How much are you spending per battery, and are you getting generic aftermarkets, or are you getting genuine OEM parts?
Do you still have the factory original to compare to and look for differences on to tell the difference between an OEM battery and a knock-off if necessary?
Cheap aftermarkets and counterfeit OEM batteries can be rife from sellers on both Ebay and Amazon, but it is possible to get legitimate OEM parts, too... but it usually takes some research, and checking the history and reviews of the company selling. It also helps to have the original to compare to the replacement to check to see if it's counterfeit. Occasionally, the counterfeit OEM batteries will be done
really well to the point that you can barely tell, but most of the time it's really piss poor. Other than logo sharpness and details, the markings, fine print, country(ies) of manufacture, build and sticker quality, and specs of the battery itself can all be compared as well. In your case, the part number should be an LG BL-T5 and it'd better be 3.8V, 2100mAh/8Wh with a minimum mAh/Wh rating of 2030mAh/7.7Wh. If you still don't have the original kicking around,
there are some good photos of both sides of one over on iFixit, which'll be better than nothing. Odds are if it's brand new and you only spent $10 on it, it's probably a counterfeit.
Your best bet is buying through Amazon
directly, not a third party seller
on Amazon. This way, if you get an obvious counterfeit fake on a listing that specifically states in the name and listing that it is an LG made, OEM battery, the return and refund process will be much easier and shouldn't cost you a dime. You should probably expect to pay around $30-35. If you're not 100% sure it's genuine or a fake, don't try to guess, call up customer support at Amazon anyway and explain your concern and reservation... but odds are, if it's from Amazon directly and not a Warehouse Deal open box, you'll probably be fine.
Otherwise, it can be a crap shoot as you've seen with aftermarkets. If you do go aftermarket, make sure they're a company/brand that's been around a few years with good reviews and offers a really good warranty (one year at least). As for a specific brand, I can't help you on that. Sorry.
(By the way, this is one of the things I hate about most built-in, hard-wired batteries - harder to tell the genuine from the fakes. Most user replaceable cellphone batteries on higher end phones usually still have some sort of accessible, genuine OEM check process via serial number, holograms, etc.)