I live in the Midwest, so we get really cold winters.
Turn it off and open/close your windows as needed. In fact, I only turn my AC on when it's hot/humid enough that I'm uncomfortable, or there's an air quality issue that is causing problems. Play a game with yourself on how long you can hold out until turning on the heat. (for that matter, why has your A/C been on all this time? sounds like you've never adjusted to the actual temp outside. Facepunch. Start now.)
General cold weather info since you're new to it:
Sleeping is best accomplished, biologically, with a cool room temp and warm blanket. Layers are typically best so you can adjust for a wider variety of temperatures. IE: Get a light weight blanket (you might want it now), a medium weight one, and a heavier one. Depending on the temp, swap blankets, or put on 2 (or all 3) for comfort.
For clothing, multiple layers are better than one really heavy one. When it's really cold out, I may be wearing up to 4 layers outside, and 2-3 inside. You'll be warmer and can keep the thermostat set lower too.
Most heat loss is through the head, so get a warm hat.
Mittens are warmer than gloves.
Heat people, not spaces. Get some blankets and put them on the couch/chairs. If you're cold, it's right there.
If you're cold, put on more clothes. Kids in particular are bad about this. They'll complain they're cold while wearing a tshirt and no socks. And leave the door hanging open. (My winters growing up where a constant refrain of "go put on more clothes if you're cold" and "close the door!")
Ensure that any pets have a nice warm bed to sleep in too, they'll arrange themselves from there. They may decide that your bed is the best, which is just added warmth for you.