at the electrical wiring/pipes to do repairs or add/remove outlets without destroying walls
--use standard window sizes to cut down on costs
--orienting house to take advantage of sun--windows and overhangs calculated in such a way that the angle of the sun in summer doesn't enter the house, but when it is lower in the sky in winter, it does enter the home to warm it up. Use of a thermal sink like concrete to heat up during the day and provide passive warmth overnight.
--super insulated envelope
--earth insulation, burying part of the house underground to take advantage of natural soil temperatures keeping the home temperate.
--built-in sauna!
--I love how earthships have an integrated greenhouse that passively heats/cools the house and provides food. I don't know if I would want to go all-in with the earthship idea, but I like the idea of having an attached greenhouse that has a greywater aquaponics system and composting system, so we can harvest fruits and veggies year round.
--use of prefabricated panels (cheaper, more insulated, faster to install, built in a controlled environment)
--metal roof. they are much better these days. Cheapish and last a really long time.
--I'd like to add solar panels or other passive energy converting systems to either cut our bills down or be able to put net energy back into the grid and get paid!
--well thought out layout and travel corridors. Thinking about how you use the home most often--bringing in groceries, it's nice if your kitchen is close to where you park your car/bike. It's nice to have your kitchen open to the living area so you can chat and watch tv while you cook. I like the idea of having half the house be the "public" area and the other half "private", with bedrooms and bathrooms.
--design with accessibility in mind, so you can age in place. Think about when you need assistance getting around with a wheelchair or walker. Wider hallways, pedestal sinks, single story, etc
--focusing on small things you can do to make your house easier to clean/maintain. I really enjoyed this thread: https://forum.mrmoneymustache.com/ask-a-mustachian/advice-for-making-your-home-interior-easier-to-clean-and-maintain/

Basically, I want to design the house in such a way to take advantage of efficient, passive heating/cooling as much as possible, while also focusing on future maintainability (being able to easily fix/update things without having to rip things out) and passively supplementing our normal consumption (food or energy). I also want a house to be easy to live in and not require much upkeep--I want to spend my time on adventures, not cleaning!
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: middo on March 20, 2018, 10:18:21 PM
If you are wanting to reduce longer term energy costs, then I would get:
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: kei te pai on March 21, 2018, 12:27:42 AM
Before anything went in, I would concentrate on not building any bigger than you need. Buy clever designed space to suit your family and climate, before size.
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: chouchouu on March 21, 2018, 03:42:15 AM
Forgot ac,  our apartment has the living areas orientated north and cross ventilation. The weekend reached 40 degrees Celsius and I still didn't need to turn on the ac, my little energy efficient Dyson fan was enough.

Put any fireplaces in the middle of the house, no point wasting all that energy by having one on an outside wall.
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: Morning Glory on March 21, 2018, 04:24:35 AM
Wait a minute here, are you saying the other houses in town are too cheap for you? What makes you think you need a house in the 175-250k price range? Please tell me that all the other houses are actually more expensive than this. Building a brand new house is almost never more cost effective than buying an existing one. You also don't want to have the most expensive house in your neighborhood when you try to sell.
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: MrUpwardlyMobile on March 21, 2018, 04:47:43 AM
Wait a minute here, are you saying the other houses in town are too cheap for you? What makes you think you need a house in the 175-250k price range? Please tell me that all the other houses are actually more expensive than this. Building a brand new house is almost never more cost effective than buying an existing one. You also don't want to have the most expensive house in your neighborhood when you try to sell.

I think OP was merely suggesting that housing stocks were mostly either above or below that range and that range is in the sweet spot for their wants and needs.  In my area, that range is the affordable condos and coops range and not house range. A 1 bedroom/1 bath coop is 160ish and that skimps on a lot of amenities some might call basic.
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: bluebelle on March 21, 2018, 06:39:26 AM
assuming you're in an area where basements are 'normal', I'd want a cold storage room, aka root cellar, aka cantina.  My mother had one when I was growing up, and I'm going to have one in the house we're going to build.  It's where all the home canned food went and the big bag of potatoes and onions etc.
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: Morning Glory on March 21, 2018, 06:59:35 AM
Wait a minute here, are you saying the other houses in town are too cheap for you? What makes you think you need a house in the 175-250k price range? Please tell me that all the other houses are actually more expensive than this. Building a brand new house is almost never more cost effective than buying an existing one. You also don't want to have the most expensive house in your neighborhood when you try to sell.

I think OP was merely suggesting that housing stocks were mostly either above or below that range and that range is in the sweet spot for their wants and needs.  In my area, that range is the affordable condos and coops range and not house range. A 1 bedroom/1 bath coop is 160ish and that skimps on a lot of amenities some might call basic.
OPs price range is not unreasonable for an MCOL, it is about the right price for a 3 bedroom where I live now. I read "small rural town" and thought of central IL where a pretty dang nice house can be had for less than 100k, so it is worth looking.
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: NV Teacher on March 21, 2018, 07:17:05 AM
I’d put in a rocket mass heater.  Not very pretty but very efficient.
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: dcheesi on March 21, 2018, 07:28:47 AM
I had a house with a skylight in the bathroom. It sounds silly and indulgent, until you realize that it allows you to use the bathroom without turning lights on, including when the power goes out. Plenty of natural light for morning grooming, and because it's in the ceiling, the light makes it into the shower as well. You can even pee by moonlight :) Loved that bathroom!
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: Vertical Mode on March 21, 2018, 07:58:45 AM
Designated bicycle storage/work space at grade, with a door to the exterior so I could grab the bike and go.

Inspired by my commute this morning. Going up and down stairs to extract the bike from the basement and lock the appropriate doors before the ride in gets to be kind of a PITA some days. Eliminating an entire process in the morning when I'm only half-awake would be helpful.

Lots of good ideas in this thread!
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: LovinPSDs on March 21, 2018, 08:52:29 AM
Wait a minute here, are you saying the other houses in town are too cheap for you? What makes you think you need a house in the 175-250k price range? Please tell me that all the other houses are actually more expensive than this. Building a brand new house is almost never more cost effective than buying an existing one. You also don't want to have the most expensive house in your neighborhood when you try to sell.

Yes they are cheap, but also in very low income/drug filled/not areas I want to raise my family of 4. We're in the Midwest where I believe 200-250K should go a pretty decent way (1 acre(ish) + 3/2 house).  I am trying to work this very fine balance of a house nice enough to meet our quality and appearance standards (which admittedly are relatively high for this group I'd guess), reasonable enough to not cramp our budget, close enough to reduce my drive and in an area where we can sell if I get a wild hair for the oil field again.  It's a very delicate balance.

I know many here will say "imagine if you bought that 15K dump next to the coke dealer!! You could save 75% of your income" but that's just not where my priorities lie for my young family.

I am simply seeking out great ideas for which you would add to a house if you were going to build. Some are probably less Mustachian than others but I don't believe we're out of line.   
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: LovinPSDs on March 21, 2018, 08:53:55 AM
I had a house with a skylight in the bathroom. It sounds silly and indulgent, until you realize that it allows you to use the bathroom without turning lights on, including when the power goes out. Plenty of natural light for morning grooming, and because it's in the ceiling, the light makes it into the shower as well. You can even pee by moonlight :) Loved that bathroom!

I love this idea!! We have  family member with this and I was always surprised out how great the light was.  What about condensation for the shower?  Does it collect up there, rather than going out the vent fan?
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: LovinPSDs on March 21, 2018, 08:56:02 AM
Before anything went in, I would concentrate on not building any bigger than you need. Buy clever designed space to suit your family and climate, before size.

Great reminder.  I'm trying to balance this as well... We are currently in 1875 sq. ft which is plenty and could be dramatically optimized if I could move it around.  Hence why we're looking for great ideas!!
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: LovinPSDs on March 21, 2018, 08:58:01 AM
What about Radiant floor heating?  I freaking love that but no idea how cost effective it is.   You can keep the heat down much lower than forced air.
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: Lady SA on March 21, 2018, 08:58:56 AM
https://www.amazon.com/Make-Your-House-Do-Housework/dp/0937750336
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: Loretta on March 21, 2018, 09:00:00 AM
Maybe not mustachian overall but simple pleasures.  A bathtub with jets and a neck rest.  Kind of like the ones they advertise for seniors on daytime TV.  Definitely some skylights too.  Also an extra wide door for moving furniture in and out over the years.  Some things to make life easier when the power goes out in bad weather. 
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: Scrapr on March 21, 2018, 09:25:09 AM
Think about a net zero energy home. I laughed out loud 15 years ago when I heard the concept. I would do one now if we were to build (unlikely). Net Zero homes essentially generate as much power over a year as they use. So the home has to be insulated well. Air sealed during construction. Blower door tested a couple times before it's done. Then solar panels in the right amount. Not every builder will be able to do this. So it may take some work to find one

https://zeroenergyproject.org/buy/zero-energy-homes/

Our current home (14 y/o) is very tight and it makes a world of difference. Our home before we downsized was very leaky. We had it tightened up and ducts sealed up about 5 years before we moved. (right at the cost/value payoff) What a difference. Comfortable.

If you want to go overboard here do a Passive Haus. They have some good concepts you can use

I would get the bones of the house right before I worried about Alexa for the home type stuff

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Passive_house
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: ketchup on March 21, 2018, 09:25:55 AM
If I were building from scratch today:

Efficient layout, one-story.  Minimal hallways/wasted space.
No steps/workaroundable steps so that I can still live there when I'm 120 years old.
Roof oriented optimally for solar.
Unfinished garage, basement, and/or workshop type space.
EV charger.
As someone else mentioned, easy access to utilities and other maintenance items.
Well-insulated, but also lots of natural light (skylights!)
Radiant floor heating.
Low-maintenance yard/garden.
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: Raenia on March 21, 2018, 11:17:14 AM
Another vote for the bathroom skylight, but you do have to make sure it is ventilated properly.  Choose your orientation carefully to make the best use of solar gain and solar panels if you want to go that way.  My SO has also been doing a lot of research lately into masonry furnaces, consider that for heating if needed in your climate.  Consider what architectural styles are generally suited to the climate, and look at many examples and floorplans to see what you like and dislike.

Think about what spaces you really use - most families these days live centered around the kitchen and living room, and barely use the dining room or formal sitting room.  Think about if you like the feeling of an open floor plan, or if you prefer cozier, defined spaces.

I recommend reading The Not So Big House by Sarah Susanka, it has a ton of ideas about how to make a house feel homey and spacious without necessarily being large.
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: RelaxedGal on March 21, 2018, 01:28:25 PM
Designated bicycle storage/work space at grade, with a door to the exterior so I could grab the bike and go.

Amen!

Also Amen to the skylight or a solatube in the bathroom for power outages (and general niceness).  I wanted one in my new bathroom but I'd already put solar panels on that roof :-(  Would have come in handy during the 2 day power outage a couple weeks back.

What did come in handy during that power outage: gas water heater.  We had hot showers (in the dark, by candle/flashlight) the whole time.  And everyone with a pellet stove had heat as long as they had a generator to run the fan.  Since you're moving rural you might have to worry more about outages. 

We didn't have heat but our house didn't cool down as quickly as the neighbor's, and I think 50% of that was because all the kids went to their house (and opened and closed the doors letting out all the heat!) and 50% was because we insisted on "airlocks" when we bought the house.  Each exterior door takes you to unheated space and then you open a second door into the house proper.  Our front door doesn't help much because it only opens to a screened in porch which has plastic over the screens to keep the wind out. Our back door, however, opens to a fully walled room which also has an exterior door.  In all cases the airlocks keep the cold wind from blowing in to the house.  Or the cat from escaping, which is actually why we insisted on them when house hunting.




Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: Prairie Stash on March 22, 2018, 08:34:08 AM
Double thick walls - Net zero

In colder climates (Canada) its a construction technique where two sets of wall studs are used (offset) so that the insulation can be doubled. You get 12" walls and extra deep windows sills. The main benefit is it removes most of the heating/cooling cost from the house forever. A current house can be built that won't need a furnace (in Canada, we're talking cold weather), or AC in the summer (where I live the temperatures range from 40to 105 F every year). Without a forced air furnace or AC there is less dust in the house, its a weird side note that cleaning is minimized as well!

I use to work with a fellow who was a pioneer of the net zero homes, he passed away unfortunately. Being an engineer he posted all the costs of building his own house, his utlity bills and did a comparison to a conventional house built to be the same size. His build cost was under 10% more than a conventional home, in 1990! costs have become better since then, unfortunately its still difficult to find plans or contractors that can adapt building styles.

Bonus in the country, you won't need natural gas lines to be extended to the property.
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: Roadrunner53 on March 22, 2018, 10:46:20 AM
We like to cook and our kitchen is typical and never enough room. I would like a gourmet kitchen with a very large island. In that kitchen I would like to have a HUGE industrial refrigerator and freezer. Then off the kitchen a walk in large pantry. I would have stainless steel shelves on wheels. Then I would have a large laundry room with counter tops, sink storage cabinets. I would have a built in vacuum cleaner. Central air. One floor living. I would also have pocket door for space saving on bedroom doors.
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: dcheesi on March 22, 2018, 11:19:08 AM
I had a house with a skylight in the bathroom. It sounds silly and indulgent, until you realize that it allows you to use the bathroom without turning lights on, including when the power goes out. Plenty of natural light for morning grooming, and because it's in the ceiling, the light makes it into the shower as well. You can even pee by moonlight :) Loved that bathroom!

I love this idea!! We have  family member with this and I was always surprised out how great the light was.  What about condensation for the shower?  Does it collect up there, rather than going out the vent fan?
I never noticed a problem with that. I had relatively high vaulted ceilings; not sure if that would make a difference?
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: historienne on March 22, 2018, 11:24:23 AM

I love this idea!! We have  family member with this and I was always surprised out how great the light was.  What about condensation for the shower?  Does it collect up there, rather than going out the vent fan?
I never noticed a problem with that. I had relatively high vaulted ceilings; not sure if that would make a difference?

We used to have one, and never noticed a problem.  We took it out, however, because we put on a new metal roof and didn't trust that the skylight seal would last as long as the roof. 
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: The_Pretender on March 22, 2018, 12:02:38 PM
I spent time in a house in Italy and I thought the coolest thing there was the Pellet stove.  He had it piped to provide radiant heat throughout the house (the boiler essentially).  He cranked up the blower one night and it got really hot.  I think he went through half a bag or so of pellets.  Downside I feel of this would be that he had to buy bags of pellets like dog food and had to have a place to store them.  They also had Solar panels to help with electricity going out issues.

I would also look at MMM posts about his most recent house project he bought a couple years ago and provided reviews of all of his projects.  I liked his project using his water heat to provide radiant heat under his wood floors when needed.

I would agree with an earlier poster about understand your family needs or wants...  Is it important to have a sitting room or even a dining room?  Right now I would build a house with a nice large kitchen space with an inviting island for people to gather around and have this open up to a nice living space.  then have bedrooms on the other half of the house.  I think of the houses I enjoy spending time at... and they have this setup. 

I would say, figure out your desired layout.  try to make each square foot functional where you interact w/ the space weekly (no dead rooms). Then figure out how to make it most efficient. Insulation, heating/cooling options, and required maintenance.  Finally you can think of the cool things you could add like a Tesla roof and wall battery.

Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: bogart on March 22, 2018, 03:28:33 PM
I vote for solatubes over conventional skylights; we have them (the tube type) and love them.  They can also have lights inside them (ours do) and do double-duty.

Whole-house fan.  Good for taking quick advantage of a preferred temp outside, and nice for getting fresh air into the house, also.
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: Trekker on March 22, 2018, 03:43:34 PM
Basically, I want to design the house in such a way to take advantage of efficient, passive heating/cooling as much as possible, while also focusing on future maintainability (being able to easily fix/update things without having to rip things out) and passively supplementing our normal consumption (food or energy).

Ted Benson Open Built

http://www.phrc.psu.edu/assets/docs/Publications/2016RBDCCPresentations/Keynote-2016-RBDCC-Benson.pdf

http://teddbenson.com/category/open-built/

http://bensonwood.com/sustainable-design/open-built/
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: Jrr85 on March 22, 2018, 03:58:50 PM
So we're thinking about moving very close to my work... Current drive is 31 miles each way.. I know I know.  The place we'd move to is a relatively rural small community with not a ton of houses available, especially in the 175-250K range where we'd likely be.  So we've thought about building a house, trying our best to keep it reasonable 3/2 + a nice garage for tinkering.

My real question is, what type of mustachian things would you put in a new house.. assuming you had a clean slate.  I'm thinking like Tesla solar roof, attic fan, high efficiency AC, on demand water heater... Perhaps wood burning fireplace for ambiance that also adds heat in the winter.  Just want to kick ideas around!! What do ya'll think?! 

Ps. If the move happens I'm total getting an E-Bike!

Geothermal heating/cooling maybe? 
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: bluebelle on March 22, 2018, 04:15:03 PM
We like to cook and our kitchen is typical and never enough room. I would like a gourmet kitchen with a very large island. In that kitchen I would like to have a HUGE industrial refrigerator and freezer. Then off the kitchen a walk in large pantry. I would have stainless steel shelves on wheels. Then I would have a large laundry room with counter tops, sink storage cabinets. I would have a built in vacuum cleaner. Central air. One floor living. I would also have pocket door for space saving on bedroom doors.
this is what we planned on doing until we priced out the 48 or 60" stove.....I could put two 30" ranges in for a 1/3 of the price....WTF
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: grantmeaname on March 22, 2018, 04:35:05 PM
So we're thinking about moving very close to my work... Current drive is 31 miles each way.. I know I know.  The place we'd move to is a relatively rural small community with not a ton of houses available, especially in the 175-250K range where we'd likely be.  So we've thought about building a house, trying our best to keep it reasonable 3/2 + a nice garage for tinkering.

My real question is, what type of mustachian things would you put in a new house.. assuming you had a clean slate.  I'm thinking like Tesla solar roof, attic fan, high efficiency AC, on demand water heater... Perhaps wood burning fireplace for ambiance that also adds heat in the winter.  Just want to kick ideas around!! What do ya'll think?! 

Ps. If the move happens I'm total getting an E-Bike!

Geothermal heating/cooling maybe?
Is there any advantage to this over an air-source heat pump?
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: partgypsy on March 23, 2018, 11:38:28 AM
So we're thinking about moving very close to my work... Current drive is 31 miles each way.. I know I know.  The place we'd move to is a relatively rural small community with not a ton of houses available, especially in the 175-250K range where we'd likely be.  So we've thought about building a house, trying our best to keep it reasonable 3/2 + a nice garage for tinkering.

My real question is, what type of mustachian things would you put in a new house.. assuming you had a clean slate.  I'm thinking like Tesla solar roof, attic fan, high efficiency AC, on demand water heater... Perhaps wood burning fireplace for ambiance that also adds heat in the winter.  Just want to kick ideas around!! What do ya'll think?! 

Ps. If the move happens I'm total getting an E-Bike!

Geothermal heating/cooling maybe?
I was going to add that! Only cost effective if you are building your house, and planning to stay there a long time (big initial outlay). Many benefits to a forced air heat pump. https://www.thisoldhouse.com/ideas/geothermal-heat-pump-how-it-works
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: grantmeaname on March 23, 2018, 11:45:00 AM
Which are?
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: partgypsy on March 23, 2018, 12:05:53 PM
Which are?

No fossil fuel use. Highly efficient: you get 3-5 units of heating/cooling for every $1 unit of electricity you spend. In contrast forced air is 1 to 1 ratio. The permanent piping, should last a couple generations. No outside blowers. Can also be tied in and used to heat radiant flooring.

Biggest con is the initial outlay in costs (takes 7-8 years for payback), and whether the land is suitable for that kind of installation. 
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: bognish on March 23, 2018, 12:18:44 PM
Solar water heater.
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: BDWW on March 23, 2018, 12:30:24 PM
So we're thinking about moving very close to my work... Current drive is 31 miles each way.. I know I know.  The place we'd move to is a relatively rural small community with not a ton of houses available, especially in the 175-250K range where we'd likely be.  So we've thought about building a house, trying our best to keep it reasonable 3/2 + a nice garage for tinkering.

My real question is, what type of mustachian things would you put in a new house.. assuming you had a clean slate.  I'm thinking like Tesla solar roof, attic fan, high efficiency AC, on demand water heater... Perhaps wood burning fireplace for ambiance that also adds heat in the winter.  Just want to kick ideas around!! What do ya'll think?! 

Ps. If the move happens I'm total getting an E-Bike!

Geothermal heating/cooling maybe?
Is there any advantage to this over an air-source heat pump?

In London or other relatively moderate climates probably not. In colder climates air source heat pumps don't work in the depths of winter(though modern ones are getting a lot better) and aren't as efficient in really hot temps either. Ground source is much more reliable/stable.

The ground temperature doesn't change much throughout the year, it's roughly equal to year-average air temperature. Here, that means ~ 50F (10C). As long as your ground loop is sized properly, you can either put heat back into that temp in the summer, or extract heat in the winter.

The air temps are dramatically different of course. Pumping heat out into 100F(38C) air is less efficient (but generally works).  In the winter here, we often get air temps of -20F+(-29C), and even modern air source simply won't be able to extract sufficient heat from that. In addition to prevent freezing up at even moderately low temps 0F(-18C), air source generally has to run a resistant heating element on the exterior coil, adding cost.

TLDR: Ground pumps are generally better and more efficient, but much more expensive.
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: grantmeaname on March 23, 2018, 12:35:27 PM
Which are?
No fossil fuel use. Highly efficient: you get 3-5 units of heating/cooling for every $1 unit of electricity you spend. In contrast forced air is 1 to 1 ratio. The permanent piping, should last a couple generations. No outside blowers. Can also be tied in and used to heat radiant flooring.

Biggest con is the initial outlay in costs (takes 7-8 years for payback), and whether the land is suitable for that kind of installation.
Doesn't a typical air source heat pump also have a CoP of 4 and run off electricity? What do your extra fixed costs for a ground source heat pump get you over an air source heat pump?
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: Awesomeness on March 23, 2018, 01:01:50 PM
I think my house is mustachian.  Except for the extra cost of the quality items and wants I put in it.  Similar homes can be had for at least 40grand less but not with all the extras I put mine that make it great. 

Built in 1947, 2 bed 1 bath, 918 sq feet and a full basement. Classic small Midwest home. It was abandoned and had two feet of water in the basement the day I closed.

Completely gutted it, new sewer line and waterproofing basement system with three sump pumps. $$$

Hardwood floors last forever. Mine are 3/4 solid white pine so only need refinishing someday.

White subway tile in bathrooms, hexagon flooring, black grout, timeless and should last decades. 

Pedastel sinks, last forever. All these fit my house style well.  Chrome finish for all fixtures, all Moen with lifetime warranty.  It’s timeless and the cheapest finish you can get.

The basement floor is stained concrete, looks great, 200$ to stain 900 sq feet. Area rugs soften it all up.

Separately zone basement Hvac so it would be comfortable.  Feels the same as the upstairs.  It’s high efficiency too.   

Attic fan, love those things. Great for good weather or when you burn something. 

Solid wood cabinets, 42in so they go to the ceiling.  Picked a plain style so they wouldn’t be trendy.  Painted grey now but that can easily be changed.

Did washer and dryer connections upstairs and down just in case. 

I had a contractor for all of this and he wasn’t the greatest.  But there are real advantages Gutting and rebuilding. Everything is barely two years old.  Was able to do extras like lose a closet in the bedroom to make a huge walk in shower. It’s really great. Took out the wall between the living room and dining room.  Nice and open. Bumped into the second bedroom to make a pantry for the kitchen.

I just finished putting 10 grand into my basement to make it an apartment.  Already had W/D connections, hvac was zoned separately, had a bar already but turned that into a kitchen area.  Added an egress window so now I’m officially a 3 bedroom.  Put a door upstairs to create privacy.  I go through the front door and they enter in the back.  It’s really an awesome place, I’d live in it and rent my upstairs if I needed.  I get 800$ a month. So it costs me about 400 a month to live here. Badass right!

In total spent about 175. It’s worth 145 ish and I owe 130. Ouch but that basement income will make up for it.

You can do your research and pick the best things but it’s true that quality isn’t what it used to be. Just repaired my 400$ American Standard toilet, did it myself so that was cool.  But that’s ridiculous that a seal wore out that fast. My AC compressor crapped out, warranty covered that. Stove got a new burner, not under warranty.  Fridge repaired under warranty once but now it’s starting to rattle sometimes, that’s horrible when your house is small and the sofa is 7 feet away. 


A one level 3/2 home can be nicely done for 1500sq feet.  Go bigger than that and you can add a fourth bedroom or formal dining area.  Personally I’ve owned 6 homes and three were 1600 sq feet. Pretty much a perfect size you live your whole life in, starter to empty nester. 
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: Awesomeness on March 23, 2018, 01:11:20 PM
Wait a minute here, are you saying the other houses in town are too cheap for you? What makes you think you need a house in the 175-250k price range? Please tell me that all the other houses are actually more expensive than this. Building a brand new house is almost never more cost effective than buying an existing one. You also don't want to have the most expensive house in your neighborhood when you try to sell.

So true.  I always get the cheapest house you can get in the nicest neighborhood.  I’ve owned 6 homes. Two new, one built in 1800. One in 1947 that I fully gutted.  Two 60’s ranches.  But far the best value for the money was the two older ranches.

Builing new is a premium price for something that’s just neat and clean. After time it needs the same maintenance as everything else and you just paid more to get there.

Gutting and rebuilding and the budget is out the window from unknown issues or the “good ideas you have because this is the best time to do them”. 

Hunt for a good deal that needs cosmetic fixes in the best location possible.  That’s the best value for your money. 

Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: Rocketman on March 23, 2018, 04:32:34 PM
Small thing but get 36” interior doors and wide halls. This is to 1. Help move stuff, 2. If anyone needs a wheelchair it will fit with no problems - if you live your whole life in a place odds are really high someone, sometime will need a wheelchair ( even if it’s just for 2 months or so)
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: Slow2FIRE on March 23, 2018, 06:27:47 PM
As someone already mentioned - thicker exterior walls. Used to be 2x4 was common.  Now it is common to see 2x6 exteriors, I'd go with at least 2x8 exteriors minimum along with the passive solar heat design element considerations others mentioned.  Strike the balance between natural light in your home and too much heat in the summer (maybe infrared rejection films/coatings for all windows).

Grey water collection system for flushing toilets or maybe irrigation.

Very low water use plumbing fixtures.  I don't think the water recycling fixtures are reasonably priced yet (you can get a shower that uses only about 5 gallons of water no matter how long your shower is because it constantly filters and reheats the water at the shower only draining when you completely finish the shower, but I believe the price is too high still and you have to import it from Europe).  Check to see what they are doing in California to deal with droughts and implement some of those water saving ideas into your new home.

So we're thinking about moving very close to my work... Current drive is 31 miles each way.. I know I know.  The place we'd move to is a relatively rural small community with not a ton of houses available, especially in the 175-250K range where we'd likely be.  So we've thought about building a house, trying our best to keep it reasonable 3/2 + a nice garage for tinkering.

My real question is, what type of mustachian things would you put in a new house.. assuming you had a clean slate.  I'm thinking like Tesla solar roof, attic fan, high efficiency AC, on demand water heater... Perhaps wood burning fireplace for ambiance that also adds heat in the winter.  Just want to kick ideas around!! What do ya'll think?! 

Ps. If the move happens I'm total getting an E-Bike!

Geothermal heating/cooling maybe?

If they get the 1acre they are looking for, should be able to do it without overspending.  They can lay out the geothermal pipes in a big horizontal field format.

If they were on the more typical 1/5 to 1/8 acre in a subdivision it would be ridiculously expensive.  Basically like hiring someone to drill a really really deep well for a vertical layout.  Probably rarely ever cost effective to do this type.

If on a rural 1 acre plot, do you have to put the solar on your roof?  I'd imagine it would be easier to do a self install in the yard with a rotator motor for ultimate solar efficiency vs being stuck with a single, potentially suboptimal, roof angle.  Much easier to clean those panels on occasion at ground level too.
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: Poundwise on March 23, 2018, 08:21:05 PM
Laundry room with a clothesline by a door or window so one could just load the line directly from the washing machine.

+1 on easy bike access.

Lots of south windows so herbs and veggies could be grown indoors; in fact a bit of a greenhouse/solarium would be aces in the winter!

Super-efficient soapstone stove, instead of a wasteful fireplace.
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: AnnaGrowsAMustache on March 24, 2018, 02:23:05 AM
Angle your house to the sun, with large double glazed windows. Plant deciduous trees in front of the windows, which will shade the house in summer and let the sun in in the winter. Make them fruit trees, and you get double the benefit.

Maybe a gas continuous flow hot water system, so you're only heating what you need. It will also save space over a hot water cylinder.

A clothesline! And perhaps a large covered outdoor area that can be used to hang washing and also be an outdoor room.
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: MrUpwardlyMobile on March 24, 2018, 08:09:45 AM
Angle your house to the sun, with large double glazed windows. Plant deciduous trees in front of the windows, which will shade the house in summer and let the sun in in the winter. Make them fruit trees, and you get double the benefit.

Maybe a gas continuous flow hot water system, so you're only heating what you need. It will also save space over a hot water cylinder.

A clothesline! And perhaps a large covered outdoor area that can be used to hang washing and also be an outdoor room.

Fruit trees can be tough to maintain pre-fire.  They take a lot of maintenance and upkeep or else you’ll attract vermin.
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: LaineyAZ on March 24, 2018, 08:29:58 AM
More of a design suggestion, but how about:
[li]
[/li][/list]
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: HipGnosis on March 24, 2018, 08:53:14 AM
Room.
Throughout the house and garage.
Room for stockpiling non-perishables in bulk and/or on sale.   Room for at least one freezer.
Room for kitchen and household appliances and tools and maintenance supplies so you can do things vs paying someone else to do them.
Room for auto, house, yard maintenance tools and supplies.

Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: Steeze on March 24, 2018, 10:17:25 AM
Angle your house to the sun, with large double glazed windows. Plant deciduous trees in front of the windows, which will shade the house in summer and let the sun in in the winter. Make them fruit trees, and you get double the benefit.

Maybe a gas continuous flow hot water system, so you're only heating what you need. It will also save space over a hot water cylinder.

A clothesline! And perhaps a large covered outdoor area that can be used to hang washing and also be an outdoor room.

Fruit trees can be tough to maintain pre-fire.  They take a lot of maintenance and upkeep or else you’ll attract vermin.

Then again, if you plan fruit trees now - most will take a few years to start producing fruits, so it might just work out.

Design Ideas for me would include:
- Work with a designer and builder to achieve Passive House certification (orientation, insulation, glazing, energy use/production etc.)
- Wood stove with gas backup, because chopping wood is fun on a Saturday, and a good work out.
- Mother in-law suite with ADA compatible bathroom and bedroom on the 1st floor (airbnb, rental, parents as they age, eventually us as we age, etc.)
- Storage space for valuables and personal items so I could use primary space as a rental while traveling for long periods of time
- Garden & greenhouse space
- Large enough pantry for canning / storage of bulk food purchases
- Covered outdoor space that is suitable for sleeping

Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: Rosy on March 24, 2018, 10:44:37 AM
1. Think vernacular - it is what's called passive house certification now, just a fancy way of using the materials and the design methods that are most suitable for your area of the US. Here in Florida, it is for instance, the overhang around the houses that helps with the cooling in the heat of summer.
2. Insulation - preferably the double walls with the deep window sills - saves money forever.
3. Practicality
This is your chance to address your families needs:
No weird steps and stoops - if you want to live there in old age - also a hazard for little ones.
Doorways wide enough for a wheelchair - usually 48 inches and a clear path through the house - especially in and out of the bathroom.
Standard size windows do save a bundle or do like our friends did - buy rejected, odd size windows once they had a general plan and integrate the ones that worked for them. Many of the window shops will be happy to work with you on this.
Research the heating options to the nth degree. I vote for floor heating and a fireplace, plus a stove that can use different materials for heating.

A thousand times yes on the accessibility of pipes and electrical. Quite expensive to rip into walls or hunt down the problems when you can't get to anything - not to mention the inconvenience - if you are handy, it could save you thousands.
All rooms must have a window and I insist on a nice size window over the sink in the kitchen.
Agree on the solar tube skylight, if possible.
Decide on bike storage, a separate, spacious laundry area as well as sports/camping whatever equipment or holiday decor storage areas - and easy access to them - from the beginning. If you make it an afterthought you'll live to regret it.

Think about all the homes/apartments you've lived in or visited and what you liked best about them when you do your own planning. Even if you go two stories, with all bedrooms upstairs, plan for a room on the main floor downstairs, near a bathroom, that could become, if ever needed or wanted, a separate space for a long time visitor, teen, invalid or older adult that can no longer manage the stairs.

I'd still look at plenty of homes for sale new and old, just to see their flow and get a feel for how it would be to live in such a layout. The devil is truly in the details - well thought out solutions pay off forever, think long and hard about what is important to you and make sure you incorporate at least the top five things on your wishlist.
In this case, mustachianism to me means get the best you can afford, if it brings long-term satisfaction, is important to you or saves forever on your utility bill.

Kitchen and bathrooms top my list of pet peeves for poor design - I hate bathrooms where if you spread out your arms, you touch the wall - even in the shower. It is supposed to be a room, not a dingy closet!:) with no windows and poor airflow. Then people wonder why they have mold - duh!
Heck, even the Romans of two thousand years ago had floor heating and spacious bath areas and thick walls - just sayin'.

Good luck!

PS - yes, I use a clothesline, because we live in Florida and it is better for the life of your clothing, perhaps for the environment too, but I did plan a space with electrical wiring already in place in the utility room for a dryer when the time comes that I am too feeble to hang my own laundry.

Since I had to grapple with an impossible floor plan, 5 foot by eleven foot, I elevated the water heater when it needed replacement anyway. It sits on a heavy duty shelf up anchored to the concrete block walls, so I have plenty of space for a dryer beneath.
I ran high and deep shelving on the other wall for holiday storage and placed the rolling tool chest beneath - it isn't easy to fit today's lifestyle in a 50's small bungalow.
 
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: bacchi on March 24, 2018, 01:41:44 PM
Yes on passivhaus. Add rigid foam to the roof and walls (you can sometimes buy leftovers from craigslist).

The "perfect wall" is a good start. Make sure to adapt it to your climate.

https://buildingscience.com/documents/insights/bsi-001-the-perfect-wall
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: AnnaGrowsAMustache on March 24, 2018, 02:51:53 PM
Angle your house to the sun, with large double glazed windows. Plant deciduous trees in front of the windows, which will shade the house in summer and let the sun in in the winter. Make them fruit trees, and you get double the benefit.

Maybe a gas continuous flow hot water system, so you're only heating what you need. It will also save space over a hot water cylinder.

A clothesline! And perhaps a large covered outdoor area that can be used to hang washing and also be an outdoor room.

Fruit trees can be tough to maintain pre-fire.  They take a lot of maintenance and upkeep or else you’ll attract vermin.

Um... not so. They need a bee-friendly spray when the blosssoms drop, they need winter pruning (and the idea is to keep them small and compact so you can actually reach the fruit - no higher than your roof line), and they need someone to actually pick the fruit which is not something I consider a chore! A lawn requires far more maintenance than a fruit tree, and that's just a useless expanse of vegetation. Lawns were originally considered a sign of enormous wealth, because you could afford to have unused land. Now, of course, everyone has one and I consider them a sign of dumbarsery - pointless square footage that you paid for and now have to spend half your life mowing.

As for vermin, a good cat will put paid to that. I have a HUGE monster of a walnut tree, which attracts all sorts. The hedgehogs can stay, because they also eat all the snails and slugs, but the cat keeps the mice and rat population very low. I just rake the leaves into a big pile in the yard and let them mulch down. Walnut mulch is a natural weed killer. Not so good on the vege garden because it'll kill the plants, but great in those corner areas of driveway or fence where you don't want anything growing.
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: the_fixer on March 24, 2018, 10:53:06 PM
LED lighting
Thoughtful design / optimized space
Ranch single level
Whole house fan


Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: partgypsy on March 26, 2018, 08:48:43 AM
Angle your house to the sun, with large double glazed windows. Plant deciduous trees in front of the windows, which will shade the house in summer and let the sun in in the winter. Make them fruit trees, and you get double the benefit.

Maybe a gas continuous flow hot water system, so you're only heating what you need. It will also save space over a hot water cylinder.

A clothesline! And perhaps a large covered outdoor area that can be used to hang washing and also be an outdoor room.

Fruit trees can be tough to maintain pre-fire.  They take a lot of maintenance and upkeep or else you’ll attract vermin.

Um... not so. They need a bee-friendly spray when the blosssoms drop, they need winter pruning (and the idea is to keep them small and compact so you can actually reach the fruit - no higher than your roof line), and they need someone to actually pick the fruit which is not something I consider a chore! A lawn requires far more maintenance than a fruit tree, and that's just a useless expanse of vegetation. Lawns were originally considered a sign of enormous wealth, because you could afford to have unused land. Now, of course, everyone has one and I consider them a sign of dumbarsery - pointless square footage that you paid for and now have to spend half your life mowing.

As for vermin, a good cat will put paid to that. I have a HUGE monster of a walnut tree, which attracts all sorts. The hedgehogs can stay, because they also eat all the snails and slugs, but the cat keeps the mice and rat population very low. I just rake the leaves into a big pile in the yard and let them mulch down. Walnut mulch is a natural weed killer. Not so good on the vege garden because it'll kill the plants, but great in those corner areas of driveway or fence where you don't want anything growing.
Nut trees are even better than fruit trees! Both relatives and friends (one tried to do organically, one sprayed) got extremely low yields from their fruit trees due to pests and predation. It seemed like an uphill battle and not worth the trouble.
OTOH we used to have a pecan tree in the side yard of the house we rented. Free pecans, and every 4,5 years a big bumper crop with no additional work!

As far as geothermal, it does have a very expensive price tag. An alternative to reducing heat bills is to have radiant floor heating and have a fireplace in a central location, which can also heat the house if say heating goes out. I also ditto using passive solar building techniques, if you have the ability to angle how to set the house on the lot or at the least how the walls, windows etc are set. How exciting! When I was a kid I loved to draw "house plans" of dream houses. 
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: LaineyAZ on March 26, 2018, 09:51:31 AM
Related to the above, take plenty of photos during construction.  Will help pinpoint where all the "innards" are after the drywall goes up - a big help in every future behind-the-wall project.
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: Thegoblinchief on March 26, 2018, 11:12:43 AM
If planning to use the site productively, look at slope and the way water flows to help pick the best home site. Consider that while being on the top of a hill gives you great views, functionally it’s a very bad place shelter wise to put your house.

For cold-temperate climates, the best book on overall homestead planning especially related to water is Ben Falk’s Resilient Farm and Homestead. I’m less familiar with good resources for subtropical, arid, or Mediterannean climates.
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: grantmeaname on March 26, 2018, 11:51:32 AM
If planning to use the site productively, look at slope and the way water flows to help pick the best home site. Consider that while being on the top of a hill gives you great views, functionally it’s a very bad place shelter wise to put your house.
Because you don't want the water to flow up to your house?
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: Thegoblinchief on March 26, 2018, 04:02:12 PM
If planning to use the site productively, look at slope and the way water flows to help pick the best home site. Consider that while being on the top of a hill gives you great views, functionally it’s a very bad place shelter wise to put your house.
Because you don't want the water to flow up to your house?

No, being at the top of a hill puts you at the mercy of wind from every direction, so it makes energy efficiency much harder.

Edit: and you lose the ability to possibly gravity feed water to your house, having to rely on pumping.
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: robartsd on March 26, 2018, 05:29:43 PM
Yes on passivhaus. Add rigid foam to the roof and walls (you can sometimes buy leftovers from craigslist).

The "perfect wall" is a good start. Make sure to adapt it to your climate.

https://buildingscience.com/documents/insights/bsi-001-the-perfect-wall
Those perfect walls are great - of course the devil is in the details of how put holes through it.
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: change_seeker on March 26, 2018, 06:29:53 PM
I had a house with a skylight in the bathroom. It sounds silly and indulgent, until you realize that it allows you to use the bathroom without turning lights on, including when the power goes out. Plenty of natural light for morning grooming, and because it's in the ceiling, the light makes it into the shower as well. You can even pee by moonlight :) Loved that bathroom!

Our new house has that too, but in the hall (kids) bathroom rather than the master.  Will have to try peeing by moonlight ;)
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: nickybecky1 on March 26, 2018, 06:45:11 PM
Major +1 to the have your house do your housework book. I borrowed it from the library but would absolutely buy it if planning to build a home or even if embarking on a house hunt. About half of it is stuff that I can implement in my own home but half is probably how you build the house to have the minimum maintenance (both cost and time efficient). It is recommended in the thread about making your house easy to maintain along with an ergonomics book that I’d recommend checking out while planning.

My aunt and uncle have a house that’s passive solar heated, with nearly all the windows open to the south and insulated garage doors basically that close at night to keep the heat in. It’s very cool and very cheap to operate. One side is built into the ground which helps maintain temperature quite a lot. I don’t know if I’d go to the trouble of getting passivehaus certified but would use some of the principles to figure that out.

One story houses are the easiest to maintain. But after that, a two story house that has balconies by all the windows so you can wash all the windows while standing on your own, and a roof that on one side is low enough to step onto because it’s built into the ground is almost as good. This is the case for my aunt and uncle’s house and it’s great.

I’d also recommend minimizing the doors that go in and out to maintain more efficiency. I love houseplans where the garage/most used entrance and main guest entrance are either one door (some midcentury designs have this) or enter the house in roughly the same area so that you can always access the mudroom/coat storage easily from both without walking through the house.

I also love skylights and natural light and we’ve been adding them to our house so I agree that’s a great option.
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: Lmoot on March 27, 2018, 03:21:58 AM
When I think of a frugal house, I don’t think of adding things. I would try and design it in a way which makes maintenance cheaper and easier. For example, wall panels to plumbing and electrical components, crawl space or attic access to pipes (instead of burying in concrete). Or even a detached “control closet” where plumbing, electric and mechanical components live).

Maximizing square footage by extending living areas to the outdoors. Wood burning stoves if live in colder climate, and slanted clerestory windows angled to capture max winter sun. If hot area, large roof eaves and short bushy trees around windows, fans in every room (fans are a friend to southern houses...we even have them on our porches).

Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: grantmeaname on March 27, 2018, 03:49:59 AM
clerestory
Damn that's a good word.
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: robartsd on March 27, 2018, 10:33:08 AM
I've always dreamed about building my own house, but it doesn't seem like the practical thing to do. Early in life my dreams were probably an over-reaction to growing up in a large family in a 3 bedroom house (a very large family room was partially pressed into service as a bedroom while the occupant load exceeded 2 people per actual bedroom). Now I'd still like a house where extended family could gather for Thanksgiving, featuring a 6-800 sf space with the kitchen on one end and living room on the other. With a desire for an entry foyer and formal family room as well, the size of the public space in my "dream house" is close to the entire space of my current house.

Pushing the boundaries on environmentalism could include composting (http://www.compostingtoilet.com/?page_id=401) toilets (http://www.clivusmultrum.com/products-services.php) in addition to grey-water and  rain catchment systems. These aren't likely to make financial sense unless you're building in remote areas and can completely avoid the costs associated with utility service.

More practical desires have already been mentioned: pantry space, passive solar design, aging in place. I picture integrating a ramp from the driveway to the porch into the landscape and space for a ramp from the garage to the interior (might use this space for a garage workshop until the ramp is needed). I do want to see a good architectural detail for how to connect a concrete porch and a raised frame floor in a way that would meet ADA accessibility standards - every raised frame floor I've seen has porches that are a step down so the porch don't have to be higher than the concrete foundation wall the framed floor sits on.
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: Vertical Mode on March 27, 2018, 06:04:55 PM
I've always dreamed about building my own house, but it doesn't seem like the practical thing to do. Early in life my dreams were probably an over-reaction to growing up in a large family in a 3 bedroom house (a very large family room was partially pressed into service as a bedroom while the occupant load exceeded 2 people per actual bedroom). Now I'd still like a house where extended family could gather for Thanksgiving, featuring a 6-800 sf space with the kitchen on one end and living room on the other. With a desire for an entry foyer and formal family room as well, the size of the public space in my "dream house" is close to the entire space of my current house.

Pushing the boundaries on environmentalism could include composting (http://www.compostingtoilet.com/?page_id=401) toilets (http://www.clivusmultrum.com/products-services.php) in addition to grey-water and  rain catchment systems. These aren't likely to make financial sense unless you're building in remote areas and can completely avoid the costs associated with utility service.

More practical desires have already been mentioned: pantry space, passive solar design, aging in place. I picture integrating a ramp from the driveway to the porch into the landscape and space for a ramp from the garage to the interior (might use this space for a garage workshop until the ramp is needed). I do want to see a good architectural detail for how to connect a concrete porch and a raised frame floor in a way that would meet ADA accessibility standards - every raised frame floor I've seen has porches that are a step down so the porch don't have to be higher than the concrete foundation wall the framed floor sits on.

I'm not sure whether I'm correctly visualizing what you're describing here - are you suggesting that the porch and finish floor elevation at the door should be level, instead of a step down? Is the porch itself level with the surrounding grade?

You've probably thought of this already, but if you're planning ahead (as in new construction) it is generally easier to accomplish a flush egress condition by grading the site itself up to meet your porch elevation, unless you have serious space constraints. Much easier to play with the soft stuff (soil) than go to the trouble of architectural solutions which involve time, money, and engineering. In the grand scheme of construction projects, moving earth is relatively cheap. Plus, it will ensure positive drainage away from your house!
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: robartsd on March 28, 2018, 10:14:29 AM
I do want to see a good architectural detail for how to connect a concrete porch and a raised frame floor in a way that would meet ADA accessibility standards - every raised frame floor I've seen has porches that are a step down so the porch don't have to be higher than the concrete foundation wall the framed floor sits on.

I'm not sure whether I'm correctly visualizing what you're describing here - are you suggesting that the porch and finish floor elevation at the door should be level, instead of a step down? Is the porch itself level with the surrounding grade?

You've probably thought of this already, but if you're planning ahead (as in new construction) it is generally easier to accomplish a flush egress condition by grading the site itself up to meet your porch elevation, unless you have serious space constraints. Much easier to play with the soft stuff (soil) than go to the trouble of architectural solutions which involve time, money, and engineering. In the grand scheme of construction projects, moving earth is relatively cheap. Plus, it will ensure positive drainage away from your house!
This is just a theoretical dream project for now. Every house I've seen where porch is even with floor has been slab on grade construction. I would love to see a porch even with the floor where the floor is framed over a crawlspace or basement. I've always seen these where the framed floor is built on top of concrete foundation walls and the top of the porch is no higher than the top of the concrete foundation walls. Usually the cladding will extend a little below the wood framing overlapping the top of the foundation wall and the top of the porch will be just below the bottom of the cladding. The detail that I'm having trouble envisioning is where concrete porch, framed floor, and cladding all meet. So far I'm thinking it probably involves use of pressure treated rim joists.

Yes, I agree that landscaping to provide grade level transition to the concrete porch would be appropriate.
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: LovinPSDs on March 29, 2018, 09:25:31 PM
So we went and looked at a house that was "net zero" on Tuesday, how cool!! The owner had a pretty big solar array and was on the waitlist for a Tesla 3 but fell into 10 acres and is moving to build.  Property had electric on demand water, electric heaters to supplement the gas, and a few other nick nacks. He was also grandfathered in to the net metering plan until 2048 I think it is. I really liked the house enough to consider an offer but the wife doesn't like the lack of privacy sharing a private pond with about 10 other houses and it was near a highway which created noticeable noise. Once the trees bloomed I'm sure it would go down but o well, wife wasn't into it

I'll be honest, even if we stay where we are I'm becoming inverested in solar options. I read MMM latest blog about solar and noticed the link he provides for equipment actually went up in $/kw as the systems grew in size, what's that all about?
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: fixie on April 17, 2018, 05:09:35 PM
A single-level open floor plan in the Danish/Northern European simple design with a centrally located wood-fired masonry heater/heated bench.  High efficiency glazing with excellent light.  Easy entryway to accomodate bikes/mudroom, raingear.  Super insulated straw bale or straw clay insulation(can last hundreds of years).  Clay plaster and wood interior finishes.  Wiring installed in-wall conduit.  Floor plan design to optimize plumbing runs.  Metal roof with cement board siding or Yakisugi board and batten cedar siding.  Covered outdoor cooking area for hot summers.  Water catchment to cistern from roof.  Solar panels with battery backup.  Enormous shop for all my tinkering hobbies built in same manner as house but BIG.  Apartment over shop for rentals/guests.  Shop has overhead gantry hahaha.  That was fun.

-fixie
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: dhc on April 17, 2018, 08:32:04 PM
Wait a minute here, are you saying the other houses in town are too cheap for you? What makes you think you need a house in the 175-250k price range? Please tell me that all the other houses are actually more expensive than this. Building a brand new house is almost never more cost effective than buying an existing one. You also don't want to have the most expensive house in your neighborhood when you try to sell.

Yes they are cheap, but also in very low income/drug filled/not areas I want to raise my family of 4. We're in the Midwest where I believe 200-250K should go a pretty decent way (1 acre(ish) + 3/2 house).  I am trying to work this very fine balance of a house nice enough to meet our quality and appearance standards (which admittedly are relatively high for this group I'd guess), reasonable enough to not cramp our budget, close enough to reduce my drive and in an area where we can sell if I get a wild hair for the oil field again.  It's a very delicate balance.

I know many here will say "imagine if you bought that 15K dump next to the coke dealer!! You could save 75% of your income" but that's just not where my priorities lie for my young family.

I am simply seeking out great ideas for which you would add to a house if you were going to build. Some are probably less Mustachian than others but I don't believe we're out of line.
You're moving to be closer to work, but is this somewhere you plan to live forever? Because if not, building a house that's the most expensive in town is almost certainly a great way to throw your money down the toilet - who else is possibly going to buy what you're building where you're building it a few years down the road?

Besides, if you think every house for sale in the town you want to move to is so below your standards that there's a coke dealer next door (Im sure that's not true, but it suggests you think the town is somehow "below you), are you sure you're going to be happy living in that town?

Seems to me like the mustachian way of doing this isn't to buy a dump and just be happy with it, but it's also not to contribute to sprawl and waste by building something completely new. Instead, it's probably to buy an existing home with good bones and no coke dealer directly next door and spend the money you save rehabbing it to be pleasant, safe, efficient, and not completely out-of-character with its neighborhood.


Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: chaskavitch on April 18, 2018, 06:31:49 AM
A single-level open floor plan in the Danish/Northern European simple design with a centrally located wood-fired masonry heater/heated bench.  High efficiency glazing with excellent light.  Easy entryway to accomodate bikes/mudroom, raingear.  Super insulated straw bale or straw clay insulation(can last hundreds of years).  Clay plaster and wood interior finishes.  Wiring installed in-wall conduit.  Floor plan design to optimize plumbing runs.  Metal roof with cement board siding or Yakisugi board and batten cedar siding.  Covered outdoor cooking area for hot summers.  Water catchment to cistern from roof.  Solar panels with battery backup.  Enormous shop for all my tinkering hobbies built in same manner as house but BIG.  Apartment over shop for rentals/guests.  Shop has overhead gantry hahaha.  That was fun.

-fixie

Ha, this sounds like a perfect compromise between what my husband and I want.  He's always talking about making a longhouse-style home with a big fire in the middle, and having a giant shop with living space above it.  I'm all about the neat energy efficiency/water saving features.  We'd both love a sunny house and easy to access wiring and plumbing.
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: Roadrunner53 on April 18, 2018, 06:41:30 AM
Built in cabinets in the bedrooms so no need for dressers. Lots of closets. Lots of outlets. Ceiling fans. Large laundry room. Large bathrooms. Walk in closets.
Title: Re: What Mustachian things would you put in a new house if you built??
Post by: partgypsy on April 18, 2018, 10:47:18 AM
Double thick walls - Net zero

In colder climates (Canada) its a construction technique where two sets of wall studs are used (offset) so that the insulation can be doubled. You get 12" walls and extra deep windows sills. The main benefit is it removes most of the heating/cooling cost from the house forever. A current house can be built that won't need a furnace (in Canada, we're talking cold weather), or AC in the summer (where I live the temperatures range from 40to 105 F every year). Without a forced air furnace or AC there is less dust in the house, its a weird side note that cleaning is minimized as well!
 
I use to work with a fellow who was a pioneer of the net zero homes, he passed away unfortunately. Being an engineer he posted all the costs of building his own house, his utlity bills and did a comparison to a conventional house built to be the same size. His build cost was under 10% more than a conventional home, in 1990! costs have become better since then, unfortunately its still difficult to find plans or contractors that can adapt building styles.

Bonus in the country, you won't need natural gas lines to be extended to the property.

This is awesome. It's too bad these building designs are not more mainstream.