Let’s see if the renounce their entire income from the civil list and pay out of their own pockets for the round-the-clock security they will require for the rest of their lives before we congratulate them.
It’s nice to say you want to be independent, but the reality isn’t so easy.
This was my thought too.
Security for family members of Very Important People are often to prevent VIP from caving to demands, rather than directly of benefit for the family. It completely burns me that the US pays SO MUCH for Trump's family security (more than any other Presidential family in history, reports say), many of whom don't do anything for the public, but I'd never suggest that it be withdrawn unless they can pay for it themselves.
To be clear, it's higher because of the 1) greater number of kids he has, 2) older age of kids+grandkids, who travel separately from Trump & Melanie as a result. That doesn't burn me, it's 3) the sheer frequency and lavishness of their personal trips, the multiple residences, the choice to live separately for months in a horrible location to provide security, which impacts the security costs. E.g. if the protected stays in an expensive hotel overseas, the protectors need to as well. If the protected chooses to live apart from her husband for months in a poorly secured location, the public pays for the additional required security. And if the protected stays at his personal hotel, well, the protector gets to pay the protected for that privilege as well, which is particularly galling how it lines his own pockets...
If you want to talk about the Economic Outpatient Care (EOC) of the entire British aristocracy on the other hand, that's a valid discussion, though unlikely to change anytime soon. But we actually don't know yet if they intend to forego that as well (unlikely, as it's not related to their public duties they are giving up). They have large personal inheritances that they may choose to live on along with any money they receive from running their charity. Let's applaud rather than condemn this first and extremely unusual step by a member of the immediate British royal family.
ETA to clarify for the nonmustachans that EOC is Economic Outpatient Care