I bought a brand new VW Jetta in 1996. Not very mustachian, I know. But on the flip side, I'm still driving the same car today 211k miles later. My parents, sister, and friends have all gone through multiple cars each in that time. For the last decade I've been on the receiving end of more and more explicit jokes about my Jetta. Not once have I wanted to buy a new one - why would I, when this one still works?
Though for reference, when I do buy a new car I will probably not buy another VW. It's fun to drive and easy to find one with a manual transmission, but I've had more than my share of mechanical issues - especially with the electrical and exhaust systems.