The Money Mustache Community

General Discussion => Welcome and General Discussion => Topic started by: jim555 on February 11, 2018, 04:14:42 PM

Title: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: jim555 on February 11, 2018, 04:14:42 PM
I hope they have a backup plan, doesn't sound like it.

http://www.tampabay.com/sold-everything-to-sail-the-world-boat-sank-next-day
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: PDXTabs on February 11, 2018, 04:24:38 PM
They had no insurance.
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: chasesfish on February 11, 2018, 04:29:49 PM
I saw that....insane.

And how do you own a house you can't afford to replace without insurance?
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: abhe8 on February 11, 2018, 04:50:00 PM
Wow. How did they have NO money? How were they planning to eat or feed their dog while sailing around?
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: Zamboni on February 11, 2018, 05:03:18 PM
It seems like maybe they had this dream of sailing from port to port, docking to work tables for while or something?

In any case, their plan definitely did not seem very solid . . .
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: SC93 on February 11, 2018, 05:41:01 PM
That's about the same plan, difference scenario, lots of people have..... none. I used to not plan 1 minute ahead.
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: Bateaux on February 11, 2018, 06:23:37 PM
Pretty much gave up on the boat living idea after last hurricane season.   So fragile.   Even with insurance you lose a lot.
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: shunkman on February 11, 2018, 07:07:46 PM
Sounds like inexperience and poor navigation skills. Boating safely can be as much of a challenge as flying an aircraft only there is no license required for boating.
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: Bateaux on February 11, 2018, 08:53:36 PM
That old boat and their level of experience does not allow for insurance.
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: SC93 on February 11, 2018, 09:01:43 PM
Still, 5k cost + 5k repairs. Not as if it's the end of the world.

Also, don't people usually get insurance on the thing that is 100% of their NW?

With what money?
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: the_fixer on February 11, 2018, 10:25:47 PM
The cost of insurance that would repair / replace the boat would likely not be worth it by the time you got a fresh survey, made the required repairs and paid the premiums.

Pretty common with older budget boats.

Right or wrong at least they had the courage to cast off the lines and give it a go many have failed but there have also been some epic journeys that have started out that way.

https://youtu.be/lAye0mf2A8g


https://youtu.be/2lwbHYOFD-4



Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: edgema on February 12, 2018, 04:33:15 AM
Since the success of youtube channels like La Vagabonde there have been many people showcasing 'a sailing life' and many doing so successfully. Could I ask what is the point you are making in posting this? It is a genuine question.

I with the_fixer as mostly I am not sympathetic to people doing silly things with poor planning, but at least they got up off the couch and had a crack at doing something. Hopefully this event won't stop them trying again, but that next time they will plan things an awful lot better. I would have thought it more appropriate for this site to post something with a title 'silly people continue to work 70 hour weeks to finance new Range Rover and larger house'.

Most people sailing overcome inexperience with conscientiousness and caution (it is their life at stake after all) but that clearly appears to have not been the case here;

"was about 8:45 p.m. when they sailed into a new port, navigating a channel they had never sailed before, in the dark, fog rolling in. Broadwell steered while Walsh stood at the bow, lighting their path with a spotlight, trying to figure out the navigational buoys. But the red and green buoys seemed out of place, they said, and the shoal wasn’t where their 2016-17 navigational charts said it should be. Had Hurricane Irma altered the channel?"

There is a lot wrong in that sentence. Another young youtube couple managed to crash their mast into a rising bridge and wrote off the boat doing so. However, most don't and have an incredible time.

We are a family of four and going sailing is definitely part of our post FIRE plans starting Summer 2019. Buying the boat is clearly not the most Mustachian, but the lifestyle can be. You become hyper aware of all sorts of elements of lifestyle inflation that 'Western Life' takes for granted,

. Energy usage - If diesel, solar panels and wind generators are your source of power, you soon start to appreciate it.
. Provisioning - You have to meal plan and batch shop.
. Thoughtless consumerism - You are removed and don't have the space for most of these temptations.
. Waste - You know exactly how much you are throwing away as you have to get in a dingy and take it to shore. Not to mention the plastic waste you will see in the oceans (don't get me started on plastic...).

I could list others.

For me, sailing ticks a lot of the boxes around the fears people have (and me) about what they will do with the time they have after retiring. For goal oriented people, which almost by definition everyone on this forum is, then you are replacing the FIRE goal with the complicated, challenging and fun goal of taking your family to see some of the world from a somewhat different perspective. I want my kids to retain perspective and remain amazed that you can fly from London to New York in 7 hours when it would take you three weeks to sail.

You also, I think, have a chance to develop new skills, becoming navigator, teacher, diesel engine engineer, electrician, plumber (gulp!), carpenter, seamsmith, and that's not including the 'fun' skills.   
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: frugalecon on February 12, 2018, 04:37:03 AM
I worry about the safety of the pug. He didn’t get a vote on their bone-headed plan.
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: ReadySetMillionaire on February 12, 2018, 06:33:29 AM
I'm just in awe at how stupid these people are.
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: boarder42 on February 12, 2018, 07:19:59 AM
i'm sorry but those supporting this couple are nuts. they "sold all the owned" which amounted to 5k to buy the boat - i dont care if its a cool FIRE decision many around here are making or not the couple is obviously very poor at planning - take the cool boat out of it and read the rest of the article and you've got a couple who only owned 5k worth of stuff in their life which means they were wasting piles of money.  If this story was more along the lines of how an intelligent FIREee would look at this and approach it i'd have more sympathy.  But they were clearly not very good at life prior to buying this boat and then sinking it.
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: edgema on February 12, 2018, 07:50:49 AM
Boarder42, I don't think anyone is supporting what they did. My question is what has it got to do with anything? Paraphrasing your own statement "if this story were anything to to with Mustachianism then..." but it isn't. Not my place to police what people want to talk about here, I just don't understand what the original post was getting at, rather than a slightly nasty 'look at these idiots' finger pointing at a couple of people who tried to have an adventure and messed up. Look I don't think this debate has legs, just providing my two pennies worth.
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: the_fixer on February 12, 2018, 08:23:36 AM
I have often thought if I had to do it all over again that I would explore / adventure more while young and work in my later years. The way we approach work / retirement here in the US has always seemed backwards working most of your life to get a few years at the end of your life where you are tired and broken down.

MMM is the safe middle ground where if you get onboard while young you will have some financial security and health to enjoy many years doing things you want but not everyone is aware of it or drinks the kool aid.

For the other 99% of the people in the US that are not on board with the MMM lifestyle I would applaud any young person that can see that the way we think of retirement is jacked and has the courage to walk away from the societal norm and strike out on a grand adventure.

When you are young is the time to live, you have less worries about health insurance, stability and the fears that are beat into you over your life.

I wish I had listened to the demons in my head when I was a 17 year old homeless surf bum sleeping in my car and planning to explore the world looking for the perfect surf spot.

Watch this video and see what your thoughts are after

https://youtu.be/ibP5IQxId34




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: Turnbull on February 12, 2018, 10:19:58 AM
I worked for an insurance company for a while and we insured numerous $5k and/or old boats. Not sure why people are saying insurance would be impossible or hard to get unless it makes a difference that it would be in salt water (most of our insured boats were fresh water).

Maybe the industry has changed since I left but when I read this article I never once thought that they wouldn't have been able to get insurance if they had wanted it.
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: Bateaux on February 12, 2018, 10:33:32 AM
I worked for an insurance company for a while and we insured numerous $5k and/or old boats. Not sure why people are saying insurance would be impossible or hard to get unless it makes a difference that it would be in salt water (most of our insured boats were fresh water).

Maybe the industry has changed since I left but when I read this article I never once thought that they wouldn't have been able to get insurance if they had wanted it.

You can insure them, bit there are many levels of insurance.   It is largely dependent upon the level of experience of the operator, where it will be used, how far offshore and the results of a marine survey.  But yes, much more complicated than freshwater.
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: Cromacster on February 12, 2018, 10:59:31 AM
I have often thought if I had to do it all over again that I would explore / adventure more while young and work in my later years. The way we approach work / retirement here in the US has always seemed backwards working most of your life to get a few years at the end of your life where you are tired and broken down.

MMM is the safe middle ground where if you get onboard while young you will have some financial security and health to enjoy many years doing things you want but not everyone is aware of it or drinks the kool aid.

For the other 99% of the people in the US that are not on board with the MMM lifestyle I would applaud any young person that can see that the way we think of retirement is jacked and has the courage to walk away from the societal norm and strike out on a grand adventure.

When you are young is the time to live, you have less worries about health insurance, stability and the fears that are beat into you over your life.

I wish I had listened to the demons in my head when I was a 17 year old homeless surf bum sleeping in my car and planning to explore the world looking for the perfect surf spot.

Watch this video and see what your thoughts are after

https://youtu.be/ibP5IQxId34




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Love that documentary!  Great even if you aren't into sailing.
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: ender on February 12, 2018, 11:21:23 AM
I have a hard time feeling sorry for people who clearly didn't know what they are doing having exactly what is expected happening to them.
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: Cowardly Toaster on February 12, 2018, 01:12:31 PM
Sounds like inexperience and poor navigation skills. Boating safely can be as much of a challenge as flying an aircraft only there is no license required for boating.

There's more planes in the sea than boats in the sky... but jokes aside you are quite correct. The sea can be a cruel place.
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: jlcnuke on February 12, 2018, 01:31:40 PM
I have a hard time feeling sorry for people who clearly didn't know what they are doing having exactly what is expected happening to them.

One of the mantras in most industries is to ask "what could go wrong?" before starting something and the minimize the chances of those happenings. These people demonstrated why that's a good idea in real life too as the outcome was quite predictable when you take the number of risk factors they intentionally exposed themselves to and thus see the compounded risk... inexperienced people sailing, sailing at night, sailing in poor conditions, sailing without assistance, sailing in an unfamiliar area, not researching the area they were going to sail (tons of warnings about that area's waterway conditions have been out for months), not having insurance, not having adequate funds for their planned journey, etc etc

Yeah, a blind squirrel could have seen this possibility.
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: FIRE Artist on February 12, 2018, 01:39:25 PM
This should be in the anti-Mustachian hall of shame.  The article claims that they have $90 to their name.  Yes, that was $90, no missing zeros there.  They were going off to pursue their dream will all of $90 in their pocket.  How exactly were they planning to pay for gas, food and mooring fees? 

They are better off getting sunk before they got started. 
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: GuitarStv on February 12, 2018, 01:53:50 PM
They are better off getting sunk before they got started.

+1

It kinda feels like they may have averted tragedy here . . .
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: Zamboni on February 12, 2018, 02:04:18 PM
Yes, this is a good cautionary tale.

The sailboat life probably has the same glamorous pull as the RV life . . . and, from what I've heard, plenty of full time RV'ers end up with a vacant look in their eyes when they realize that life still costs more money than they had planned.

To me, the main reason this belongs on this forum is that clearly this couple did not even do the basic financial exercise of figuring out how much money they would need. That's the first thing people point out here on new case studies . . . many of the posted cases have unexplained leakage, or emergencies that aren't really emergencies that keep people debt slaves. For most of us working stiffs, outflow needs to be tracked carefully for at least 3 months before you even try to do anything. Sailing is not free, and you will run out of food eventually.
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: CheapskateWife on February 12, 2018, 02:12:39 PM
They are better off getting sunk before they got started.

+1

It kinda feels like they may have averted tragedy here . . .
This is a perspective I share...clearly the crisis in a place where they could be rescued is preferable to a terrible tale of them being found on their boat dead from starvation or some other awful fate.  They are still young (and dumb) and will probably make more mistakes going forward :)
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: Cowardly Toaster on February 12, 2018, 02:39:19 PM
This should be in the anti-Mustachian hall of shame.  The article claims that they have $90 to their name.  Yes, that was $90, no missing zeros there.  They were going off to pursue their dream will all of $90 in their pocket.  How exactly were they planning to pay for gas, food and mooring fees? 

They are better off getting sunk before they got started.

Sailing, the art of slowly going nowhere at great expense.
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: Cromacster on February 12, 2018, 02:41:37 PM
This should be in the anti-Mustachian hall of shame.  The article claims that they have $90 to their name.  Yes, that was $90, no missing zeros there.  They were going off to pursue their dream will all of $90 in their pocket.  How exactly were they planning to pay for gas, food and mooring fees? 

They are better off getting sunk before they got started.

Sailing, the art of slowly going nowhere at great expense.

Also fondly referred to as "boat maintenance in exotic places"
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: Kyle Schuant on February 12, 2018, 03:21:02 PM
At the ages of 24 and 26, they'd had enough of working. Just let that sink in (haha) a bit.

At the ages of 24 and 26, when they sold everything they had $10,000.

Something tells me they'll still be working - and doing gofundmes! - at 75. That is, if they don't blow their gofundme money on another boat, in which case next time they go out they won't come back.

I with the_fixer as mostly I am not sympathetic to people doing silly things with poor planning, but at least they got up off the couch and had a crack at doing something.
There was a man who wanted to fly, he decided to jump off a cliff and figured he'd learn halfway down, it didn't work out well for him. But at least he got up off the couch and had a crack at something!

The 7 Ps, boys and girls. Proper preparation and planning prevents piss-poor performance. How about some sailing lessons? Work on a fishing boat one season, get fishing experience and earn some money.

Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: Undecided on February 12, 2018, 09:02:34 PM
I hope someone takes the Pug away before they hurt it.

I have trouble understanding why anyone would contribute to their GoFundMe.
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: the_fixer on February 12, 2018, 09:41:52 PM
Totally against the go fund me :(

Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: tj on February 12, 2018, 10:10:20 PM
I hope they have a backup plan, doesn't sound like it.

http://www.tampabay.com/sold-everything-to-sail-the-world-boat-sank-next-day

The backup plan is get bailed out by suckers on GoFundMe:

https://www.gofundme.com/new-sailing-life


Quote
I have trouble understanding why anyone would contribute to their GoFundMe.

People hate their working lives, so they want to live vicariously through someone else. That's the only logical reason.
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: edgema on February 13, 2018, 12:47:44 AM
I should leave this alone ....

First let me say I neither support what they did, or the funding handouts that they now seek, but wow this is a tough crowd.

We are a self selected group of somewhat obsessive planners so their lack of planning jars with us and I get that. Maybe we are not the most carefree group and it pisses us off a little to see others who can do something like this, however poorly planned. Maybe we quite like seeing them fall on their face because it supports our approach of patience and hyper planning.

Yes they did something stupid, but the real idiots are the tens of millions of people over 60 in both the UK and US that have absolutely no savings for retirement in my view.

Maybe these two are heading that way, but they at least were looking at a simple mustachian style of life rather than debt after debt after debt. They actually had one foot in the right camp. Rather than criticise I would like to speak to them and say 'you had some good ideas, here is how you might execute better'

Maybe I am just grumpy at the lack of any empathy in the group. No one here did anything stupid in their early 20s? I for one drove a car too fast and into a tree and might not be here in another universe...
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: AnnaGrowsAMustache on February 13, 2018, 01:59:41 AM
I should leave this alone ....

First let me say I neither support what they did, or the funding handouts that they now seek, but wow this is a tough crowd.

We are a self selected group of somewhat obsessive planners so their lack of planning jars with us and I get that. Maybe we are not the most carefree group and it pisses us off a little to see others who can do something like this, however poorly planned. Maybe we quite like seeing them fall on their face because it supports our approach of patience and hyper planning.

Yes they did something stupid, but the real idiots are the tens of millions of people over 60 in both the UK and US that have absolutely no savings for retirement in my view.

Maybe these two are heading that way, but they at least were looking at a simple mustachian style of life rather than debt after debt after debt. They actually had one foot in the right camp. Rather than criticise I would like to speak to them and say 'you had some good ideas, here is how you might execute better'

Maybe I am just grumpy at the lack of any empathy in the group. No one here did anything stupid in their early 20s? I for one drove a car too fast and into a tree and might not be here in another universe...

I understand your point of view, and I think the reason that those without retirement savings aren't treated with the same astonishment is that they're ubiquitous! The sailing pair have the same mentality but their method of expressing that was astounding in it's complete idiocy. They leaped before they looked, in the most ridiculous way.
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: Kyle Schuant on February 13, 2018, 05:32:47 AM
Maybe I am just grumpy at the lack of any empathy in the group. No one here did anything stupid in their early 20s?
I did many stupid things. Once each. They're planning on a second go.

When I blew through money, I didn't put my hand out crying poor.

The issue is not their doing something obviously stupid, it's that they're repeating it, and panhandling rather than shifting for themselves.


Quote
I for one drove a car too fast and into a tree and might not be here in another universe...
Did you crash into a tree a second time? Did you ask people to donate so you could get another car and drive in the same reckless way again? Or did you learn from your experience and work hard to earn back what you'd lost?
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: Villanelle on February 13, 2018, 05:36:50 AM
Boarder42, I don't think anyone is supporting what they did. My question is what has it got to do with anything? Paraphrasing your own statement "if this story were anything to to with Mustachianism then..." but it isn't. Not my place to police what people want to talk about here, I just don't understand what the original post was getting at, rather than a slightly nasty 'look at these idiots' finger pointing at a couple of people who tried to have an adventure and messed up. Look I don't think this debate has legs, just providing my two pennies worth.

I don't see how these people are really much different than the average consumer sucka.  Instead of making thoughtful, careful choices and leading a well-examined life, they set out to live a life they didn't understand and had not fully considered.  They just *did*, acting on impulse, rather than thinking and planning and considering.  How is that significantly different than someone just acting by purchasing a shiny new SUV and a McMansion? 
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: CheapskateWife on February 13, 2018, 08:09:51 AM
Their GoFundMe is up to $14K in 4 days...maybe they aren't the stupid ones.
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: Just Joe on February 13, 2018, 09:12:17 AM
I've dreamed of the same sailing adventure and have a tiny bit of experience with sailboats. I'd spend 6 months working, and taking daily trips out into the coastal area with the boat - sail an hour out and an hour back.

Sort through its any maintenance issues and build experience. I can't imagine what they would have done in a storm.

Sailing on the ocean is not like steering a pontoon boat around a lake. 

I want to do some big projects at our house this year. I think I'll go start a GoFundMe. ;)
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: Helvegen on February 13, 2018, 09:27:34 AM
Their GoFundMe is up to $14K in 4 days...maybe they aren't the stupid ones.

I think they are professional grifters.
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: Acastus on February 13, 2018, 09:37:57 AM
Saw this on FB. The boat cost $5k. They sold everything to buy it.
A:  What kind of boat can you get for 5k?
B:  $5k was your life savings and you thought you could retire?
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: the_fixer on February 13, 2018, 09:53:15 AM
It sounds like they did have some experience.

"His father helped them sail along the Gulf Coast, from Alabama to Panama City. That’s how the couple learned how to sail"

Then they sailed the boat to Tarpon Springs (a good distance) where they worked on the boat.

After fixing up the boat they headed out that is when they ran into issues.

Typical click bait reporting that makes it sound more sensational.

Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: FINate on February 13, 2018, 10:03:10 AM
B:  $5k was your life savings and you thought you could retire?

So judgmental! They are entitled to live their dream even if it means other people have to fund it! </sarcasm>

I wonder if any of the $14k GoFundMe will be used to pay for the cost of rescuing them and cleaning up their wreck?
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: FIRE Artist on February 13, 2018, 11:02:55 AM
they at least were looking at a simple mustachian style of life rather than debt after debt after debt. They actually had one foot in the right camp.

I'm pulling this out as I have seen what I consider to be alternative definitions of Mustachianism being used lately on the forum which I don't think is positive for the movement, and definitely not for those being mislead.   

Mustachianism = Financial Independence through Badassity. 

Living at or in this case, below the poverty line with no reserve funds is not being financially independent and certainly isn't badass by most definitions.  This isn't Mustachianism.  Perhaps equating this type of lifestyle to Mustachianism or romanticising it as something exciting and adventurous is steering some young people in the wrong direction. 
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: NoraLenderbee on February 13, 2018, 03:12:50 PM
This should be in the anti-Mustachian hall of shame.  The article claims that they have $90 to their name.  Yes, that was $90, no missing zeros there.  They were going off to pursue their dream will all of $90 in their pocket.  How exactly were they planning to pay for gas, food and mooring fees? 

They are better off getting sunk before they got started.

https://forum.mrmoneymustache.com/antimustachian-wall-of-shame-and-comedy/couple-sells-everything-for-boat-it-sinks-on-day-2/
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: Kyle Schuant on February 13, 2018, 04:22:14 PM
I don't see how these people are really much different than the average consumer sucka. 
The average consumer sucka does not risk getting killed by their poor consumer choices.
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: GuitarStv on February 13, 2018, 06:58:21 PM
I don't see how these people are really much different than the average consumer sucka. 
The average consumer sucka does not risk getting killed by their poor consumer choices.

Well, the average consumer sucka drives an SUV more likely to flip over in a crash because it 'feels' safer, eats shit processed food that gives him heart disease, and works a job that stresses him out, spends a lot of time on the road commuting to afford a McMansion, etc. so . . . meh.
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: BTDretire on February 13, 2018, 07:17:55 PM
They are better off getting sunk before they got started.

+1

It kinda feels like they may have averted tragedy here . . .

 I lost some friends, RoseMary, David and their 17 yr old son just 5 years ago to the sea.
The left on an around the world trip in 2011, they were lost to a storm between New Zealand and Australia in 2013.
They were experience sailors lost with the 1926 famous sailing yacht,  The Nina.
 Rosemary was a special person, and missed dearly.
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: dbm on February 13, 2018, 10:29:23 PM
I hope they have a backup plan, doesn't sound like it.

http://www.tampabay.com/sold-everything-to-sail-the-world-boat-sank-next-day

Did no one think this was karma for selling time shares?  Their "holiday" dream ruined, after suckering other people with holiday dreams into time shares...

No, no one?  Just me then...
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: Kyle Schuant on February 13, 2018, 11:28:58 PM
Well, the average consumer sucka drives an SUV more likely to flip over in a crash because it 'feels' safer, eats shit processed food that gives him heart disease, and works a job that stresses him out, spends a lot of time on the road commuting to afford a McMansion, etc. so . . . meh.
Those are orders of magnitude less immediately risky than open sea sailing with little to no sailing experience.

But you knew that. Quibbling to avoid the point - it's so fucking internet.
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: Zamboni on February 14, 2018, 03:53:55 AM
I lost some friends, RoseMary, David and their 17 yr old son just 5 years ago to the sea.
The left on an around the world trip in 2011, they were lost to a storm between New Zealand and Australia in 2013.
They were experience sailors lost with the 1926 famous sailing yacht,  The Nina.
 Rosemary was a special person, and missed dearly.

Sorry to read about your loss, @BTDretire. Please accept my condolences.

Did no one think this was karma for selling time shares?  Their "holiday" dream ruined, after suckering other people with holiday dreams into time shares...

No, no one?  Just me then...

It was my first thought as well . . . and now they are averting charity money from people coping with massive medical problems or small children who just survived a house fire or worse with their obnoxious gofundme campaign. Oh well.
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: GuitarStv on February 14, 2018, 11:13:31 AM
Well, the average consumer sucka drives an SUV more likely to flip over in a crash because it 'feels' safer, eats shit processed food that gives him heart disease, and works a job that stresses him out, spends a lot of time on the road commuting to afford a McMansion, etc. so . . . meh.
Those are orders of magnitude less immediately risky than open sea sailing with little to no sailing experience.

But you knew that. Quibbling to avoid the point - it's so fucking internet.

No intent to avoid a point.  The average consumer sucka does risk getting killed by poor consumer choices.  Hence the small joke at your poor choice of words.

I do agree with what appears to be your sentiment, that they were being unnecessarily risky.
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: Johnez on February 15, 2018, 11:30:24 AM
Looks like these guys now have a headstart in the minimalistic lifestyle.
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: Car Jack on February 15, 2018, 11:56:18 AM
I have a pretty old story that's similar, but I think more interesting.  I had an uncle (now late) who divorced and eventually bought a big sailboat.  He would often prod my dad, who was second generation in the family insurance agency that he didn't pay for insurance and waste his money.  Well, my dad gets word that he was caught off Haiti in a storm and had to abandon the boat and get to shore.  As the weather cleared up, looters took everything.  As is often the case, Haiti wasn't exactly safe and my uncle was looking for a way out of there.  Ok, sounds very James Bond, but my dad knew a former CIA contact so he got in touch with him.  This contact somehow got my uncle back to the US.  The boat was never recovered by him, although it was probably recovered by someone down in Haiti for all we know. 

My uncle always seemed to survive, but we know he didn't always pay his bills because debt collectors would call us and my mom now and then.

I guess the lesson learned is to buy insurance for things you can't afford to lose.
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: tj on February 15, 2018, 01:23:42 PM
Quote
I guess the lesson learned is to buy insurance for things you can't afford to lose.

The main point of the insurance is to protect your liability. Like the costs of removing this boat from the water. I guses if you can just convince people on GoFundMe, who needs insurance.
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: KTG on February 15, 2018, 01:35:32 PM
They had no insurance.

This is more common than you think. During the last hurricane here, I hosted some friends who live on the coast and they brought their uncle who sold everything to retire on a boat. No insurance with a hurricane on the way. Luckily no real damage done, but its definitely rolling the dice. And he has said he cannot afford the extra payments.

So I guess its only a matter of time...
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: GuitarBrian on February 15, 2018, 09:51:58 PM
This should be in the anti-Mustachian hall of shame.  The article claims that they have $90 to their name.  Yes, that was $90, no missing zeros there.  They were going off to pursue their dream will all of $90 in their pocket.  How exactly were they planning to pay for gas, food and mooring fees? 

They are better off getting sunk before they got started.

Sailing, the art of slowly going nowhere at great expense.

Also fondly referred to as "boat maintenance in exotic places"


I have been ranting about this for the last few days. This "news" article has been all over the web. My grandpa had even read about it in the paper!

I have lived about half my life on a sailboat (6 months on/6 months off). And it was never* at a marina. From a structural point, it shouldn't have sunk. It looks like it hit a sandbar. I have heard that the keel "fell off"... This is a big deal, the keel shouldn't fall off when you run aground, even if you hit a rock. There doesn't seem to be much swell from the photos I've seen, so I doubt there was surf the was the culprit. Honestly I sounds like the boat wasn't structurally sound. So it was MUCH better to find that out in the relative calm vs. 500 nm from nowhere, while your battling 50kts of wind and 18ft seas. They should be thankful for this event as it probably saved their lives.

I have been drawing the same analogy as I read in other posts... You buy a car (used and not that expensive, say... $10k) and 2 days later you wreck it. You of course don't hurt anyone and you both walk away. This is a mistake, and should be owned by you. Why is it morally acceptable to first get the story out, by doing interviews and self promotion, and secondly, start a GoFundMe?

None of us would be talking about this if the boat had sunk, and they had just shook their heads, thanked god that it didn't sink at sea or on a shore that's covered in lava rocks and pounding surf. Instead they posted pictures and did *something* to get the story out and the ball rolling.

Then when the media was taking up the story they started a GoFundMe. And basically said they want to try again. Which I think they should, but again, is it moral to beg for money?


All boats end up back on terra firma. Either at the bottom of the ocean or rotting in the backyard.


*Last marina we were at was in 2001, for 1 night. Before that, 1996 for 2 weeks.... and before that, I don't know, I was young :)
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: GuitarBrian on February 15, 2018, 10:12:46 PM
Just the other day, a boat came into the bay, it didn't anchor by the rest of the boats, instead it headed up the channel. There is a HUGE (100m x 30m) rock, right in the middle of the channel. It isn't marked on some charts, nor are there buoys. Well he hit it, Hard. Made so much worse, is the ~2-3 kt current running down the channel.

I attached a photo. He had been stuck for about an hour by this time. All on a falling tide... when he started there was 4 feet left of about a 10ft that day, he healed over a lot more. Then the current reversed, and as he started to float, it pushed him higher up the rock. Eventually it drug the keel, scrapping every inch of the way, all the way down the rock.

He was lucky, during spring tides, the rock dries out. He would have suffered serious damage to the hull. There's a good possibility the hull gets compromised and doesn't rise with the tide. ie. the boat sinks.

Note that the keel didn't fall off! He suffered massive gouges to the bottom of the keel. But, the integrity of the hull held up. From a stress point, this was much worse that hitting a soft shoal. He said the grinding, scrapping, banging, as the boat turned sideways to the current and was pinned down and drug along the rock was the worst thing he's had to experience. He has been blue water sailing for 25 years.
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: Channel-Z on February 18, 2018, 07:19:23 PM
I didn't put that story in my newscast, but I saw it just about everywhere else. Part of me wondered if these kids were a couple of tweakers who stole someone's boat, wrecked it, and made up the story to cover their crime.

Judging by the gofundme account, I'd say it has worked out for them.
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: tj on February 19, 2018, 12:16:08 PM
They were interviewed in this video:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j7fLn5DItPw


Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: Kierun on March 06, 2018, 02:51:06 PM
And now they have boat (for $1) and more than 16k from their crowd funding, why bother working and contributing to society when the world will just give you handouts to mooch off of.

edit: forgot article https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/good-news/couple-who-sold-their-belongings-to-live-on-now-sunken-sailboat-gets-new-boat-from-stranger/ar-BBJWPY2?ocid=spartandhp (https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/good-news/couple-who-sold-their-belongings-to-live-on-now-sunken-sailboat-gets-new-boat-from-stranger/ar-BBJWPY2?ocid=spartandhp)
Title: Re: Article - They sold everything and bought a boat.. It sank on day 2
Post by: Jrr85 on March 06, 2018, 03:12:51 PM
I hope someone takes the Pug away before they hurt it.

I have trouble understanding why anyone would contribute to their GoFundMe.

I assume they are just hardcore darwinists and don't want to leave anything to chance. 

Getting those two to blue water quickly seems like the best way to ensure they don't reproduce.