The Money Mustache Community

Learning, Sharing, and Teaching => Ask a Mustachian => Topic started by: scottydog on March 19, 2018, 06:13:20 AM

Title: Need advice for roofing underlayment: plywood vs securpan
Post by: scottydog on March 19, 2018, 06:13:20 AM
Does anyone have thoughts about whether we should prefer plywood or securpan as a material for membrane roofing underlayment?

I live in a duplex with a flat roof, and this summer my neighbour and I are having the roof replaced. Our place was built in 1924 and has a 29-year-old tar & gravel flat roof. Recent city bylaws require us to get a white roof and we've decided to go with a white elastomere membrane. We're restricting our search to CAA-approved contractors (CAA is the Canadian equivalent of AAA) to ensure the job is done well enough that we won't need to think about it for 2-3 decades. There's a real problem up here with roofing companies filing for bankruptcy and reforming under a new name every couple of years and we want to avoid those guys.

We've narrowed it down to 2 estimates. The cheaper company recommends an underlayment of securpan:
http://www.alcor-inc.com/58-product-securpan.html (http://www.alcor-inc.com/58-product-securpan.html)

The $4000 more expensive estimate has some advantages:

We have no idea what's underneath our current roof. It was last replaced years before either of us moved in. Maybe (hopefully?) there's already a solid layer that they could put the securpan on to.

What do you all think? Is it worth $4000 more to eliminate silicone joints and have a stronger underlayment?