Here's a little secret, your whole reply is called a non sequitur, it has nothing to do with my position that your "Your anecdotal experience cannot prove or disprove anything". I will not comment on the tangent you took since you did not address my actual point.
"Investment experience" includes observing and witnessing other traders do their magic for the past 15 years; it includes my own real time use of technical, fundamental, and psychological analysis in order to time trades, and witnessing others employ the same tactics to time their own.
What you did is latch onto a little sentence, misread it, and attempt to reduce everything I've been saying for weeks into being something like my own little private investment fantasy.
Have you read any books on technical analysis?
Have you read any books on behavioral psychology as applied to speculation?
Have you read any books on the role of fundamental analysis in exploiting market inefficiencies?
My guess is "definitely no" to the first two, and maybe a book or two dealing with the last. But by all means, don't let a lack of knowledge of a subject deter you from throwing your opinion out there; hasn't stopped the resident efficient market hypothesizers from doing the same.