Anecdotal, but... I'd beware of AAA. I went through the pain of calling around all the insurance companies and settling on AAA. When I called Allstate to cancel, my agent asked me where I was going. I said AAA. He said, "I used to be an independent agent. We stopped selling AAA because they would hook you with one price, then raise the price or cancel in a couple of months."
Sure enough: about a month and a half in, AAA canceled both my home and auto for 2 different ridiculous reasons. As I was in the middle of a long, hellish family emergency, I just punted and went back to Allstate. My broker just chucked and said, "I told you so."