Financial advisor sounds like a good fit for your background and the things you like to do. And being a lawyer gives you a leg up, both in terms of perception (there's a credibility/authority factor inherent in being a lawyer) and in more practical terms. I remember looking into starting an Edward Jones financial advisor franchise several years ago and one of the things they regarded as a qualification was being a lawyer.
I wonder if you could combine that with being an estates and trusts attorney. It makes sense to me that the two positions could go together, because as a financial advisor you might be suggesting they do X with their estate (a la, "to ensure your disabled daughter is cared for after your death without endangering her ability to get Medicaid, you want to create yada-yada type of trust"), and then as an estates and trusts lawyer you could then provide the person with exactly X.
I don't think a tax attorney position would be as good a fit, given your desire for more in-person activities. I'm totally biased here but when I think "tax attorney," one thing that comes up is "lots of activities similar to doc review, but EVEN MORE BORING because you're reviewing financial documents instead of people's emails." And it would cost you tens of thousands of bucks to get the qualification! Ack! Whereas you don't need anything but some CLE's to reinvent yourself as an estates and trusts lawyer-slash-financial advisor. And for that I don't think you need to be a CPA; you're not doing or auditing people's books or doing their taxes, you're just advising them.