Unless you really like being a landlord I would sell it. My wife and I also bought a home in Colorado in 2013 and sold it after a couple years, pocketing nearly $100k. We used some of the profit as a down payment on another home in a LCOL area, paid off our other debts, and have really benefited from the freedom a little money in the bank can offer. Luckily for us, prices in our location kind of tapered off and have even dipped a bit since our sale.