Your only option is ACA plans. I'm in Indiana and there are only two companies I could choose from, probably similar in Ohio.
Don't try to do it online or you will get bombarded by unsolicited emails and phone calls, hook up with a local insurance navigator to help you price and select the best plan.
Brace yourself, I'm at similar income level and cost is $1,285 per month for myself and spouse.
Have to be below approx. $67,000 to start getting discounts.