Depending on how often you haul the 7-8 people, you could sell the Honda, keep the Subaru, and rent a passenger van for the occasional need to haul the larger group. While they cost a bit more to rent than a regular rental car, they cost far less than $35,000 to rent. They even cost far less to buy than $35,000 so if the real purpose of getting the Honda was as a large group people hauler, why not just by a van? Used passenger vans are not very expensive because they are utility focused rather than comfort and cool factor.