I tried it. I quit after one box.
They seemed to have paid 0 attention to anything I put in my profile or on my pinterest board. I spent probably 2 hours Pinning stuff and filling that profile out.
I was not thrilled with my box. Most of it seemed low quality and not at all my style. Worse - the sizing was way weird. I got a dress that fit perfectly, but a pair of pants that was about three sizes too small. How is that possible? I tried following up to figure out what went wrong with the sizing, but it was a bit like banging my head against the wall.
I kept the dress - one that I never in a million years would have chosen for myself, but looks pretty sweet on me. I get a lot of compliments about it when I wear it. I mostly only kept it because of the $20 styling fee (yep, they do that for a reason), but the dress really was a winner. It's funny, because I hate the color combination and pattern every time I look at it, but then I love it once it's on.
Here's what I got:
dress - good quality, very nice dress
pants - good quality, if I could have obtained the correct size, I might have kept them, even though they are more expensive than I normally buy
three cheap shirts - and I mean appeared to be poor quality - and not my style - and they were $50 each. A t-shirt better rock my world if I'm paying $50 for it. Also, why did I have two t-shirts and one "club" shirt when I wanted specifically business attire for an accountant. No where in my profile did I say I was the drunk CPA who gets clients at the local dance club.