So it turns out I'm not organized enough to hack with credit cards. While we have been able to do some traveling over the last few years, I just realized I've paid $838 over the last three years in credit card fees because I didn't shut down the cards at the one year mark!
Closed the offending cards, I'm thinking I'll just stick to the no-fee-ever rewards cards for a while. Right now that would be the Amazon Prime card and Barclays.