Those who suggested the excellent public schools were told "that's not an option" with no reason given.
Funny, the wife and I both went to public schools. We've got 5 college degrees between the 2 of us and are pretty successful, on track to retire by 40. I wonder what the extra value is of sending them to private school? I think a lot of a child's success depends on their level of "give a shit" (and their parents').
I wanted to ask, but, I didn't want to ask, IYKWIM, because the folks who mentioned it were shot down so quickly.
I went to a private school, despite being in a top public school district. Being a special snowflake dragonkin, I just wasn't happy at the public school. Didn't get along with the peer group, teacher bored me, etc. Sure, I could have done fine in public -- gotten good grades, had the same university prospects. In other words, I would have had academic success regardless.
But I was happier at the private school because it was small (I knew literally every kid there), small classes, highly involved teachers, and an education philosophy that taught me more about life. In public, I would have just been wasting a significant portion of the day. In private I was more engaged.
That's certainly not to say that it was
necessary, financially smart, or universal to every school and kid. But I can say for certain that I, personally, am a better person for it. I'm happy to send my kid to public school if that works for them. If it's not working, though, I'd consider the expense of private.
edit: more to the point of my original comment, which was shockingly mocked (shocking!), if I lived in a bad school district, I'm still sure my kid could have academic success. Maybe even more so, if the peer group was disadvantaged. But some bad schools are bad because they are in an economically challenged warzone. Living in constant fear of personal safety, despite having good grades, with no access to good enrichment activities within the school system, I'm not sure that's a definition of success I want to adopt.