We are considering buying a prius- we would like to have a better roadtrip car, and I have an old Subaru that REALLY needs to be replaced (18 years old, 225k miles, burns oil, terrible MPG, and is generally done. It isn't a mustachian car, and is worth maybe $1500). Our other car is a 06 civic, which works well, but is LOUD on the highway, not the safest car around, and the MPG isn't quite as awesome. I'll miss the manual transmission I have always had, but... the environmental and monetary upside of a prius is too good to pass up. I was scared of their transmissions (We have manuals since they were traditionally more reliable) but this thread has facepunched me into realizing an automatic prius is a good long term car.
What are the thoughts on Gen 2 vs gen 3? Has anyone here driven both? The Gen 2 can be had very cheap, but I wonder if a newer vehicle could be a better long term bet (Still used and depreciated!) Features I would like include the improved MPG, better ride, improved safety, beltless design, and less engine miles- I don't want an oil burner if I can help it, and the gen 3's have less abuse built into them by nature of being less old. I wish I could get a plug in version, but those all seem to still be quite pricey. - My thought is a Gen 3 may be a better car to have long term, as we would like to drive it into the ground. I would be doing most of my own work on it as well.
The big issue I see is people claim the gen 3 may be less reliable, and has a worse interior. I will test drive both, but the reliability issue.. I have trouble deciphering it, and I see conflicting reports depending on where I look. Thoughts?
Local prices: Gen 3's for sub 100k - 150 miles seem to go for under $6000-$9000, but Gen 2's go from $3000 to $6000- but with more miles. If the reliability of the gen 3 is on par with the gen 2, would spending the extra on a 3 make sense? (We would be buying in cash)