Author Topic: Case Study: Can I do better?  (Read 2568 times)

Jack Able

  • 5 O'Clock Shadow
  • *
  • Posts: 1
Case Study: Can I do better?
« on: June 18, 2017, 11:43:09 PM »
Hello Mustachains, I've been a long time lurker. I feel like I have most of my house in order. As in, I spend way more than is minimally necessary, but at least I know where the leaks are.

The current debate over who can actually call themselves optimized finally made me post. Where am I, on the spectrum of badassity?

Background: Single, 36, working for the US Government; living in the PNW


INCOME              MONTHLY   ANNUAL   
Taxable.............$6,887    $82,649   
Tax Free............$3,326    $39,908   
Gross...............$10,213   $122,556   

PRE TAX SAVINGS     MONTHLY   ANNUAL   
Federal TSP.........$1,500    $18,000   
trad IRA............$458      $5,500   
total Savings 1.....$1,958    $23,500

TAXES               MONTHLY   ANNUAL   
Med/SS..............$527      $6,323   
Federal.............$856      $10,268   
total Taxes.........$1,383    $16,591   Filling single, no dependents. Expect a 2k refund for 2017.
                  
POST TAX SAVINGS    MONTHLY   ANNUAL   
Vanguard............$2,800    $33,600   
Slush Fund..........$400      $4,800
total Savings 2.....$3,200    $38,400
         
FIXED EXPENSES      MONTHLY   ANNUAL   
Rent................$1,075    $12,900   
Tithe...............$720      $8,640   
Cell Phone..........$63       $756   
Gym.................$54       $648   
Electric............$40       $480   
Internet............$40       $480   
Hulu & Audible......$26       $312   
Life Insurance......$15       $180
total Fixed.........$2,033    $24,396   
            
VARIABLE EXPENSES   MONTHLY   ANNUAL   
Auto................$314      $3,770  No loan. It’s just an expensive car
Groceries...........$243      $2,916   
Gifts & Community...$241      $2,896   
Fun.................$146      $1,752   
Professional Crap.............$1,000  Uniforms, re-licensing fees, training fees.
Restaurants.........$154      $1,848
Personal............$87       $1,046   
Household...........$70       $842   
Travel..............$62       $740  Metro card, Uber, etc. Other 'real' travel is credit card hacking
Alcohol.............$14       $164   
Misc................$10       $124  Where does this go???
total Variable......$1,342    $17,098


So, my financial life looks like
Income      $10,213   $122,556   
- Taxes     $1,383    $16,591   
- Savings   $5,158    $61,900    Savings (pre & post tax)
- Tithe     $720      $8,640
===========================
SPENDING    $2,952    $35,424
[/b]

The Good:
1. High salary; low tax; high savings.

2. No liabilities. Good at travel hacking

3. Negotiated internet down to the bare minimum price offered. Electricity is weirdly cheap in my city.

4. My rent is cheap like whoah. My tiny apartment keeps my purchased down.

5. Good at travel hacking, removing around 3k of expenses/year.

The Really Bad:
1. The car.

2. The cellphone. I own the phone, so why not switch to a cheap-o plan? Laziness and analysis paralysis.

3. The restaurants. 2017's number are actually a pretty big improvement over my pre-MMM days, but it's still shameful. People like to eat, and there's good food in this city.

The Whineypants
1. The amount I spend having fun. My friends like to go out, and do things. I can steer them towards cheap activities about 50% of the time. The remainder, I have to pay if I want to play.

2. Groceries. Laziness again. I don't want to make a price book. I just want to go to the closest store, and get the misery over as soon as possible.

The Things I'm Not Going to Change
1. Tithe. I'm not going to switch to volunteering, because the money is the thing.

2. Gifts & community. I live in a poor area; I'm rich; it's my responsibility to help.

So, what else?

joonifloofeefloo

  • Magnum Stache
  • ******
  • Posts: 4865
  • On a forum break :)
Re: Case Study: Can I do better?
« Reply #1 on: June 19, 2017, 12:29:29 AM »
I don't know... Certainly you cannot do better at making things tidy! That was the prettiest case study post I have ever seen. You will be well loved on this forum :)

Also, thank you (genuinely) for seeing your wealth and gifts received, and for your commitment to redistributing some of that. Good stuff.

marty998

  • Walrus Stache
  • *******
  • Posts: 7372
  • Location: Sydney, Oz
Re: Case Study: Can I do better?
« Reply #2 on: June 19, 2017, 03:27:46 AM »
You've done quite well... but I sense you are doing well because you have the financial means to make good choices.

For example, a poor person would not have been able to pay cash for a car, so would have a loan instead. You have the luxury of not needing the loan, so your expenditure won't have that item.

Similarly with the house - I'll bet you are able to buy good quality fixtures and appliances, which means you are not spending as much on upkeep and repairs.

I guess I'm trying to make the point that it is comparatively easier to be "badass" when you already come from a position of strength.

I'm in a similar situation to you (except I don't tithe) and this was a realisation I had many years ago. I'm able to choose to be "badass" because of choices made in the past, but a lot of people don't have the choice to be as flexible with their money or spending because of past behaviour, or until they clear their loans, or existing contracts.

Or some people have to spend because they have children. It doesn't make them less badass because they spend more... everyone will be running a different race depending on family structure or location.

You are saving well over $60,000 a year. Don't feel horrible about spending an extra $1000 on having a bit of fun (something I am learning to do too). It won't delay FIRE plans in any material sense.