Author Topic: Unusual $$ circumstances- need help!!  (Read 6969 times)

Lepetitange3

  • Guest
Unusual $$ circumstances- need help!!
« on: May 16, 2017, 07:24:40 AM »
This is super long, sorry about that but thanks for reading and any advice !!  Been a hard core  lurker, first time posting.  I have a question/problem that deserves many face punches and a serious sigh from longtime Mustachians.  I only came to the light just this April after stumbling on the MMM blog.  I'm going to give a broad picture of our current status and my questions at the end:  My issues are admittedly not in any way the norm and deserving of no pity so here goes ;)


We are a couple with 4 kids.  One child (17) leaves for boot camp this summer and I we have also 8, 4, and newborn (found the light while on maternity leave).

Our income is very high.  We have multiple streams from several places, totaling 11-12k monthly more on that in a minute.  We adopted oldest child when he was 14 so 1k of this disappears when he turns 18, it's a supplement from the state.  Our only debt  is what's always sold as "good" debt (I know...lies)

Mortgage  1, the house we live in (and barring financial ruin never intend to leave...this is the dream house we plan to die in) 380k
mortgage 2, a house we used to live in in another state but haven't been able to sell 168k
Half my husbands student loans (the ones that qualify to be wiped out by being in public service for 10years, we paid the rest off already) 50k
1 car (we drove the other until it was totaled in an accident and bought new...ugh) 25k

Since finding mustachianism, I'm on track to halve our monthly expenses with little effort... Seriously lifestyle creep...it's evil.  Hubby has barely noticed changes other than switching grocery stores and me firing all the services (maids, lawn care etc) we both like to clean and garden and we pretty much just had these people coming for the sake of it because their work just redid stuff we were doing anyway.

So here's where we get too sad panda land because obviously despite the overspending, our income could plenty support it.  We have about 40k in various assets- checking, savings, 401k.  We are already technically retired.  6k of the above income is military pensions.  Husband and I are in our 30s and will receive this income forever.  Husband is currently in law enforcement, which I may never convince him to retire from.  He would be doing it even if we won the lottery.  He is already vested for the Leo pension too.  If he goes a full 20 with them, he will draw a third pension starting the day he retires.  I work entirely from home (as a teacher for our states online k-12)  now and am also in the same pension pool as hubby but chose the 401k instead because he was taking the pension.  The OLD plan was to work another 20 years (into our 50s)  and then draw 3 pensions and have a nice stash in the 401k for fun money.  By this point all the mortgages and student loans would be gone too.  And if we picked up social security later in our 70s even better.  If I was still seeing the world through normal glasses this plan wasn't half bad. 

But I have obviously discovered the error of my ways. 1) unlike hubby I am not overly fond of my job.  It's easy and it's very flexible (which is why I took it, i am insanely overqualified but I write books in my spare time and wanted to be home with the kids) and it's hard to quit when I make a pretty good salary for doing only 3-4 hours of work 5 days a week.  But it's annoying and I also pretty much have to always have my smartphone on to be "available" to my students.  I would rather just write and do the children but between lifestyle creep and debt that hasn't been a feasibleoption until I recently came to the light.  As I said above, hubby is unlikely to retire early.  He LOVES his job.  He has even talked about staying on the reserve force for 2 or 3 days a week after he officially retires and draws pension.

Anywho,

 Right now about 5k goes to service the above debts.  Ironically, mortgage 2 and mortgage 1 are only a few hundred bucks apart because mortgage 2 is a 15 year and 1 is a 30 year.  We are actively trying to sell the second home.  It's rented out for less than the mortgage presently.  And it's an older home in another state that is a money pit because we have to pay someone else to do repairs.  I can see cutting expenses down even further until I'm mostly in line with MMM beyond servicing these debts until they are paid.  But we have complications ...

So these are my 2 BIG questions-

1) how do you get a frugal but non-converted to mustachianism spouse onboard when you don't really have any financial issues or negativity surrounding work to motivate them?  I can definitely sell hubby on aggressively paying off the mortgage and student loan and car because he hates debt.  And even building the nest egg, but some of his consumerism (he likes gear people...military Leo stuff and he eats out a lot even when I pack him food because he eats all the time, he's that chronically fit guy who eats 100 times a day).  I don't want to lower spending temporarily, I want to cut the lifestyle creep permanently.  I'm not sure how to sell that.  Or what books I could get to sell him on that.  We are heavy readers. 

2) what should my goals and investment target even look like to officially FIRE?  (I'm sure some will say I'm really almost already fired since we could live off our pensions with extreme frugal measures, but at a bare minimum to consider myself truly FI, I would want all debts including our mortgages paid off and some kind of sizebale nest egg so we can live on the pension income and rely on the nest egg for our extras like travel, potentially helping children etc).  And I want to quit my job without making hubby uncomfortable.  It's the FU money.  See I still kind of care that getting 55j a year to do almost nothing even though I hate it isn't money I can quite let go of yet.  I want to be able to roll my eyes and drop my 2 weeks notice and say whatever and then roll over that 401k
To some VTSAX.

With the spending even slightly more in line, and especially if I can get the other property sold we will have a ton of money to throw at stuff, so help me !!!  What's my best game plan??

Lepetitange3

  • Guest
Unusual $$ circumstances- need help!!
« Reply #1 on: May 16, 2017, 07:24:55 AM »
This is super long, sorry about that but thanks for reading and any advice !!  Been a hard core  lurker, first time posting.  I have a question/problem that deserves many face punches and a serious sigh from longtime Mustachians.  I only came to the light just this April after stumbling on the MMM blog.  I'm going to give a broad picture of our current status and my questions at the end:  My issues are admittedly not in any way the norm and deserving of no pity so here goes ;)


We are a couple with 4 kids.  One child (17) leaves for boot camp this summer and I we have also 8, 4, and newborn (found the light while on maternity leave).

Our income is very high.  We have multiple streams from several places, totaling 11-12k monthly more on that in a minute.  We adopted oldest child when he was 14 so 1k of this disappears when he turns 18, it's a supplement from the state.  Our only debt  is what's always sold as "good" debt (I know...lies)

Mortgage  1, the house we live in (and barring financial ruin never intend to leave...this is the dream house we plan to die in) 380k
mortgage 2, a house we used to live in in another state but haven't been able to sell 168k
Half my husbands student loans (the ones that qualify to be wiped out by being in public service for 10years, we paid the rest off already) 50k
1 car (we drove the other until it was totaled in an accident and bought new...ugh) 25k

Since finding mustachianism, I'm on track to halve our monthly expenses with little effort... Seriously lifestyle creep...it's evil.  Hubby has barely noticed changes other than switching grocery stores and me firing all the services (maids, lawn care etc) we both like to clean and garden and we pretty much just had these people coming for the sake of it because their work just redid stuff we were doing anyway.

So here's where we get too sad panda land because obviously despite the overspending, our income could plenty support it.  We have about 40k in various assets- checking, savings, 401k.  We are already technically retired.  6k of the above income is military pensions.  Husband and I are in our 30s and will receive this income forever.  Husband is currently in law enforcement, which I may never convince him to retire from.  He would be doing it even if we won the lottery.  He is already vested for the Leo pension too.  If he goes a full 20 with them, he will draw a third pension starting the day he retires.  I work entirely from home (as a teacher for our states online k-12)  now and am also in the same pension pool as hubby but chose the 401k instead because he was taking the pension.  The OLD plan was to work another 20 years (into our 50s)  and then draw 3 pensions and have a nice stash in the 401k for fun money.  By this point all the mortgages and student loans would be gone too.  And if we picked up social security later in our 70s even better.  If I was still seeing the world through normal glasses this plan wasn't half bad. 

But I have obviously discovered the error of my ways. 1) unlike hubby I am not overly fond of my job.  It's easy and it's very flexible (which is why I took it, i am insanely overqualified but I write books in my spare time and wanted to be home with the kids) and it's hard to quit when I make a pretty good salary for doing only 3-4 hours of work 5 days a week.  But it's annoying and I also pretty much have to always have my smartphone on to be "available" to my students.  I would rather just write and do the children but between lifestyle creep and debt that hasn't been a feasibleoption until I recently came to the light.  As I said above, hubby is unlikely to retire early.  He LOVES his job.  He has even talked about staying on the reserve force for 2 or 3 days a week after he officially retires and draws pension.

Anywho,

 Right now about 5k goes to service the above debts.  Ironically, mortgage 2 and mortgage 1 are only a few hundred bucks apart because mortgage 2 is a 15 year and 1 is a 30 year.  We are actively trying to sell the second home.  It's rented out for less than the mortgage presently.  And it's an older home in another state that is a money pit because we have to pay someone else to do repairs.  I can see cutting expenses down even further until I'm mostly in line with MMM beyond servicing these debts until they are paid.  But we have complications ...

So these are my 2 BIG questions-

1) how do you get a frugal but non-converted to mustachianism spouse onboard when you don't really have any financial issues or negativity surrounding work to motivate them?  I can definitely sell hubby on aggressively paying off the mortgage and student loan and car because he hates debt.  And even building the nest egg, but some of his consumerism (he likes gear people...military Leo stuff and he eats out a lot even when I pack him food because he eats all the time, he's that chronically fit guy who eats 100 times a day).  I don't want to lower spending temporarily, I want to cut the lifestyle creep permanently.  I'm not sure how to sell that.  Or what books I could get to sell him on that.  We are heavy readers. 

2) what should my goals and investment target even look like to officially FIRE?  (I'm sure some will say I'm really almost already fired since we could live off our pensions with extreme frugal measures, but at a bare minimum to consider myself truly FI, I would want all debts including our mortgages paid off and some kind of sizebale nest egg so we can live on the pension income and rely on the nest egg for our extras like travel, potentially helping children etc).  And I want to quit my job without making hubby uncomfortable.  It's the FU money.  See I still kind of care that getting 55j a year to do almost nothing even though I hate it isn't money I can quite let go of yet.  I want to be able to roll my eyes and drop my 2 weeks notice and say whatever and then roll over that 401k
To some VTSAX.

With the spending even slightly more in line, and especially if I can get the other property sold we will have a ton of money to throw at stuff, so help me !!!  What's my best game plan??

Lepetitange3

  • Guest
Re: Unusual $$ circumstances- need help!!
« Reply #2 on: May 16, 2017, 07:28:44 AM »
Sorry no idea why it posted 3 times...grrr

Mr. Paws

  • 5 O'Clock Shadow
  • *
  • Posts: 53
Re: Unusual $$ circumstances- need help!!
« Reply #3 on: May 16, 2017, 07:37:39 AM »
As far as changing your spouses mind on expenses did you read the sticky above about converting spouses?  Also, why are you renting your other house for less than the mortgage?  (i have to state that i have very little real estate experience except for buying houses i have lived in.)

Lepetitange3

  • Guest
Re: Unusual $$ circumstances- need help!!
« Reply #4 on: May 16, 2017, 07:43:07 AM »
Yes...I've read the entirety of that post, plus the whole blog and most of the forum posts.  A lot of the spouse conversion stuff I've put into place but a lot of the suggestions revolve around starting with a more dire financial situation and/or having a spouse who has any desire to retire earlier.  Hubby already thinks it's pretty clever to intend to retire in our 50s, and he still plans on working after that because he loves his job.

I cannot get rent on the other house that is equal to or more than the mortgage payment.  It's a heavy military location so there are a ton of rentals available.

elaine amj

  • CM*TO 2024 Attendees
  • Walrus Stache
  • *
  • Posts: 5610
  • Location: Ontario
Re: Unusual $$ circumstances- need help!!
« Reply #5 on: May 16, 2017, 08:26:51 AM »
Some ideas:

- I sold it to my husband as having options. It's OK if we end up choosing not to retire early - but everything becomes easier if there are options on the table.
- reduce waste. Why waste money? Also, we really enjoy the rush of getting the most for our buck.
- if YOU retire (while he keeps working), you could spend more time on things you really care about - your kids and your writing. Happy wife, happy life, right?

I am also careful - this isn't a lifestyle of deprivation. This is a lifestyle of optimization. Don't deprive him of his gear - just ask him to consider it more carefully and quit the impulse buys.

My DH just asked me if we could hold a fireworks party at our house (we haven't done it for a few years). This will cost us at least $500 to buy the fireworks (and this is doing it on the cheap with a much smaller show than normal) and our friends are not in the positions to chip in as much as they have in the past (a few of our friends use to chip in $200-300 towards the fireworks). It's absolutely crazy to literally toss $500 into the fire for maybe 30 mins of fun. But we love it...and so do all our friends. We've been mulling it over since we have been really trying to trim expenses. After a lot of discussion over whether it will be "worth it", I think we're going to go ahead and do it.

re: the eating out - he might do better if you sell him on the healthier aspects of eating home-cooked food. None of the nasty stuff they add into food in restaurants. My DH likes to eat out a lot so lately I've just interjected a lot of comments with totals on how much he has been spending and that we need to trim it back a little. He's cut back a bit. But I also upped our budget for dining out when I saw that it was something he really wanted to do. I do keep him abreast on the totals he is spending on eating out so he is aware though. Ultimately I tell him if it's something he really wants to do, just go do it. If it's mindless and just because...well then, that's not a valid reason to spend unnecessarily.

Lepetitange3

  • Guest
Re: Unusual $$ circumstances- need help!!
« Reply #6 on: May 16, 2017, 08:33:41 AM »
Thanks Elaine!  The options and waste reducing are definitely on target for him.  I think he's become concerned that this reads as a lifestyle of deprivation.  So i am definitely going to try to focus him in on the optimization, really paying conscious attention.

He actually loves home cooked meals and takes his main meal to work from home.

  The problem is this man eats like 3 mini meals as well (he works 12 hour shifts).  So the 3 mini meals end up being from fast food or if the rest of the guys sit down to eat, he goes with them for the social aspect and then eats whatever I packed him as one of his other meals.  in uniform, many local businesses also heavily discount meals for law enforcement so it doesn't seem like that much $$ at any one time, but when you put it together it's a lot over the course of a month or year.  And you're right about the health aspect- the food we are talking about is ugh

nereo

  • Senior Mustachian
  • ********
  • Posts: 18174
  • Location: Just south of Canada
    • Here's how you can support science today:
Re: Unusual $$ circumstances- need help!!
« Reply #7 on: May 16, 2017, 08:43:23 AM »
Quote
1) how do you get a frugal but non-converted to mustachianism spouse onboard when you don't really have any financial issues or negativity surrounding work to motivate them? 

2) what should my goals and investment target even look like to officially FIRE? 

1) You've said you have read the sticky on getting a MMM on board, plus the entire blog series of blog posts.  You also mentioned that your spouse "loves his job" and has no desire to fully retire.  So: it may be that he simply does not want the ER-dream many of us here strive for.  You already have a reasonable degree of FI.  The key here is to frame this as: what do you most want to do? It may be he wants to work for another decade. Or perhaps he'll decide once Kid#1 leaves that he wants to travel more.
IME defining what you want our of life is the most important step.

2) this is a highly personal decision based on many factors, including your risk tolerance, income stream(s) (e.g. guaranteed pensions mean you can afford more volatility elsewhere), long-term goals, expenses etc.  Very broadly speaking most of your money needs to be invested.  Conservative approaches will preach a bond-ladder that guarantees your income for the next several years (and flattens out sequence of returns risk).  Others will advocate for >90% equities as your best long-term strategy - particularly if you have some other sources of income like pensions or rental income.
In sum: no one single answer covers everyone.

Lepetitange3

  • Guest
Re: Unusual $$ circumstances- need help!!
« Reply #8 on: May 16, 2017, 08:56:05 AM »
Thanks for the reply!  I think you're right that his desire for super early ER is low.  That being said, he's not opposed to me leaving my job if it can be done.

I think I am overwhelmed by the investment options and ideas in the forum, the blog, and just online other FI sites.  Until now, I had just been planning to take the max into my 401k every year for the next 20 years and then pull the plug while hubby brings in the third pension.  I'm not sure how to best accelerate this given our situation to build that nest egg faster so that at least I can be done with my job sooner.

BrightFIRE

  • Stubble
  • **
  • Posts: 223
  • Location: Philadelphia
Re: Unusual $$ circumstances- need help!!
« Reply #9 on: May 16, 2017, 09:46:03 AM »
You have young children. Would your husband like to have more time with them? Even if he loves his job, he may love time with the kids more.

Try having the open ended discussion of "what's your perfect life?" rather than "don't you want to quit your job?" If necessary, maybe frame it as "sure, you love your job, but if you somehow came into $2 million tomorrow, would anything change?" If he says yes, then that's his FIRE dream. If he wouldn't change a thing, then maybe he's already found what makes him happy.

index

  • Pencil Stache
  • ****
  • Posts: 663
Re: Unusual $$ circumstances- need help!!
« Reply #10 on: May 16, 2017, 10:20:05 AM »
You didn't post income or expenses beyond the 5k (a month?) in debt obligations.

Lady SA

  • Pencil Stache
  • ****
  • Posts: 556
  • Age: 33
  • Location: Midwest
Re: Unusual $$ circumstances- need help!!
« Reply #11 on: May 16, 2017, 10:22:34 AM »
I'm sorry, I'm not entirely following what your problem is.
Is it that you want your DH to fully retire early and he's just not on board?

Sounds like you and DH are following more of a route similar to me and my DH: my DH loves his job, he gets to solve puzzles and problems all day (he's a software engineer). My job, on the other hand, I could take it or leave it. I'm just sort of meh about the whole working thing and I have things I would much rather be doing, like hobbies or painting or raising kids in the future.

We are a decade or more behind you, but essentially our long-term plan is to both work for a few more years and build our nest egg, then I "retire" when we have children. DH would continue working his flexible, fun job and potentially go down to part-time to spend with our family, enough to cover our expenses while we leave our investments untouched. When the kids are older, DH thinks he wants to go back to full-time (with significant negotiating power to ask for more vacation in exchange for not needing as much salary) and I may find a part-time job just to get some adult interaction, or I might stay fully "retired" and work on projects and hobbies.

This is what both of us "want" out of life. *I* want freedom and no longer be beholden to an employer and be able to focus on my children and family. My husband, on the other hand, LOVES getting out of bed every day and solving problems and getting paid. He's not as interested in "total freedom" as I am, but we are compromising when the time comes in that he will ask for less pay in exchange for significantly more vacation time to spend with us.

This is actually a win-win-win for us because DH is happy (and then I am happy), I will have the freedom I crave, and with him working, our investments will grow untouched for many years.


With that said, it sounds like you are unsatisfied with the scenario I'm talking about and I'm not following why exactly. Can you clarify?
Also, you should absolutely work with your DH to cut down on wasteful spending. Streamlining your expenses is always a good idea. You can't optimize what you don't keep track of.
« Last Edit: May 16, 2017, 10:32:09 AM by LadyLB »

CmFtns

  • Pencil Stache
  • ****
  • Posts: 583
  • Age: 34
  • Location: Melbourne, Fl
Re: Unusual $$ circumstances- need help!!
« Reply #12 on: May 16, 2017, 10:32:21 AM »
I don't understand the problem here

you said that you receive $6,000/mo in military pensions from now until the day you die? or $72,000/yr?!

So sell the second house, cut your expenses to an incredibly lavish $70,000/yr lifestyle, quit your job, and live your life. The goal is to get to a point where you have passive income and then live at or under that passive income stream... Well you got it already!!

Let your husband keep his job if he doesn't want to quit and he can waste all that money on fun things he wants

If my assumptions above are correct you are FIRE if you spend $72k/yr or less
« Last Edit: May 16, 2017, 10:34:26 AM by CmFtns »

bigalsmith101

  • Pencil Stache
  • ****
  • Posts: 518
  • Age: 38
  • Location: Lake Stevens, WA
  • Yes, that's really my face.
    • No Jobs, No Responsibilities, No Better Time then Now
Re: Unusual $$ circumstances- need help!!
« Reply #13 on: May 16, 2017, 10:33:41 AM »
Game Plan:

1) Get serious and figure out your priorities. Not generalized. Specific priorities.

2) Communicate effectively with your husband.

3) Realize that if he truly loves his job, and may never want to stop working, that you're plans will have to compromise to each others ideals.

4) Write up a case study, and give us more info so we can realistically help you.

5) Realize that if you can't get by on your current $6k combined monthly pension, there are a LOT of expenses that need to be eliminated.

6) Pack him more food. If he's buying more, he doesn't have enough. ;)
« Last Edit: May 16, 2017, 10:36:03 AM by bigalsmith101 »

Lepetitange3

  • Guest
Re: Unusual $$ circumstances- need help!!
« Reply #14 on: May 16, 2017, 10:35:55 AM »
Bright fire- thanks!  I'm going to see if I can get at his dream.  His job is actually really convenient for the kids because he's a week on / week off.  So one week he works 5 days and the next week he works only 2.  He is already happy with what he has even if we had $2mik more

Lady- I think you've hit the nail on the head, really it's wasteful spending.  And wanting to prioritize some type of fiscal freedom- i.e. If we paid off our mortgage now and aggressively reached to grow our nest egg so we don't have to wait 20 years for my job to build that in my 401k.  We have been coasting because we have plenty of income, no really bad debt and already draw pensions with plans to add more in the future.  In his mind, my job is extremely flexible and I work from home so why would we give up my easy income and 401k building just for even just me to retire sooner?  These ideas of FI are really new and unusual to him.  Because before now, 99% of people would say we are doing beyond well.  But I don't want to do another 20 years even at a really easy job I do from home.  So while it's fine for him to keep going and reach to earn a 3rd pension, I'm concerned that we are spending money just to spend it (seriously we were before I got into this, I literally halved spending in a month by doing next to nothing differently other than opening my eyes to how crazy it's gotten).  And that I'm essentially working to support the wasteful spending, MMM had a blog post that vaguely referenced this once..I'm working a job I don't really like to afford nothing.  But Im not sure how to get him onboard with greater FI when as you say, he's happy with his job and his component of the plan.

Lepetitange3

  • Guest
Re: Unusual $$ circumstances- need help!!
« Reply #15 on: May 16, 2017, 10:42:53 AM »
Thanks guys!  I didn't post a full case study because our income vastly exceeds our debt requirements.  I am working on selling the other home.  Our pensions aren't enough because of the 5kx12 mortgage/car/student loan so 60k a year situation.  The car will be paid off in another year (yes I realize I should trade down per MMM but we have 1 car and we drive our cars until they die or in the case of the lady, got totaled because someone ran a red light into us...hubby will not compromise on changing out cars). 

I did halve our expenses in the month since I found this site.  You really don't even want to know, but it's epic face punch worthy.  He didn't even notice the changes for the most part we were just throwing money away. 

I'm concerned that until the mortgages go, my job is at least necessary even if he wants to always keep his job.  I have passive income from other sources too that's random and not included because it can't be counted on (authors revenues from books).  Plus, it's a couple thing.  We communicate really well and had a plan but I'm the one who has seen the light and wants to make a change (and wants to ditch my day job). 

bigalsmith101

  • Pencil Stache
  • ****
  • Posts: 518
  • Age: 38
  • Location: Lake Stevens, WA
  • Yes, that's really my face.
    • No Jobs, No Responsibilities, No Better Time then Now
Re: Unusual $$ circumstances- need help!!
« Reply #16 on: May 16, 2017, 10:59:19 AM »
Thanks guys!  I didn't post a full case study because our income vastly exceeds our debt requirements.  I am working on selling the other home.  Our pensions aren't enough because of the 5kx12 mortgage/car/student loan so 60k a year situation.  The car will be paid off in another year (yes I realize I should trade down per MMM but we have 1 car and we drive our cars until they die or in the case of the lady, got totaled because someone ran a red light into us...hubby will not compromise on changing out cars). 

I did halve our expenses in the month since I found this site.  You really don't even want to know, but it's epic face punch worthy.  He didn't even notice the changes for the most part we were just throwing money away. 

I'm concerned that until the mortgages go, my job is at least necessary even if he wants to always keep his job.  I have passive income from other sources too that's random and not included because it can't be counted on (authors revenues from books).  Plus, it's a couple thing.  We communicate really well and had a plan but I'm the one who has seen the light and wants to make a change (and wants to ditch my day job).

You've got 6k monthly pension, at $72k a year. You've got $60k of major expenses.

Are you suggesting that you can't currently cover the rest of your monthly expenses on your husbands income without the aid of yours as well?

You still haven't prioritized your goals. Simply telling us, "We bring in $135-$145k a year, and spend a shit load, but can trim lots of costs, and only have one car" doesn't really paint a very clear picture.

It sounds like,

#1 Sell the house of out state, even if it's at a slight loss, as it's draining your resources monthly and is not worth keeping.
#2 Only pay off the car early if it's interest rate is higher than 4%.
#3 Same principle applies to your current residence.
#4 Trim the fat of your monthly expenses like you say you can.
#5 MAX OUT your 401k option at work, fully contribute to his pension, and max out 2 IRA's.
#6 Put it all down on paper/spreadsheet, and physically show your husband how easy it now is to cover ALL of your expenses, contribute to retirement investments, and maintain your lavish lifestyle while allowing your to quit your job and stay home with your children and pack his massive lunches so he doesn't feel the need to buy more food. 
#5.

Lady SA

  • Pencil Stache
  • ****
  • Posts: 556
  • Age: 33
  • Location: Midwest
Re: Unusual $$ circumstances- need help!!
« Reply #17 on: May 16, 2017, 11:01:35 AM »
Quote
In his mind, my job is extremely flexible and I work from home so why would we give up my easy income and 401k building just for even just me to retire sooner?
Quote
But I don't want to do another 20 years even at a really easy job I do from home.  So while it's fine for him to keep going and reach to earn a 3rd pension, I'm concerned that we are spending money just to spend it
Quote
I'm essentially working to support the wasteful spending
Quote
Im not sure how to get him onboard with greater FI

Ah, ok. I think I've got it. Essentially, your DH wants to continue to coast along how you both have been, but YOU want freedom. So your essential question is instead, "how do I get DH on board with ME retiring early?"
You would need to run some numbers, but likely you're at the point where having YOU working is just redundant. EDIT: just saw your update regarding until the mortgages are gone, you still need both salaries. Maybe a case study with your new current expenses would be worthwhile and we can help find more optimizations in your budget. And really prioritize ditching the other house, its like an anchor around your neck.

so:
1) cut down expenses. You've done this already, but also ensure there is a little wiggle room in the budget so he doesn't feel deprived, just making sure his purchases are smart rather than mindless.
2) run the numbers to see if DH's salary is enough to cover the new expenses. If yes, good. If no, are there any further optimizations you can do?
3) come up with a plan of how things will look and work if you stop working. What is your fallback plan if it falls apart? Build in some flexibility, perhaps the possibility of getting another part-time job down the road if you want.
4) Talk to DH about YOUR perfect life, how you want to stop working and focus on things YOU love, and how it is within reach if he will support you. Show him the numbers, lay out your plan. Address his concerns and just have a conversation about how you are feeling worn out, frustrated, and desperately want a break. If the numbers are in your favor there's no reason for him to object.
5) create shared goals with him, whether that is a paid off mortgage or xyz amount saved. He may have a certain point where he feels comfortable with you no longer having an income, but you really need to have a conversation with him about what you want, what he wants, and what compromises you can agree on.
« Last Edit: May 16, 2017, 11:12:47 AM by LadyLB »

nereo

  • Senior Mustachian
  • ********
  • Posts: 18174
  • Location: Just south of Canada
    • Here's how you can support science today:
Re: Unusual $$ circumstances- need help!!
« Reply #18 on: May 16, 2017, 11:04:41 AM »

Lady- I think you've hit the nail on the head, really it's wasteful spending.  And wanting to prioritize some type of fiscal freedom- i.e. If we paid off our mortgage now and aggressively reached to grow our nest egg so we don't have to wait 20 years for my job to build that in my 401k.  We have been coasting because we have plenty of income,...

It's certainly easier when you are a high-income couple to coast along.
For us it helped to 1) have a goal and 2) frame every purchasing decision in light of this goal.

our goal is to reach greater FI so that we can prioritize spending more time with family while working occasionally (we both love what we do but we don't want to put the 60+hour weeks common in our field).
Each time we purchase something we ask how this impacts our goal - I know each $216 I spend is another week I have to work full-time in 6 years when I am hoping to be completely FI. So it becomes: is this lavish meal out worth an extra week, or are we just doing this because we are lazy?  We are by no means depriving ourselves, but this exercise has helped cut out all the meaningless purchases and now when we spend money it's on things and experiences we truly value.

swick

  • Magnum Stache
  • ******
  • Posts: 2874
Re: Unusual $$ circumstances- need help!!
« Reply #19 on: May 16, 2017, 11:07:47 AM »
MOD NOTE: Topics Merged. In the future, if it multi-posts, please delete the content from the double posts, say something like "delete" and use the "Report to Mod"  button so we can delete them for you. Thanks!

CmFtns

  • Pencil Stache
  • ****
  • Posts: 583
  • Age: 34
  • Location: Melbourne, Fl
Re: Unusual $$ circumstances- need help!!
« Reply #20 on: May 16, 2017, 11:10:16 AM »
Thanks guys!  I didn't post a full case study because our income vastly exceeds our debt requirements.  I am working on selling the other home.  Our pensions aren't enough because of the 5kx12 mortgage/car/student loan so 60k a year situation.  The car will be paid off in another year (yes I realize I should trade down per MMM but we have 1 car and we drive our cars until they die or in the case of the lady, got totaled because someone ran a red light into us...hubby will not compromise on changing out cars). 

I did halve our expenses in the month since I found this site.  You really don't even want to know, but it's epic face punch worthy.  He didn't even notice the changes for the most part we were just throwing money away. 

I'm concerned that until the mortgages go, my job is at least necessary even if he wants to always keep his job.  I have passive income from other sources too that's random and not included because it can't be counted on (authors revenues from books).  Plus, it's a couple thing.  We communicate really well and had a plan but I'm the one who has seen the light and wants to make a change (and wants to ditch my day job).

Your right you can't quit your job unless you lower expenses but the point is that you and your husband do not need to worry about investing or gathering more money to be FIRE because your pension covers what most here would consider a lavish retirement. You just need to control spending.

-First, Sell the second house at a fair market value if it isn't selling than it isn't at market value
-Second, get your random miscellaneous expenses under control and i mean aggressively gut this category... if you don't know where your money is going then it's not going toward something important.
-You said the other 50k student loan would be forgiven after 10 years and also said that your husband wanted to keep working so just pay minimums with husbands salary until he reaches 10 years therefore this is not part of your 72k retirement budget.
-You can trade down your car or just pay off your car with you and your husbands excess money over the next few months then you can quit
« Last Edit: May 16, 2017, 11:12:42 AM by CmFtns »

Lepetitange3

  • Guest
Re: Unusual $$ circumstances- need help!!
« Reply #21 on: May 16, 2017, 11:23:03 AM »
Thank you to everyone!

I think we have been coasting because our income is high, and we had always been told our debts were "good" "fine" etc.  and yay you also have a 401k and money in the bank so work 20 more years and you're set to continue on the wasteful spending train.  Because what else would people do?  They would FIRE that's what and stop being so stupidly unconscious about where their money goes. 

The suggestions for talking to DH I will work on this week.  I'm also going to look to trim expenses further, but I need him onboard for the changes to be sustainable.  I spent the last month cutting the easy fat to see how much would attract his ire.  I've been using a lot of everyone's good advice from previous case studies so I didn't want anyone to have to restate the obvious.

I have solid yearly earning from writing, and he's really supportive of that.  I've just always had a day job in addition.  My current job that is from home was actually a large pay cut from my previous...and there's a resistance there because I can still write, I stay home with our kids, but I still have this annoying 2 hours of nonsense 5 days a week I don't want to do.  But from the normal perspective, it's easy money that doesn't really take away much from the things I prefer to be doing  so why give the income up.  It's difficult to sell that side in addition to the rest of this being new conceptually.

bigalsmith101

  • Pencil Stache
  • ****
  • Posts: 518
  • Age: 38
  • Location: Lake Stevens, WA
  • Yes, that's really my face.
    • No Jobs, No Responsibilities, No Better Time then Now
Re: Unusual $$ circumstances- need help!!
« Reply #22 on: May 16, 2017, 11:33:06 AM »
Can you cover your expenses on your current income, WITHOUT your military pensions?

If not, that might be a trigger point for your husband. You won't lose your pensions, but it may be interesting to point out, "Husband. We spend so much damn money, that we couldn't afford our lifestyle without our pensions. Doesn't that seem ridiculous?"

Lepetitange3

  • Guest
Re: Unusual $$ circumstances- need help!!
« Reply #23 on: May 16, 2017, 11:48:02 AM »
Thanks bigAl :)

Yes, but barely, given the old spending pattern. 

Under the one that's been in place for a month, without any effort on his part, we can easily.  If I can get him onboard, which I think your question will help with giving the historical spending (easy to see now because I put us on Mint), we can go down a lot further without really even touching what is a ridiculously lavish lifestyle.

The_Pretender

  • 5 O'Clock Shadow
  • *
  • Posts: 47
  • Location: Midwest
Re: Unusual $$ circumstances- need help!!
« Reply #24 on: May 16, 2017, 01:31:50 PM »
He appears to love his job to infinity and beyond... NOW, but he isn't his own boss.  I cannot recall reading, but I believe he is police officer?  What if a new mayor or elected police chief came into office and decided to gut the police force or make the things he loves about the job to go away?  Would he still love his job? 

Sounds like all the advice above is good.   

work on communication.  Seems like you have been together long enough to understand that life changes.  I recall you saying that you have a plan now.  How long has this been your plan? 2 years? 5? 10?  Looking back on my married life, plans last about 1-3 years.  If you always stick to the plan, you may miss opportunities since it wasn't on the "Plan".  When you two committed to this plan, you both were excited!  who wouldn't be... knowing that they could retire mid-50s a decade before the "norm".  You are now at the point where things have changed in your life.  You came across this whole FI sub-culture.  How living in the modern world is very affordable.  Heck look at the MMM family, they can live sub-30K for the past decade.  Comes down to re-aligning the plan and making adjustments.  Talk through trade-offs.  What would make him feel comfortable?  Would you need to work 1 year saving every penny you earn?  Show how your salary (albeit nice) really is not necessary in impacting overall quality of family life.


Lepetitange3

  • Guest
Re: Unusual $$ circumstances- need help!!
« Reply #25 on: May 16, 2017, 02:03:25 PM »
Thanks Pretender.  I think that's where we are at.  We have been together a long time by most standards ;) yay for exceeding societal standards there.  It just needs to be something we both can get on board with even if he's to a lesser extent interested in FIRE and just good for FI. 

I really appreciate all the thoughts from everyone.  Even comments on other threads have been really insightful for my situation, and while we obviously have the means to do the whole FI thing sooner than many, everyone's experience and advice is spot on and very helpful.  I'm an expert in another field unrelated to my present job (my old profession), and I think the Mustahian  community is really the experts on FI. 

frugaldrummer

  • Pencil Stache
  • ****
  • Posts: 846
Re: Unusual $$ circumstances- need help!!
« Reply #26 on: May 16, 2017, 11:30:48 PM »
Just one cautionary word. It sounds like you're in a good position financially, but I want you to imagine the following scenario:
- you give up your "easy, profitable" job
- a few years pass
- your husband then leaves you for another woman

Would you be ok financially? Would you regret having given up that easy, profitable job? Would you make different financial choices now if you knew this was looming in your future?

Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying there is anything wrong with your relationship and not trying to hex you. But as a woman who mommy-tracked my career for years, and whose husband of 24 years left in a cloud of midlife crisis when he turned 50 - I just want to say, no matter HOW solid you think your relationship is, stuff happens. And the wife who put her career on the back burner usually gets the shaft. And police work is a high risk profession for infidelity (stress + opportunity).

So just make sure that whatever decisions you make, you're not going to be screwed if your marriage breaks up. Take it from someone older and wiser.

Lepetitange3

  • Guest
Re: Unusual $$ circumstances- need help!!
« Reply #27 on: May 17, 2017, 07:12:48 AM »
Thanks frugal, and I'm so sorry to hear your story.  I draw one of the military pensions, and I actually out  ranked my husband when we retired from the military,, so of the two, it's the greater amount ;)  the military has the same high incidence of infidelity but hubby and I have always done fine.

 But I do think you're right that even when you're part of a solid couple who are both trying to FIRE, it's good to think about what if things change relationship wise.  I don't think that's going to happen in our case, because we weathered multiple deployments on both sides just fine, but you're right that no one ever really knows.

 Part 2 would be that we have been married so long that I would be vested into any pension he received from law enforcement as well based on the way the rules look around here.  So in my situation at least, I could give up the easy profitable job, at the point where even if that happened in my future, I'd just have to downsize to a nice small condo on the beach ;) and draw my pension. So I'd be ok financially, and frankly my life wouldn't be as lavish as it is now, but my pension is more than the entire MMM family spends in a year, so I'd be ok money wise.  I could also go back to my former profession  before the easy, profitable job (read extremely profitable but insane job) where my expertise and skill set were so high need and unusual that I could probably take 3 decades off and still go back. 

I hope despite the fact that the husband was a jerk, you are getting progress now to your own FI or FIRE or whatever your ideal looks like.

Dee18

  • Handlebar Stache
  • *****
  • Posts: 2299
Re: Unusual $$ circumstances- need help!!
« Reply #28 on: May 17, 2017, 01:45:43 PM »
+1 to selling the other house, even at a loss.  I suspect that this will give you even more of a psychological boost than a financial boost.  Houses are a lot of work! Then you can use that money from mortgage payment 2 to invest.  Set up automatic contributions to whatever investment accounts you choose so you don't think, "oh, we have so much in the checking account why not....eat out, throw a lavish birthday party, buy the kids unnecessary new clothes, etc." 

Lepetitange3

  • Guest
Re: Unusual $$ circumstances- need help!!
« Reply #29 on: May 17, 2017, 03:22:43 PM »
Yes, I think that's exactly what I'm aiming for Dee.  I appreciate the idea/thoughts

Lulee

  • Bristles
  • ***
  • Posts: 252
  • Location: NH
  • "We'll jump off that bridge when we come to it."
Re: Unusual $$ circumstances- need help!!
« Reply #30 on: May 19, 2017, 12:27:57 PM »
I think mustachism is a great thing but like anyone making large lifestyle changes, it can be disruptive and therefore family and friends may resist its impacts on their lives even if the logical part of their brains agrees with the precepts.  Having seen this a lot over my lifetime with people either undergoing a religious conversion or revamping their behavior to get rid of bad health habits like smoking or drinking, I’d recommend you slow down in your “proselytizing” to your husband.  You don't need to risk alienating him to “The Way” by pushing hard as financially you guys are secure.

While you continue to work on easy for him to miss cutbacks in spending, you can be planting seeds in his mind and giving them time to grow.  Ask him questions about the future like how can we improve the quality of the food you eat while at work (send multiple small meals maybe?) or how much should we be saving for kids college costs.  Then sit back for a while and return to it later.  It’ll likely have been percolating away on the back burner of his consciousness and he may have some really good ideas.  And you won't have built up any resentment by making YOU the source of all changes.

I’m convinced that there’s an equally powerful opposite to hedonic adaption/lifestyle creep though hanged if I know its name.  I’m also convinced that if you go at big changes in a slow but methodical manner, the changes stick better.

Think of it as if your former lifestyle had you guys 300 feet underwater --- rapid ascension is not recommended unless someone is in crisis which you two are not.  Instead, you need to come up a distance, pause to adjust, then ascend another ways up before your next pause, and so  slowly make your way up to the surface safely.  Safely being defined in your circumstance as both of you in agreement with the changes being made and the plans for the future.


Lepetitange3

  • Guest
Re: Unusual $$ circumstances- need help!!
« Reply #31 on: June 03, 2017, 03:10:15 PM »
Thanks to everyone and quick update- I'm officially FIRE!  We reviewed everything l, decided my full time work income was not needed, and the pensions are plenty so I'm free!  The idea of being mortgage free appealed massively to hubby, so we have a hard savings goal to kill the mortgage rapidly, and then add to our savings/investment accounts after that to give us a decent nest egg as a hedge against changes to the 2 pensions we draw now and the 3rd we will add if hubby stays in the job he loves (likely).  Either way, we took our expenses down to be = to 1 pensions worth.  Thank you to everyone!

ambimammular

  • Bristles
  • ***
  • Posts: 424
  • Age: 48
  • Location: Indiana
Re: Unusual $$ circumstances- need help!!
« Reply #32 on: June 04, 2017, 02:10:38 PM »
I am so pleased! Congratulations!