Just finished watching a webinar on the role of compassion in therapy - it is designed for clinicians so might not be a great fit for what you are dealing with, but they spent some time at the end talking about compassion focused therapy and the three circle model of how the threat, drive and compassion systems play into our emotional and physical well-being. Thought immediately of what you are dealing with. Here is a intro level discussion of the concepts:
https://blog.timlebon.com/p/compassion-focussed-therapy-cft.html
The link to the booklet he mentions explaining CFT for patients is broken, but you can find it here:
https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=1&ved=2ahUKEwis8KrwjrPlAhUXqZ4KHVb9ApMQFjAAegQIAhAC&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.getselfhelp.co.uk%2Fdocs%2FGILBERT-COMPASSION-HANDOUT.pdf&usg=AOvVaw3Z9KBE2XrC5u7RVKeVlk6E
Thank-you for this. It seems to have overlapping elements to the inner critic course I'm taking. I've downloaded the guide.
The thing about a "first love" is that you really believe a new person can grant you entry into a new world. It's never actually true, but it can feel true. After a few rinse & repeats, you realize that it's not true... but you still remember that first falling-in-love as magic.
It sounds like you've had that experience just once, and are trying to hang onto it, and it's slipping away from you. I don't think it really matters how old your spouse is -- it's the "being granted entry into a new world" that matters, and it is just not a sustainable thing.
I think you're very wise in understanding that a sweet young thing would give you a cheap imitation of the "new world" thing for a short time, and then leave you far worse off. But I think you're very unwise in continuing to be, or wanting to continue to be, in love with your wife. Of course you should love her, and of course you do. But "in-love" goes away and it's supposed to go away. It's just laying way too much on a human being to expect them to make your world magic forever.
You are correct that I've had this experience once. I mean, I had "crushes" in high school that felt like something, but nothing in comparison to the emotions felt with my first, reciprocated love. Who would have thought when we started out that years later years later we'd still be together. Somehow, we managed to side-step a number of landmines which allowed our relationship to continue. I've done a lot of reading over the years on what to expect through different phases of a relationship. The 7 year itches, the 5 love languages, etc. I'm "book smart" about it, but do not have the experience which leaves me vulnerable. I've read that for most, the euphoric "butterflies in the stomach lasts for a year or two." The "lust" phase. It's what feels like intense love, but it's not. Love is what comes afterwards. Love is like a calm ocean with soft, calming waves, not waves thrashing about on a rock face with intensity.
And I'm blessed because I get to share my life with the person I experienced "first love" with. This is comforting in many ways. I don't have the feeling of screwing up and losing my "true love" and I don't have regrets about past failed relationships. Equally, I didn't get to learn and grow from past failures. And to add fire to the flames of confusion, our relationship was star-crossed. Forbidden by my parents, long distance after 8 months for two years, age difference separating us, peer pressure and ridicule... But despite all that, we seemed to work.
And as a result, my wife and I have been together for 23 years and we've managed to build a rather successful life and be on the cusp of FIRE.
But tie that into long-term anxiety and supposed bipolar hypomania and I'm struggling. So the beginning phase of our relationship was really a barrage of different emotions. The euphoric high was magnified and the constant "break-ups" because of external forces were heart breaking.
I'm not trying to have my own pity party and it's real enough to me that I'm examining through therapy and a variety of courses to try to understand. My benefits suck so I'm paying for all of this out of pocket. Being somewhat mustachian, thousands and thousands of dollars is a lot of money. But I have hope that it will help me uncover something.
You really need to stop looking for magic where it can't be found, and look for it where it can be. You're trying to do something that can't be done. It's far less destructive to try to find the magic with your same old spouse than to try to find it with a new sweet young thing -- but it won't be any more successful.
This is an interesting observation and I didn't think of it this way. I needed to re-read to understand what I think you were saying. So my mind is taking me back 23 years and I'm ruminating the beginning of the relationship of my wife. The mental image that's created is both of us in the car, late at night with nothing but the glow of the moon
illuminating her face 3 feet in front of me. At that time, we weren't in love yet. It was just fun. It was new. It wasn't even in that euphoric state yet.
But fast forward 23 years, I find I'm looking through rose coloured glasses and adding all sorts of powerful emotions to that memory. Those emotions didn't exist at the time. I'm adding them based on what I know now. And I find that it's triggering the "magic" for a couple seconds and then fizzling out. So it's a hugely intense sense of loss and heartbreak. The emotion is misfiring.
It's almost like the scene in American Beauty at the end when Lester Burnham is remembering different moments in his life. The scene in particular that hits me hard is at 3:25 (
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NtbbqjiFaGY) where he says "And Carolyn" which shows a fun, carefree version of his wife on the ride laughing and smiling. This vivid memory for him is my glow of the moon illuminating my wife's face back in 1996.
I'm poking at something that's fleeting and to your point, I'm not going to be successful.
But this is only a small part of it. My bigger challenge is that as time moves forward, the further we get from "that place" of magic in time. My mind plays games on me. 20 years feels like yesterday, and so 20 years will go by in no time. It's disorienting. And all of a sudden, my wife is the age of her parents who are of ill health (assuming nothing gets her before hand).
My brain is playing tricks on me and it's exceptionally cruel.
Also, my brain swings like a pendulum. I'm trying not to repeat or contradict myself in my responses but if I do, it's because it's how I'm feeling at that particular time. I appreciate everyone's patience and insight.