Author Topic: Dad with two daughters, want to protect them  (Read 9389 times)

ministashy

  • Stubble
  • **
  • Posts: 233
Re: Dad with two daughters, want to protect them
« Reply #100 on: February 03, 2023, 02:04:52 PM »
I would agree with almost all the recommendations in this thread, with one exception - please do not send your daughters to 'a' self-defense class.  A single class - or even a short series of classes - will not build up the muscle memory or instincts they will need if they ever find themselves in a physical altercation.  At best, it will give them some theoretical good tips - 'check the backseat of your car before getting in', 'always stay alert and know who's around you', etc - and at worst it will give them a false sense of confidence that they can break a hold or escape someone who has grabbed them when they've only practiced a move once or twice, usually against people who are not trying very hard to hold on to them. 

I would absolutely recommend you enroll them in a good (not sport) martial arts course, at least by their preteens, and keep them in it long enough that they know how to maintain their balance, they know how to react when they're being grappled or shoved to the ground, and that they know how to throw a solid punch or a kick without even thinking about it.  Look for ones that focus on practical self defense --kicks, punches, grappling, falling and getting back up quickly--rather than super-flashy tournament or Hollywood-esque moves.  Enroll in it yourself so you know the school and you know what they'll be teaching your kids. 

Hopefully they'll never have to use any of it.  But as other people have said, it will teach confidence, self-awareness of possible threats, and just the way they move and hold themselves will likely deter a lot of potential predators, whether they're strangers or boyfriends or something in between.

RetiredAt63

  • CMTO 2023 Attendees
  • Senior Mustachian
  • *
  • Posts: 20848
  • Location: Eastern Ontario, Canada
Re: Dad with two daughters, want to protect them
« Reply #101 on: February 03, 2023, 03:06:43 PM »
Hopefully they'll never have to use any of it.  But as other people have said, it will teach confidence, self-awareness of possible threats, and just the way they move and hold themselves will likely deter a lot of potential predators, whether they're strangers or boyfriends or something in between.

I enrolled DD in karate*, she got to Brown Belt and then stopped - Black Belt has legal implications.  We both figured that a boy would not want to date a girl with a brown belt if he wanted an easy target.    Plus between dance and soccer she had a mean kick.

Not all of her boyfriends were wonderful human beings, but learning how to avoid those is a different kind of knowledge.  Not being pressured to marry the first half-decent one who came along helped.  Her husband is a really nice guy and is being a great dad.


*When she was little there was a story in the news about a hockey player** (older teen) whose team lost a super important game.  He drove his girlfriend out to a deserted area and beat her up, badly.  I wanted to do everything possible to make sure that never happened to DD.

**Not all Canadians are nice.

Villanelle

  • Walrus Stache
  • *******
  • Posts: 6702
Re: Dad with two daughters, want to protect them
« Reply #102 on: February 03, 2023, 05:40:03 PM »
Hopefully they'll never have to use any of it.  But as other people have said, it will teach confidence, self-awareness of possible threats, and just the way they move and hold themselves will likely deter a lot of potential predators, whether they're strangers or boyfriends or something in between.

I enrolled DD in karate*, she got to Brown Belt and then stopped - Black Belt has legal implications.  We both figured that a boy would not want to date a girl with a brown belt if he wanted an easy target.    Plus between dance and soccer she had a mean kick.

Not all of her boyfriends were wonderful human beings, but learning how to avoid those is a different kind of knowledge.  Not being pressured to marry the first half-decent one who came along helped.  Her husband is a really nice guy and is being a great dad.


*When she was little there was a story in the news about a hockey player** (older teen) whose team lost a super important game.  He drove his girlfriend out to a deserted area and beat her up, badly.  I wanted to do everything possible to make sure that never happened to DD.

**Not all Canadians are nice.

What are the legal implications of earning a black belt?  (Lest tone be misconstrued, I'm genuinely curious.)  Google mostly turned up "myth" answers to very specific questions, so I'm wondering what you've learned or experienced.  Or how Canada treats the issue.

Kris

  • Walrus Stache
  • *******
  • Posts: 7362
Re: Dad with two daughters, want to protect them
« Reply #103 on: February 03, 2023, 06:23:33 PM »
Hopefully they'll never have to use any of it.  But as other people have said, it will teach confidence, self-awareness of possible threats, and just the way they move and hold themselves will likely deter a lot of potential predators, whether they're strangers or boyfriends or something in between.

I enrolled DD in karate*, she got to Brown Belt and then stopped - Black Belt has legal implications.  We both figured that a boy would not want to date a girl with a brown belt if he wanted an easy target.    Plus between dance and soccer she had a mean kick.

Not all of her boyfriends were wonderful human beings, but learning how to avoid those is a different kind of knowledge.  Not being pressured to marry the first half-decent one who came along helped.  Her husband is a really nice guy and is being a great dad.


*When she was little there was a story in the news about a hockey player** (older teen) whose team lost a super important game.  He drove his girlfriend out to a deserted area and beat her up, badly.  I wanted to do everything possible to make sure that never happened to DD.

**Not all Canadians are nice.

What are the legal implications of earning a black belt?  (Lest tone be misconstrued, I'm genuinely curious.)  Google mostly turned up "myth" answers to very specific questions, so I'm wondering what you've learned or experienced.  Or how Canada treats the issue.

I am genuinely curious too.

RetiredAt63

  • CMTO 2023 Attendees
  • Senior Mustachian
  • *
  • Posts: 20848
  • Location: Eastern Ontario, Canada
Re: Dad with two daughters, want to protect them
« Reply #104 on: February 03, 2023, 07:54:28 PM »
Being a Black Belt is basically the equivalent of being armed.  If DD hurt someone she would be legally treated differently with a Black Belt than with a Brown Belt.  Or so she told me, and I assume her sensei told her.

I didn't worry about it, I figured for my purposes brown belt was fine.

Any Canadian criminal lawyers here?  Was she correct?