Waffle, if zebra is not lying, they said you will only receive quotes from the agents you inquired about, and none of the others, so I would be surprised/disappointed if that happened to you. (I have not received anything I have not asked for).
Currently I am looking through the quotes from Metromile, Geico, and Elephant Auto, which are each fairly comparable and will probably end up going for one of those.
I still kind of wonder about how different claim resolution can be. As in, the larger companies know they can lawyer up and fight harder to keep from paying claims than the smaller companies because they can, so wouldn't that be an argument against larger companies?
I have a strong feeling that I get to keep what I don't pay for here was well as in investing. Insurance companies have to run their numbers very conservatively, so the numbers are going to be helping them make a profit more than helping me avoid a huge loss, which chances are very small. Especially since I drive about 1000mi/year.
Thanks for the responses everyone.