Ha! Here's a different angle. DH's Craigslist Score is zero. Yup, zero. As in, he's never put anything on CL that hasn't sold. He's been using CL to obtain needed items and then to resell them, often at a profit, for decades. Love that guy!
Since I posted this, DH listed and sold something else. We had flooring left over from a recent project. The material came from Lumber Liquidators. They give better prices the more material you buy. However, if you return any left over, they recalculate the whole job, so it can literally cost you money to return material to them.
So DH posts six boxes of flooring on CL. Guy sees it, goes to a LL, checks it out, then calls DH. He pays the full asking price and comes over to pick it up the same day. Turns out he's using it in his boat. DH spent quite a bit of time with him, discussing the best way to install the new flooring. By the time I got home today, there was a nice empty spot in the garage, and $100 more in DH's pocket. Win-win. Maybe I should say the score is love-all.