The Money Mustache Community

Learning, Sharing, and Teaching => Ask a Mustachian => Topic started by: Emergo on November 07, 2015, 10:50:53 AM

Title: Latest: put 5.5k of savings into traditional or roth ira before yr ends?
Post by: Emergo on November 07, 2015, 10:50:53 AM
Hello all. This forum is pretty impressive. I've seen nothing like it, and I browse online for forums a lot. Anyway, I've read a bit about MMM and have always felt like I needed real advice from people instead of just reading the blog posts. I would gladly appreciate it if you guys could help me. I'm going to follow the stickied topic's guideline on how to make posts easy for people to help me. If it's wrong in any shape or form, please forgive me. Also, I found the spreadsheet provided very intimidating, so I did not do it. I will try to give as much information as possible.

Topic Title: General Help for 27 year-old single male, became engineer with foreign degree (Philippines, I was very blessed to find job given this) 2 years and 4 months of experience

Life Situation:
IRS filing status - single W2, I believe?
number & ages of dependents - None
(state/country of residence, age, etc.) - Houston, TX, living with my mom

Gross Salary/Wages: $65,000

Pre-tax deductions: 401k, HSA, FSA, IRA, insurance, etc. - I am not very knowledgeable about this right now (I know I should be). But I do know I'm only set at default for my 401k (without about $4k in my 401k? that's what the automated machine told me when I called last week).

--update below---
opened up my paystub and saw this:

$73.90 401k
$20.50 dental
$31.60 medical hra2
$2.60 vision

$149 ss tax
$35 medicare
$400 fed inc tax

$2 grp term life
$56 401k match


Other Ordinary Income: Nothing

Qualified Dividends & Long Term Capital Gains: Nothing

Rental Income, Actual Expenses, and Depreciation:
$200 to pay my mom for rent monthly (this actually dropped down from $300 this month, since we found another person to occupy the other room)
$21.70 Planet Fitness - Every month
$120.00 EZ Tag - Every three weeks (I go through the tollway every day, I have to)
$440.00 Tithes - Every month (please don't tell me to eliminate this, I know it's a large sum, but this is strongly part of my beliefs)
$57.66 T-Mobile - Every month
$21.95 Equifax - Every month (looking to get rid of this soon as I heard there's a free way to check credit scores once a year on a certain website)
$128.04 GEICO - Every month (I drive a 2008 Rav4 Limited, that's it)
$200-250 Gas - Every month (I commute 18 miles to get to work, and 18 miles back)
$8.65 Hulu - Every month
plus $400 on food (ROUGH estimate) - as mentioned below


Adjusted Gross Income: Umm if this means how much I get out of my paycheck every 2 weeks, it's $1780. $875 of that is put into my savings account, which sometimes I have to grab money out of since I run out of money from the other half from paying monthly debts (listed above)

Taxes: Federal, state/local, and FICA.  - I have no idea what this section is. But I have a low credit score around the 640s

Current expenses: Other than my monthly expenses... I do eat out more than I should. Yes, I should prepare food for myself to save money but I am so tired from work when I get home... I work from 8 to 5, but I get home at 6 because I have a 50 minute commute from work since traffic in Houston is HORRIBLE. My mom does time to time prepare food for me (without me paying for groceries as she does her own thing for food, she cooks for people). This might be a rough estimate on how much I spend on food monthly... but I think it's around $400. There was a month recently that I did go to Smoothie King every day and spent $13 on a large smoothie... that adds up, yes.



Expected ER expenses: Nothing

Assets: Nothing

Liabilities: Nothing, living with mom paying rent, bought my 08 rav 4 used and paid in full.

Specific Question(s):
So currently I'm close to achieving my goal of $10k emergency funds.
After that, what do I do? And yes, please help me arrange what I should do with my 401k.
I do have a goal of having my own home one day, but I'm told it is wiser to find a wife first.
I do want to get into investing, but I have no idea where and how to start. I'm read that vanguard is the best around here. But i'm still not sure if that's what I should do right away after I achieve my $10k emergency fund.
I plan to get Lasik surgery next year, so that will be around $1500.
Basically I just need a good sequence of a plan so I can go from one step to another. I already have step 1 of emergency funds... unless you guys tell me to increase that.
I just honestly don't think I earn enough (I wish i had a wife already to help me out).... but I did read the philosophy of MMM is that's a misconception and I'm just not saving enough.
I wish I had some way of earning passive income... maybe I should do audio transcription at home for $13 dollar an hour and earn some money that way.



Take it easy on me guys... I'm a newbie. A newbie who just honestly in desperate need of your help.

Might have forgotten a few things to say here, in that case I'll just post more info later...

Thanks guys.
Title: Re: 1st post. New to MMM. Started with 0. Feels like I'm saving too slow, Need help
Post by: Malum Prohibitum on November 07, 2015, 10:59:43 AM
What to do about your 401(k)?  You make 65,000, have no debt, and live at home with your mother.  I am not even sure why this is a question.  Contribute the maximum to your 401(k), 18,000 a year.  This is $1500 monthly, or, if you are paid twice a month, $750 a paycheck.

This will reduce your taxable income by $18000, so you will pay less in taxes.

Why do you want a $10,000 emergency fund? 
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. Feels like saving too slow, Need help
Post by: Emergo on November 07, 2015, 11:01:55 AM
What to do about your 401(k)?  You make 65,000, have no debt, and live at home with your mother.  I am not even sure why this is a question.  Contribute the maximum to your 401(k), 18,000 a year.  This is $1500 monthly, or, if you are paid twice a month, $750 a paycheck.

This will reduce your taxable income by $18000, so you will pay less in taxes.

Why do you want a $10,000 emergency fund?

If I pay $750 a paycheck, I'm left with no money left for myself... then I have to eliminate the money I put into my savings account of $875 each paycheck?

Dude, that was fast! Thanks for replying btw.
Title: Re: 1st post. New to MMM. Started with 0. Feels like I'm saving too slow, Need help
Post by: Emergo on November 07, 2015, 11:03:19 AM


Why do you want a $10,000 emergency fund?


In case I get laid off or any emergency event in my life or family. I thought this was the common thing people do?
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. Feels like saving too slow, Need help
Post by: Malum Prohibitum on November 07, 2015, 11:06:11 AM
What to do about your 401(k)?  You make 65,000, have no debt, and live at home with your mother.  I am not even sure why this is a question.  Contribute the maximum to your 401(k), 18,000 a year.  This is $1500 monthly, or, if you are paid twice a month, $750 a paycheck.

This will reduce your taxable income by $18000, so you will pay less in taxes.

Why do you want a $10,000 emergency fund?

If I pay $750 a paycheck, I'm left with no money left for myself... then I have to eliminate the money I put into my savings account of $875 each paycheck?

Dude, that was fast! Thanks for replying btw.

You make $65000 a year.  Contributing 18000 to your 401(k) leaves you with $47,000 a year, which is about average household income in the United States (including one and two earner families), and you do not even have a household to support.

This is a no brainer, and you will thank me later.  Just do it!

Yes, I would stop putting $875 each paycheck into a savings account.  The savings account will not grow.   It just sits there.  That is why I asked why you want such a large emergency fund.
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. Feels like saving too slow, Need help
Post by: Imonaboat on November 07, 2015, 11:06:59 AM
Since it brings your taxes down the max 401k contribution practically pays for itself.

10k is the emergency fund I use as a single earner of a family of 4. You could get away with less in your situation.
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. Feels like saving too slow, Need help
Post by: Emergo on November 07, 2015, 11:10:14 AM
What to do about your 401(k)?  You make 65,000, have no debt, and live at home with your mother.  I am not even sure why this is a question.  Contribute the maximum to your 401(k), 18,000 a year.  This is $1500 monthly, or, if you are paid twice a month, $750 a paycheck.

This will reduce your taxable income by $18000, so you will pay less in taxes.

Why do you want a $10,000 emergency fund?

If I pay $750 a paycheck, I'm left with no money left for myself... then I have to eliminate the money I put into my savings account of $875 each paycheck?

Dude, that was fast! Thanks for replying btw.

You make $65000 a year.  Contributing 18000 to your 401(k) leaves you with $47,000 a year, which is about average household income in the United States (including one and two earner families), and you do not even have a household to support.

This is a no brainer, and you will thank me later.  Just do it!

Yes, I would stop putting $875 each paycheck into a savings account.  The savings account will not grow.   It just sits there.  That is why I asked why you want such a large emergency fund.

Okay, how long do I have to do the max contribution to 401k for? What if my life situation changes and I get married?
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. Feels like saving too slow, Need help
Post by: Emergo on November 07, 2015, 11:11:03 AM
Since it brings your taxes down the max 401k contribution practically pays for itself.

10k is the emergency fund I use as a single earner of a family of 4. You could get away with less in your situation.

It brings down the $400 federal income tax I have, is that what you guys are saying?
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. Feels like saving too slow, Need help
Post by: Malum Prohibitum on November 07, 2015, 11:15:11 AM
$128.04 GEICO - Every month (I drive a 2008 Rav4 Limited, that's it)
  Wow! That's a lot!  Is this full coverage?  You have enough in savings already to just about buy another one even if you totaled the car, and it was your fault.  If the wreck is somebody else's fault, then their insurance has to pay to fix your car.  I would consider self insuring the cost of this car and carrying minimum liability insurance only.

Quote
$200-250 Gas - Every month (I commute 18 miles to get to work, and 18 miles back)
  Houston has bus and rail, and they let you bring your bike on board.  Is there a bus or rail stop close enough to you to bike to it?  You could eliminate 200-250 monthly from your budget in one fell swoop.

Quote
plus $400 on food (ROUGH estimate) - as mentioned below . . .
Current expenses: Other than my monthly expenses... I do eat out more than I should. Yes, I should prepare food for myself to save money but I am so tired from work when I get home... I work from 8 to 5, but I get home at 6 because I have a 50 minute commute from work since traffic in Houston is HORRIBLE. My mom does time to time prepare food for me (without me paying for groceries as she does her own thing for food, she cooks for people). This might be a rough estimate on how much I spend on food monthly... but I think it's around $400. There was a month recently that I did go to Smoothie King every day and spent $13 on a large smoothie... that adds up, yes.
  Well, you know the answer here.  Stop doing that!  LOL!  Insert face punch here.  I do not spend much more than you to feed five people.  Pack your lunch and bring it to work.  Also, here you are mentioning how horrible the traffic is again - look into bus and rail!



Quote
So currently I'm close to achieving my goal of $10k emergency funds.
  Why so much?  What sort of emergencies are you anticipating covering?
Quote
After that, what do I do? And yes, please help me arrange what I should do with my 401k.
Index funds, Vanguard if its available in your plan.
Quote
I do want to get into investing, but I have no idea where and how to start. I'm read that vanguard is the best around here. But i'm still not sure if that's what I should do right away after I achieve my $10k emergency fund.
  I would not wait to get $10,000 together.  I would start your 401(k) maximizing now.  You are 27, you make a BUNCH of money, and you have discovered Mr. Money Mustache.  You are going to be rich in your 30s.
Quote
I plan to get Lasik surgery next year, so that will be around $1500.
  Ok, well set that aside in cash, since you are going to need it.  This is a good reason to have a savings account.
Quote
Basically I just need a good sequence of a plan so I can go from one step to another. I already have step 1 of emergency funds... unless you guys tell me to increase that.
  Increase?  I would tell you to decrease.
Quote
I just honestly don't think I earn enough (I wish i had a wife already to help me out).... but I did read the philosophy of MMM is that's a misconception and I'm just not saving enough.
  Dude, you earn plenty.  You are killing it for somebody so young.  Good job!
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with TAX DEDUCT
Post by: turketron on November 07, 2015, 11:33:56 AM
I plan to get Lasik surgery next year, so that will be around $1500.

Have you had a consultation for this yet with an actual quote for the full cost of the surgery? My costs were much higher when I had Lasik (~$3500 total) so $1500 seems low to me. Regardless, if you still have the opportunity to do so, you should allocate as much as possible of the cost of the Lasik to a FSA account for 2016. The max you can contribute is $2500, but you'd be contributing pre-tax income to this so you'll save a good amount in the end. Lasik isn't cheap but I absolutely recommend it if your prescription is as bad as mine was (-6.75/-7).
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. Feels like saving too slow, Need help
Post by: Emergo on November 07, 2015, 11:38:15 AM
Malum,

It's almost full coverage, without vandalism I think. What do you mean about "self insuring the cost of the car"?

I just did a quick research on bus routes. It takes approximately two hours going to work and two hours going back home. that's way too long...

Btw, so if I put in a lot of money in 401k, how does that help me in the future? Once it gets to 100k, I can retire? Sorry, I'm a newbie.

If I do put that $750 into 401k every two weeks. I'll only have about $500, maybe less, a month to do with what I wish. So this goes into Vanguard or house saving?

What about if I want to get married... Don't i need to save up for a wedding and a ring too?

Thanks guys!! Love ya!
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with TAX DEDUCT
Post by: Emergo on November 07, 2015, 11:39:39 AM
I plan to get Lasik surgery next year, so that will be around $1500.

Have you had a consultation for this yet with an actual quote for the full cost of the surgery? My costs were much higher when I had Lasik (~$3500 total) so $1500 seems low to me. Regardless, if you still have the opportunity to do so, you should allocate as much as possible of the cost of the Lasik to a FSA account for 2016. The max you can contribute is $2500, but you'd be contributing pre-tax income to this so you'll save a good amount in the end. Lasik isn't cheap but I absolutely recommend it if your prescription is as bad as mine was (-6.75/-7).

My friend told me that he used a Groupon deal to get it down to $1500.

I'm still not sure how FSA works and what you mean by pre-tax income...
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with TAX DEDUCT
Post by: Malum Prohibitum on November 07, 2015, 11:45:54 AM
I'm still not sure how FSA works and what you mean by pre-tax income...
  Pretax income means that it is a deduction that comes out before your income taxes are calculated.  In other words, you are not taxed on it.  It is tax free money.

So, for example, your employer deducts health insurance premiums from your paycheck.  You pay no tax on that money, even though you earned it.

Your $73.90 put into your 401(k)?  Same deal.  It is not taxable.  It is pre-tax.

Does that make more sense?

Putting money into your 401(k) reduces your taxable income from $65000.  Assuming your are paid twice monthly, the $73.90 means you are reducing your taxable income by 1773.60 a year, so you pay taxes only on $63,226.40 instead of on the full $65,000. 

If you increased your 401(k) contribution to the maximum permitted for employees, or 18,000, then only $47,000 of your income would be taxable.  The 18000 would escape taxes (or, technically, the tax would be deferring until you withdrew money from your 401(k)).

The bottom line is that it would not mean that $750 was missing from your paycheck.  It would be $750 minus whatever your marginal tax rates are, so less than $750 would be missing even though the entire $750 gets invested.
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. Feels like saving too slow, Need help
Post by: Malum Prohibitum on November 07, 2015, 11:49:36 AM
Malum,

It's almost full coverage, without vandalism I think. What do you mean about "self insuring the cost of the car"?
Just this.  Reduce the insurance coverage to the minimum liability coverage.  If you get drunk and drive off the road and crash into a tree, totaling your Rav4, you have enough cash to go out an buy a replacement used car. 

I realize the RAV4 is the largest asset in your life right now (but not for long!), but you are overinsured.  You can afford to replace it, maybe with a slightly cheaper car, but you can afford to replace it.  Losing the car to a crash you caused would not be financially devastating. 

So see if you can knock that insurance premium down from 128.04 (1536 a year) to less than fifty bucks a month.

Then you will have just that much more money to buy your future.
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. Feels like saving too slow, Need help
Post by: boarder42 on November 07, 2015, 11:54:10 AM
Malum,

It's almost full coverage, without vandalism I think. What do you mean about "self insuring the cost of the car"?

I just did a quick research on bus routes. It takes approximately two hours going to work and two hours going back home. that's way too long...

Btw, so if I put in a lot of money in 401k, how does that help me in the future? Once it gets to 100k, I can retire? Sorry, I'm a newbie.

If I do put that $750 into 401k every two weeks. I'll only have about $500, maybe less, a month to do with what I wish. So this goes into Vanguard or house saving?

What about if I want to get married... Don't i need to save up for a wedding and a ring too?

Thanks guys!! Love ya!

i dont quite understand how you're an engineer and cant understand the math with all these questions you ask

the 1500 per month doesnt hit you at 1500 per month.  at 65k you're in the 25% bracket... texas doesnt have state income tax so you are only going to see an 1125 per month hit.

128 on car insurance is bat shit crazy on a monthly basis.  shop around find something lower.

400 on food for one person - bat shit crazy

250 for gas - bat shit crazy

even if we assume this and dont decrease your expenses posted one bit. you're at 1600 a month or 19.2k per year.  YOU HAVE MONEY GOING SOMEWHERE ELSE

so lets say youre spending 25k per year. give you some fluff

you make 65k - contribute 18k to your 401k now you're making 47k

taxes on 47k - 12k
FICA on 65k - 5k

so now you have 30k leftover after just maxing your 401k

now to the what do i need to retire.  You gotta do some reading around here man...

25x your expenses.  so righ now lets say you're spending 30k annually.  you need 750k to retire. 

good luck ... you're an engineer.  look around the site take it in do some math.
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with TAX DEDUCT
Post by: boarder42 on November 07, 2015, 12:00:59 PM
also if you like the SUV and feel like you have to have one.  since you said you have an hour commute over 18 miles i assume you're sitting or traveling under 40MPH alot.  get a ford escape hybrid i get 45MPG in the summer in mine and 38 in the winter. 

i know you said its non negotiable but that 440 tithe is 10% of your income.  is there anyway to donate your time right now?  If you were investing this now you could tithe more later in life and make up the contributions.

how can you have 0 expected expenses in ER.  are you planning to buy a farm and live a sustainable life as a hermit? 
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. Feels like saving too slow, Need help
Post by: Emergo on November 07, 2015, 12:03:17 PM
Malum,

It's almost full coverage, without vandalism I think. What do you mean about "self insuring the cost of the car"?

I just did a quick research on bus routes. It takes approximately two hours going to work and two hours going back home. that's way too long...

Btw, so if I put in a lot of money in 401k, how does that help me in the future? Once it gets to 100k, I can retire? Sorry, I'm a newbie.

If I do put that $750 into 401k every two weeks. I'll only have about $500, maybe less, a month to do with what I wish. So this goes into Vanguard or house saving?

What about if I want to get married... Don't i need to save up for a wedding and a ring too?

Thanks guys!! Love ya!

i dont quite understand how you're an engineer and cant understand the math with all these questions you ask

the 1500 per month doesnt hit you at 1500 per month.  at 65k you're in the 25% bracket... texas doesnt have state income tax so you are only going to see an 1125 per month hit.

128 on car insurance is bat shit crazy on a monthly basis.  shop around find something lower.

400 on food for one person - bat shit crazy

250 for gas - bat shit crazy

even if we assume this and dont decrease your expenses posted one bit. you're at 1600 a month or 19.2k per year.  YOU HAVE MONEY GOING SOMEWHERE ELSE

so lets say youre spending 25k per year. give you some fluff

you make 65k - contribute 18k to your 401k now you're making 47k

taxes on 47k - 12k
FICA on 65k - 5k

so now you have 30k leftover after just maxing your 401k

now to the what do i need to retire.  You gotta do some reading around here man...

25x your expenses.  so righ now lets say you're spending 30k annually.  you need 750k to retire. 

good luck ... you're an engineer.  look around the site take it in do some math.

Lol, I like your post bro.

It's not the math that's hard. It's all the linggo and how those terms are applied, I find difficult understanding just yet.

But I'm learning.

As far as the car insurance, I already went through shopping for cheaper insurance. I might just follow the guy's advice and remove the other stuff and only do liability...

Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with TAX DEDUCT
Post by: Emergo on November 07, 2015, 12:05:01 PM
also if you like the SUV and feel like you have to have one.  since you said you have an hour commute over 18 miles i assume you're sitting or traveling under 40MPH alot.  get a ford escape hybrid i get 45MPG in the summer in mine and 38 in the winter. 

i know you said its non negotiable but that 440 tithe is 10% of your income.  is there anyway to donate your time right now?  If you were investing this now you could tithe more later in life and make up the contributions.

how can you have 0 expected expenses in ER.  are you planning to buy a farm and live a sustainable life as a hermit?

ER is early retirement, right? I'm not sure... what should I have in there? That's the 401k right?

Like I said, take it easy on me guys... lol

Yeah, the tithing is pretty much non-negotiable.
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with TAX DEDUCT
Post by: boarder42 on November 07, 2015, 12:23:20 PM
ER is early retirement

Retirement is leaving the work force

Early means doing something sooner than others in this case.

Expenses are the money you spend

so ER expenses would be the money that you plan to spend annually when youre no longer working at a younger age than 65

The ways in which you accrue funds such that you have 25x your expenses are numerous

Diffenent savings vehicles available to you
1. Tax Advantaged savings accounts are best your 401k is one of these accounts others include
    a. IRA - Individual Retirement Account (Roth - Post Tax maybe your only option based on income level)
    b. HSA - Health Savings account - you have an HRA at work so you can open one of these to avoid taxes on health related expenses

2. Taxable account - An account you put funds in after you have maxed out all Tax advantaged savings account.

what i would do if i were you.

1. Max your 401k
2. Max an HSA - see if your work has this as an option to come out of your paycheck as it will avoid FICA (FICA is the money the govt takes away from you for social security and medicare)
3. Max your IRA or Roth IRA depending on what you have decreased you taxable income to
4. fund a Taxable account.

Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with TAX DEDUCT
Post by: Emergo on November 07, 2015, 12:30:01 PM
ER is early retirement

Retirement is leaving the work force

Early means doing something sooner than others in this case.

Expenses are the money you spend

so ER expenses would be the money that you plan to spend annually when youre no longer working at a younger age than 65

The ways in which you accrue funds such that you have 25x your expenses are numerous

Diffenent savings vehicles available to you
1. Tax Advantaged savings accounts are best your 401k is one of these accounts others include
    a. IRA - Individual Retirement Account (Roth - Post Tax maybe your only option based on income level)
    b. HSA - Health Savings account - you have an HRA at work so you can open one of these to avoid taxes on health related expenses

2. Taxable account - An account you put funds in after you have maxed out all Tax advantaged savings account.

what i would do if i were you.

1. Max your 401k
2. Max an HSA - see if your work has this as an option to come out of your paycheck as it will avoid FICA (FICA is the money the govt takes away from you for social security and medicare)
3. Max your IRA or Roth IRA depending on what you have decreased you taxable income to
4. fund a Taxable account.

Noted, sir.

I'm assuming HSA is FSA? I guess HSA is one of those things I have to ask my HR.
IRA is something I have to speak to my HR too, I suppose.

4. Fund a taxable account... i think this is one I need more clarification on.

You are very helpful, thank you.
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with TAX DEDUCT
Post by: boarder42 on November 07, 2015, 12:31:43 PM
FSA's and HSA's are different

FSAs suck

an IRA is something you do on your own outside of work same as a taxable account

YOUR COMPANY DOESNT FUND YOUR RETIREMENT YOU DO
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. Feels like saving too slow, Need help
Post by: Malum Prohibitum on November 07, 2015, 12:34:44 PM
Lol, I like your post bro.

It's not the math that's hard. It's all the linggo and how those terms are applied, I find difficult understanding just yet.

But I'm learning.

As far as the car insurance, I already went through shopping for cheaper insurance. I might just follow the guy's advice and remove the other stuff and only do liability...
Have you had a chance to read this one yet?  http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2012/01/13/the-shockingly-simple-math-behind-early-retirement/
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with TAX DEDUCT
Post by: Malum Prohibitum on November 07, 2015, 12:42:48 PM
4. Fund a taxable account... i think this is one I need more clarification on.
Well, note that he listed that one last, but what he means is something like this, go to Vanguard online and open and account and start stuffing money in VTSAX like crazy.  That is, whatever extra money you have left over after fully funding tax advantaged accounts like your 401(k) at work and an IRA that you open (which you can also do at Vanguard online).  IRAs are limited to a maximum contribution of $5500 a year.

Take full advantage of your tax advantaged accounts first.  Then invest in taxable accounts.  Taxable just means no tax advantage.  You are investing with after tax dollars and any income from the investing is taxable.
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with TAX DEDUCT
Post by: Malum Prohibitum on November 07, 2015, 12:44:02 PM
FSAs suck
  LOL!  What boarder42 means is, in an FSA you lose whatever your do not use each year.  An HSA can sit there and grow into your old age.  You own it.
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with TAX DEDUCT
Post by: turketron on November 07, 2015, 12:52:59 PM
FSAs don't suck if you have a specific expense coming up that you know you'll be paying for, like LASIK, as he mentioned.
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with TAX DEDUCT
Post by: boarder42 on November 07, 2015, 01:02:40 PM
i just find it utterly astonishing we allow people to get thru a school system and know this little about money and taxes. 

i see you said your degree is from the philippeans meaning you may not have come up thru the school system here. 

but to make the comments that you have made (which i really think YOU DONT KNOW), its just crazy.  People spend 4-5 years getting an undergraduate engineering degree but there is no required class on what to do with the truck load of money you will be given when you leave school.  I mean even people who do personal finance for others don't really understand how all this works.
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with TAX DEDUCT
Post by: Malum Prohibitum on November 07, 2015, 01:19:17 PM
i just find it utterly astonishing we allow people to get thru a school system and know this little about money and taxes. 

i see you said your degree is from the philippeans meaning you may not have come up thru the school system here. 

but to make the comments that you have made (which i really think YOU DONT KNOW), its just crazy.  People spend 4-5 years getting an undergraduate engineering degree but there is no required class on what to do with the truck load of money you will be given when you leave school.  I mean even people who do personal finance for others don't really understand how all this works.
  If I moved and took a job in the Phillipines I would have no idea about investing for retirement and taxes and such over there.  I would have to learn about PERAs and all sorts of new stuff.  These things have to be learned.
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with TAX DEDUCT
Post by: Emergo on November 07, 2015, 02:04:45 PM
The thing about my commuting expenses... it basically offsets if I had been renting an apartment. Sure, it makes my vehicle depreciate more by the miles I put in it, but still...

Another thing I forgot to mention...
How come no one has mentioned saving up for a down payment on a house? Is that against the MMM rule?

I may need to save up for one for my dad... who is basically homeless and I may need to help buy him a small home. ($50k) is this too much and will put a damper on my plans? Or does anyone have an alternative on what I can do for my dad? Move into an apartment with him? He basically has nothing for his future and I am his only son. He works a 10 dollar security job. Please help.
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with TAX DEDUCT
Post by: Murse on November 07, 2015, 03:01:01 PM
The thing about my commuting expenses... it basically offsets if I had been renting an apartment. Sure, it makes my vehicle depreciate more by the miles I put in it, but still...

Another thing I forgot to mention...
How come no one has mentioned saving up for a down payment on a house? Is that against the MMM rule?

I may need to save up for one for my dad... who is basically homeless and I may need to help buy him a small home. ($50k) is this too much and will put a damper on my plans? Or does anyone have an alternative on what I can do for my dad? Move into an apartment with him? He basically has nothing for his future and I am his only son. He works a 10 dollar security job. Please help.
This community will drastically change the projection of your life if you stick around to learn. Home ownership beliefs are split here, everyone thinks given the option it has to be a smart financial move, but many believe the non tangibles of owning a home sometimes outweigh the financials. The advice here is to know if the home is a good buy when compared to renting.
I prefer videos so here is this http://youtu.be/ZH_bIPkozjg
But here is the original Blog post as well http://jlcollinsnh.com/2013/05/29/why-your-house-is-a-terrible-investment/

As for helping your dad many people feel differently about this too. My personal belief is that you have to help yourself before you help others. Personally, I feel that I have a future to protect but will help out where I can. In this case you need to find out what is better in your market, renting vs buying (you are never going to beat your current rental arrangement with mom,) and then decide what you can do for him.
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. Feels like saving too slow, Need help
Post by: SKL-HOU on November 07, 2015, 03:08:23 PM
Malum,

It's almost full coverage, without vandalism I think. What do you mean about "self insuring the cost of the car"?
Just this.  Reduce the insurance coverage to the minimum liability coverage.  If you get drunk and drive off the road and crash into a tree, totaling your Rav4, you have enough cash to go out an buy a replacement used car. 

I realize the RAV4 is the largest asset in your life right now (but not for long!), but you are overinsured.  You can afford to replace it, maybe with a slightly cheaper car, but you can afford to replace it.  Losing the car to a crash you caused would not be financially devastating. 

So see if you can knock that insurance premium down from 128.04 (1536 a year) to less than fifty bucks a month.

Then you will have just that much more money to buy your future.

I would strongly recommend against this type of advice for a person who has no idea what pre-tax income, or any other finances are. If he gets in an accident that is his fault, he will not understand why the insurance is not paying for his car.

OP: i think before you do anything, you need to take a class, read up, whatever you need to do to learn and understand all of these very basic things.
Personally, i would not do anything internet strangers tells you without fully understanding the consequences.
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with DAD INFO
Post by: Dee18 on November 07, 2015, 03:41:17 PM
I personally would keep collision insurance on my car with $1000 deductible.  I suspect you have a lower deductible to have rates that high...or a bad driving record.  As for those smoothies, get an immersion blender like this (currently $25 at Homegooods) and some protein powder and make your own:
http://www.amazon.com/Conair-Cuisinart-CSB-75BC-Blender-Brushed/dp/B00ARQVM5O
They will cost 1/5 as much.
For cooking, do it on the weekend and freeze/refrigerate enough for the week.  Planning ahead just a little bit will save you thousands.
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with DAD INFO
Post by: MDM on November 07, 2015, 04:24:28 PM
I'm going to follow the stickied topic's guideline on how to make posts easy for people to help me. If it's wrong in any shape or form, please forgive me. Also, I found the spreadsheet provided very intimidating, so I did not do it.
If, as it appears from previous posts, you are starting with almost no financial knowledge, the spreadsheet probably is intimidating.  I'll suggest, however, that you go back and give it another try, posting specific questions here as needed.  By doing so, it should help you understand
 * what your taxes - and thus your withholding amounts - should be.  For relatively simple cases (e.g., yours) it will do a very good job calculating 2015 federal, SS, and medicare taxes based on your inputs.
 * where your money is going (the spreadsheet itself won't tell you this, but does remind you that you should be keeping track)
 * opportunity for investing (i.e., how much could you be investing) and opportunities for tax savings
 * a rough idea of how long - given current conditions - it might be until you would be FI.

Quote
Adjusted Gross Income: Umm if this means how much I get out of my paycheck....
This is a term used for federal tax returns - see Form 1040 (https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/f1040.pdf).  We ask for this as a double check on what you have entered for gross income and pre-tax deductions.

Quote
Taxes: Federal, state/local, and FICA.  - I have no idea what this section is.
How much you pay for each.  For FICA, pay=withhold.  For Texas, state=0.  For federal, the spreadsheet (or TaxCaster, etc.) can tell you the annual amount you should owe, and you can compare that with the amount you are having withheld.

Quote
Specific Question(s):
So currently I'm close to achieving my goal of $10k emergency funds.
After that, what do I do?
See the 'Investment Order' tab in the spreadsheet (http://forum.mrmoneymustache.com/ask-a-mustachian/how-to-write-a-%27case-study%27-topic/msg274228/#msg274228).
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with DAD INFO
Post by: Emergo on November 07, 2015, 05:30:37 PM
Ok, thanks guys.

What do yall think of Dave Ramseys advice? Yay or nay?
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with DAD INFO
Post by: Malum Prohibitum on November 07, 2015, 05:40:42 PM
Ok, thanks guys.

What do yall think of Dave Ramseys advice? Yay or nay?
  For getting out of debt?  It's great for focusing on that task.  For investing for FI, I do not so much like his advice.  After getting rid of debt, he suggests 3-6 months of emergency savings, then investing only 15%, then college funding for children  . . .  Those with a focus on FIRE are going to have to do way better than that on savings rate and put their money to work.
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with DAD INFO
Post by: Murse on November 07, 2015, 05:41:24 PM
Ok, thanks guys.

What do yall think of Dave Ramseys advice? Yay or nay?

Dave Ramsey is great for the general population, especially those in debt. His advice is designed for the person that works from 20-60years old, and as will be noted by many his investing advice is sub par. Having said all of that, he is a great starting point, and likely started many here.
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. Feels like saving too slow, Need help
Post by: Malum Prohibitum on November 07, 2015, 05:42:14 PM
OP: i think before you do anything, you need to take a class, read up, whatever you need to do to learn and understand all of these very basic things.
Personally, i would not do anything internet strangers tells you without fully understanding the consequences.
  Very good advice.  Of course, reading here and on MMM's blog should be a part of that.
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with DAD INFO
Post by: Emergo on November 09, 2015, 05:48:59 AM
So it's Monday, and im going to get started on doing the things with my 401k like you guys said. Question though,

I was told that i can talk to someone in my company about arranging where my 401k investments are allocated and put them where i want them? What does this mean?

So theres a penalty if i want to grab money from my 401k before the age of 60... how will i be able to retire early if this is this is the case? Theres a penalty of 50% i believe? And its taxed?

So does that mean my main source of income if i get to retirement early is the interest i gain from my investments in mutual funds? Is that how this works?

Btw, what do you guys think of news coming out of iran today ? That might mean bad news for the security of my job, yeah?
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: boarder42 on November 09, 2015, 06:38:07 AM
Its a 10% penalty and then you pay normal income taxes on it.

There are many ways to get your money out of your 401k avoiding this penalty.

Start with saving the max to your 401k then you can learn how to get it out but there are 2 main ways a Roth ladder, and SEPP.(yeah more acronyms but just know you can get it without penalty)

I expect you have a self managed 401k meaning you can go online setup an account and set your asset allocation.  You need to provide us a list of what you can invest in and what the fees are.  This will dictate where you money should go.  Look for the fund ticker symbol like VTSAX and the Expense Ratio this is what we would need to help you direct your investments appropriately
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: Emergo on November 09, 2015, 10:38:04 AM
I found the ticker symbols, but i'm not sure which number is the expense ratios. Ill compile the list today once i know. You guys are a lifesaver.
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: boarder42 on November 09, 2015, 10:53:55 AM
there should be a tab you can go to which allows you to review investment options/research and it should have a column showing expense ratio.  its usually next to the 1yr, 5yr, 10yr annual percentage gains.
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: Malum Prohibitum on November 09, 2015, 11:04:53 AM
Emergo,

Just enter each one of those ticker symbols into Google, and you will get all the information you could ever want.  For example, I entered your fist ticker symbol into Google and got this as one of the responses http://www.morningstar.com/funds/XNAS/WSMIX/quote.html showing a 1.15% under expenses (really high).

Just Google each one of them if the information is not readily available on the 401(k) web site (although it should be there, somewhere).

 
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: Emergo on November 09, 2015, 11:07:26 AM
Domestic:

WSMIX, 4.16%

 

Global:

ARTIX, 1.17%

ODMAX, 1.33%

OSMAX, 1.22%

 

Mid-cap:

VEXAX, 0.10%

 

Large/Multicap:

ABSIX, 0.89%

PEYAX, 0.98%

PINVX, 1.08%
Putnam S&P 500 Index Fund (No Ticker symbol), 0.35%

PABGX, 0.98%

 

Income/bond:

PGBOX, 0.98%

PTTAX, 0.85%
PDINX, 0.97%

 

Capital Preservation:

PDDXX, 0.49%

 

Mixed Asset:

OAKBX, 0.74%

PABAX, 1.00%

PACAX, 1.04%

PAEAX, 1.07%

 

Right now, everything's in PABAX ($4,500)
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: Malum Prohibitum on November 09, 2015, 11:08:06 AM
Right now, everything's in PABAX ($4,500)
  1% expenses
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: Emergo on November 09, 2015, 11:09:51 AM
How did you get 1 when i got 4.16% on my 401k site?
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: Emergo on November 09, 2015, 11:10:45 AM
Right now, everything's in PABAX ($4,500)
  1% expenses

Huh?
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: boarder42 on November 09, 2015, 11:11:26 AM
i'm not familiar with VEXAX very much, (maybe someone else here is) but my top 2 choices for all of you money would be

VEXAX exp ratio .1% (lowest expense ratio you have)
or that Putnam S&P 500 looks like it has a .35% expense ratio

PABAX is awful at a 1% expense Ratio

what is an Expense ratio its the money the financial institution is taking from their profits and or losses each year

ie.

if the holdings in PABAX go up 5% this year you will only see PABAX go up 4%

Thats why this is a huge deal.

I'd probably do some research on VEXAX and the end up with all my money there or in the Putnam S&P index fund.
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: boarder42 on November 09, 2015, 11:13:43 AM
How did you get 1 when i got 4.16% on my 401k site?

the 4.16% youre seeing on your site isnt an expense ratio its likely your YTD profit on your investments.
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: PARedbeard on November 09, 2015, 11:14:28 AM
Emergo: expense ratios will be key here as well as your long term plans. Go through each of those symbols, see their expense ratios, and look at their top 10 holdings. You want to knwo what you are buying into. If you are going with an index fund (which will have one of the lowest expense ratios, probably), make sure you know WHICH indexes you are investing in (i.e. which country and what type of stocks/securities).

 And just to add my two cents to the top discussion: for me, my 401k isn't my golden trail to FI (financial independence) or RE. I am hoping to live a frugal enough life that I will be able to achieve FI even without that money. Instead, it is my safety net. I know that by contributing to it now, it assures me financial resources when I get older (I'm also 27). That chunk of change waiting for my when I'm 59 1/2 means that I will have a continuity of whatever life I choose to lead in FI. Additionally, by contributing, I do two important things: 1) I limit my available spending power (a big thing for me, as I used to be a spendthrift), and 2) the IRS sees my "earned income" as being essentially lower, making me pay less in taxes. Those two combined effects are pretty powerful. It helps me discipline myself as well as limits my tax burden.

Good luck!
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: Emergo on November 09, 2015, 11:49:49 AM
Okay... so research VEXAX.

Now I just have to wrap my head around IRA and Roth IRA and how im going to approach those.
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: Emergo on November 09, 2015, 11:53:48 AM
But Redbeard, you can take your money out without any penalty before 60 like boarder said? Your golden trail is just spending less??
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: Kaspian on November 09, 2015, 12:10:35 PM
Yes, I should prepare food for myself to save money but I am so tired from work when I get home...

So is everybody.  I can't think of a single person who comes home from a full day of work feeling refreshed.  (Is there such thing as a professional sleeping job somewhere?  'Cause damn, I'm fully qualified, where can I sign up?)

Once you start making more of your own meals (and that involves chopping stuff, not pre-packaged or just-add-milk foods), you'll eventually start to enjoy it and won't enjoy takeout much at all.  Bad day at work?  Feeling tired or stressed?  I take that shit out on onions and carrots with a really sharp knife.  Plus it's way healthier!  You'll realize just how much fat, salt, and sugar restaurants put in their shlop.
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: Emergo on November 09, 2015, 12:31:42 PM
So i did a brief look at what vexax is... my brain is going to explode with all these newer terms (not mentioned in this thread).
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: Emergo on November 09, 2015, 02:44:54 PM
So is getting your 401k money without penalty legal or just a very big and secret loophole? Because no one I know seems to know about it.
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: Malum Prohibitum on November 09, 2015, 02:51:22 PM
So is getting your 401k money without penalty legal or just a very big and secret loophole? Because no one I know seems to know about it.
  Legal, and you should not be surprised that nobody with whom you are acquainted knows about it.  I also do not personally know anybody who saves 50% or more of his income. 

I just read about it here.

Seriously, go research what people are telling you here and reach your own conclusions.
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: Emergo on November 09, 2015, 03:13:12 PM
I will. And i totally appreciate everyones patience and advice for me! Cheers fellas.
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: Check2400 on November 09, 2015, 03:32:22 PM
So, I've read the responses, and think we need to bring you back to some tangible items to do for the first steps.  I also agree that you would be benefitted greatly from meeting with an hourly/consultation retirement planner in person.  People here may disagree as it is money spent on information that could be obtained by diligent research, but I can't imagine learning the difficult language of personal finance when you are having to filter it through (I assume) your own grasp of everyday English.

Here is my opinion.
1) open a Mint. com account.  Lots of colors and graphs and trends and lets you start learning where your money is going.
2) Cut the Equifax.  You'll be able to monitor you Credit cards via mint, and there is no reason that you will need to have $250/year for this unnecessary service.
3)  Find out what you are contributing to your 401K, and then max it out.  It sounds like you're doing around 1500 a year right now at a minimum (you have $56 every two weeks listed at 401K match).  Either way, if you are interested in early retirement, go ahead and start maxing it out now, or at least start the first paycheck of 2016 at max to finish off your emergency fund.
-----The reason that this is recommended is that it saves you money that grows exponentially.  For every 1500 you put into your 401k, you "lose" about only about 1000 from your paycheck since that money is not taxed.  Yes, you will have less money.  This is what you need to do though, it will train you automatically to live within your budget.
4) If you can sell your SUV and get a hybrid, then do so.  You'll save a good chunk of gas money which, along with the insurance going down because you're going to take the good advice here and get a bare bones policy, will help make up the retirement savings you won't get coming through your paycheck.

Those four things are a great first step.  If you can do that, acclimate to the new normal for a few months, and continue to learn, you'll be on solid footing.  You don't have to go for broke right away (no pun intended?). 

You're rightfully concerned about housing, ring, wife, etc.--after all, what are Mustachians if not planners?  But it sounds like you're using these as excuses to do the basics.  When you find a home, or a girlfriend, you won't be having to make a snap decision on that purchase. 

From there, there is only the continued slashing of budgets, and the educated investments of funding.  A Roth IRA seems like a great vehicle for you for step II, as you will be able to continue saving over your 401K, but still have access to the Principal Funds to withdraw for housing, Rings, etc. when the time comes.  There is risk there, but there is also growth.

That is my two cents.  You've gotten the full fisted facepunch from the forums, but much like savings, take this one step at a time.  I also respectfully defer to the others here that think that any of those four steps should be substituted out for another, but I do think that for you in particular, we should be offering more introductory steps for your planning. 

-CHECK

Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: Mother Fussbudget on November 09, 2015, 04:12:57 PM
Here is my opinion.
1) open a Mint. com account.  Lots of colors and graphs and trends and lets you start learning where your money is going.
2) Cut the Equifax.  You'll be able to monitor you Credit cards via mint, and there is no reason that you will need to have $250/year for this unnecessary service.
3)  Find out what you are contributing to your 401K, and then max it out.  It sounds like you're doing around 1500 a year right now at a minimum (you have $56 every two weeks listed at 401K match).  Either way, if you are interested in early retirement, go ahead and start maxing it out now, or at least start the first paycheck of 2016 at max to finish off your emergency fund.
-----The reason that this is recommended is that it saves you money that grows exponentially.  For every 1500 you put into your 401k, you "lose" about only about 1000 from your paycheck since that money is not taxed.  Yes, you will have less money.  This is what you need to do though, it will train you automatically to live within your budget.
4) If you can sell your SUV and get a hybrid, then do so.  You'll save a good chunk of gas money which, along with the insurance going down because you're going to take the good advice here and get a bare bones policy, will help make up the retirement savings you won't get coming through your paycheck.
+1 for what Check said.  Great advice.

Once you've COMPLETED the first 4 steps:
5) Go to the Vanguard.com website, and open a Traditional IRA account for yourself.
6) Deposit $$ into your Vanguard IRA.
7) When you have >$10K, purchase VTSAX [NOTE:  Vanguard waives the fee/commission when buying their ETF/Mutual funds in a Vanguard brokerage account!].
8) Each month, add $$ to the Vanguard IRA account, and purchase that amount of VTSAX. [example:  if you deposit $750/month, buy $750 of VTSAX once the deposit clears].

If you want to read more about retirement accounts, the differences in them, and a good strategy that folks here have investigated, and follow, read http://www.madfientist.com/traditional-ira-vs-roth-ira/

Lastly... Welcome!  Don't worry about "getting" the buzz-words. 
You want to 'FIRE' yourself - become "Financially Independent / Retire Early". 
The earlier you start, the better your chance of achieving your "FI number" while you're young.
The best part:  you've ALREADY STARTED by reading here.  All the best!  :-)

---
Edited: 
For extra credit reading, check out (and read) "Your Money Or Your Life" from the local library.   
Also read the MadFientist's website (link above) his goal is to save as much as possible while minimizing the tax hit TODAY, and in the future. 
Finally - read JH Collins' "Stock Series".  http://jlcollinsnh.com/stock-series/
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: ShoulderThingThatGoesUp on November 09, 2015, 04:27:41 PM
Or use Schwab and SCHB and skip the $10k VTSAX annoyance.
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: BarkyardBQ on November 09, 2015, 04:31:04 PM
Or use Schwab and SCHB and skip the $10k VTSAX annoyance.

Or just buy VTSMX and start with 3k.
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: Emergo on November 09, 2015, 04:31:46 PM
It would take me a long time to get another 10k. Maybe i should just invest my 10k i saved for my emergency fund since i could always take it out?
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: Emergo on November 09, 2015, 04:35:07 PM
If i do all you guys say and do it right, how early would i be able to retire with the salary i have?
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: MDM on November 09, 2015, 04:46:56 PM
If i do all you guys say and do it right, how early would i be able to retire with the salary i have?
Depends on how much of that salary you invest, how much you expect to spend in retirement, etc.  See some numbers below.  If you have different assumptions, see the 'Misc. calcs' tab in the case study spreadsheet and enter your numbers there. 

Quick calculation of "Time to FI"
Planned Withdrawal RateWR4.0%
Annual Savings InvestedS30,000$/yr
Annual Retirement ExpensesE30,000$/yr
Current Assets InvestedA0$
Investment returnr_5.0%
Time to FIt16.6yr
Desired time to FIt6.0yr
Annual Savings NeededS110,263$/yr
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: ShoulderThingThatGoesUp on November 09, 2015, 04:48:57 PM
Or use Schwab and SCHB and skip the $10k VTSAX annoyance.

Or just buy VTSMX and start with 3k.

.17% ER. SCHB is 0.04%. People really let their Vanguard loyalty blind them sometimes.
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: BarkyardBQ on November 09, 2015, 04:50:55 PM
Or use Schwab and SCHB and skip the $10k VTSAX annoyance.

Or just buy VTSMX and start with 3k.

.17% ER. SCHB is 0.04%. People really let their Vanguard loyalty blind them sometimes.


Depends on where you WANT to be long term. As long as you meet the 10k before the end of a quarter you can reclassify and get the lower ER.

edit: And speaking of blindness...

I think SCHB is missing some stocks. 2,081 vs 3,809 (VTI/VTSMX/VTSAX)

I guess the fund should cost less if the managers are doing less work. ;)


Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: Capt Stubble on November 09, 2015, 05:05:25 PM
A couple of cultural notes:

If your Filipino family (aunts, uncles, cousins living in the Philippines) is similar to my GF's family, you're going to have to get comfortable with saying "no." A lot. An American salaried engineer looks a lot like an ATM to someone who works at Jollibee in the province.

Where does your father live currently? I assume he's able to work now, but possibly not much longer? And he has little or no retirement savings? When the time comes, you might want to move him back to the Philippines where housing and medical expenses can be very cheap.

Feel free to disregard the above, especially if I've made incorrect assumptions.
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: Emergo on November 09, 2015, 05:19:32 PM
A couple of cultural notes:

If your Filipino family (aunts, uncles, cousins living in the Philippines) is similar to my GF's family, you're going to have to get comfortable with saying "no." A lot. An American salaried engineer looks a lot like an ATM to someone who works at Jollibee in the province.

Where does your father live currently? I assume he's able to work now, but possibly not much longer? And he has little or no retirement savings? When the time comes, you might want to move him back to the Philippines where housing and medical expenses can be very cheap.

Feel free to disregard the above, especially if I've made incorrect assumptions.

Lol i'm good at saying no, brother. He lives in the same city, but with my aunt. He cant live there forever, as shes just doing him a favor for me (theyre not related, its my mom's sister in law). Shes probably okay with him living there for a year or two more. I wish i could move him to the Philippines, but america is his home. He moved here when he was a teenager. But even if he approved... that would be pretty expensive buying him a home over there. And then what will be his income there to eat?
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: ShoulderThingThatGoesUp on November 09, 2015, 05:52:29 PM
Or use Schwab and SCHB and skip the $10k VTSAX annoyance.

Or just buy VTSMX and start with 3k.

.17% ER. SCHB is 0.04%. People really let their Vanguard loyalty blind them sometimes.


Depends on where you WANT to be long term. As long as you meet the 10k before the end of a quarter you can reclassify and get the lower ER.

edit: And speaking of blindness...

I think SCHB is missing some stocks. 2,081 vs 3,809 (VTI/VTSMX/VTSAX)

I guess the fund should cost less if the managers are doing less work. ;)

Correlation of 1.00 according to Portfolio Visualizer. So I'm not too worried about a few hundred stocks.
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: PARedbeard on November 10, 2015, 08:05:26 AM
What CHECK said above makes sense to me. Using a ROTH will allow you access to any contributions you make while also allowing you to have tax-free money later in life. So long as you are putting enough money into the 401k to reduce your taxes to the lowest category, it seems like a win-win!

 As for the 401k transfer, I think it is very legal, though I haven't looked into it much. Not to overload you, but there is something called a "ROTH conversion ladder/pipeline", which allows you to convert funds in (I believe, don't quote me on this--I'm just starting to explore it myself) a 401k or Traditional IRA. Since the money you convert is considered a "contribution," you can access it after 5 years. There may be other ways to get get money directly out of a 401k penalty-free, but I am not well-versed in 401k stuff yet, as I only got a job offering a 401k two months ago.

Better minds than mine can certainly help you with this! A forum member called "seattlecyclone" comes to me. He writes a lot on 401ks and IRAs.
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: boarder42 on November 10, 2015, 08:12:02 AM
Lets go down the getting the savings in the right place first before we start worrying about how to get the money out.  He needs to understand WHY we are telling him these things about where to put his money.  Not just follow an internet blog forum blindly.  once he understands why we are recommending these steps he can move on to the how do i get to my money in RE.

Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: PARedbeard on November 10, 2015, 08:16:55 AM
Amen, Boarder. Amen.
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: fiveoh on November 10, 2015, 09:53:57 AM
I agree with boarder42 as well.

My take is this guy is either trolling or needs to go read all the mmm posts and/or a basic finance site.  Most of the advice being thrown out here is for someone that has a handle on these things and he clearly doesn't.(or is trolling) 
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: Emergo on November 10, 2015, 11:06:51 AM
Geez, i'm sorry. And i'm not trolling. Im going to put in time to learn these things, just havent had a chance yet ( posted this topic less than a week ago)
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: fiveoh on November 10, 2015, 11:25:28 AM
Geez, i'm sorry. And i'm not trolling. Im going to put in time to learn these things, just havent had a chance yet ( posted this topic less than a week ago)

http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2013/02/22/getting-rich-from-zero-to-hero-in-one-blog-post/ Answers most of your questions if you are serious.
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: PARedbeard on November 10, 2015, 11:38:14 AM
Hey Emergo,
It's going to take time--finances definitely has its own lingo. You'll get there soon enough. There is a lot of background info that you will need to get a grasp on first, which will help accelerate your ability to make wise tax-sheltered and FI decisions. And honestly, you can get as much feedback from this forum as you like, but the ultimate decisions come down to you. Fiveoh and Boarder are leading you in a good direction. MMM provides an excellent background understanding of getting your financial house in order in that post.
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: Mother Fussbudget on November 10, 2015, 11:49:54 AM
What CHECK said above makes sense to me. Using a ROTH will allow you access to any contributions you make while also allowing you to have tax-free money later in life. So long as you are putting enough money into the 401k to reduce your taxes to the lowest category, it seems like a win-win!

 As for the 401k transfer, I think it is very legal, though I haven't looked into it much. Not to overload you, but there is something called a "ROTH conversion ladder/pipeline", which allows you to convert funds in (I believe, don't quote me on this--I'm just starting to explore it myself) a 401k or Traditional IRA. Since the money you convert is considered a "contribution," you can access it after 5 years. There may be other ways to get get money directly out of a 401k penalty-free, but I am not well-versed in 401k stuff yet, as I only got a job offering a 401k two months ago.

Better minds than mine can certainly help you with this! A forum member called "seattlecyclone" comes to me. He writes a lot on 401ks and IRAs.
Agreed.  But let's leave the  IRA to Roth IRA conversion ladder (http://www.madfientist.com/retire-even-earlier/) process to a later date once he has begun investing for FI.  But agreed that should eventually be in his plan.  Best tax advantages are if he performs conversion(s) once he's at FI and in a lower tax bracket, hence my suggestions in a step-by-step list include put funds in a Traditional IRA. 
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: boarder42 on November 10, 2015, 02:01:25 PM
I think you've got a good basis and a lot of work to do now OP.  You came here pretty scattered and all over the place from houses to engagement rings to FI, sounds like you're trying to figure out some of life in general.  If you can read up and understand your finances you will be in a great place moving forward, and the rest of these questions will start to answer themselves.  There are even posts on here about ways to make budget engagement rings that look fantastic and are 100% custom.
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: pompera_firpa on November 11, 2015, 07:34:34 AM
Okay, everyone has really covered all the basics re: 401k and insurance and whatnot, so this is just my extra.

First of all: congratulations! You're going much, much better than the average American at saving money. This is awesome!  That said:

I didn't see anyone mention this, but you listed employer matching for your 401k without seeming to know much about it.  Do some research! Find out what the percentage is (it looks like they match 75% of your contribution?) and, if there's a cut-off point for the match, where that point is (most employers cut off matching once their contribution gets to a certain percentage of your base pay-- often 6%), when will you be vested in the program ("vested" = "you get to keep the employer contributions even if you leave the company if you've worked here for X number of years, otherwise they keep that money"), etc.  This is FREE MONEY! You'll need to know what you're dealing with, otherwise you'll be lacking information that you'll need for making decisions in the future.

In short: if your employer contributes up to 6% of your base pay, by maxing out your 401k contributions and pulling in an employer match, you would be getting nearly the same amount of savings per paycheck-- $842 (averaged over the year) vs. $875-- but you would have nearly $500 left over after bills, instead of about $60.

At $500/paycheck, you would have the money for LASIK very quickly, and then you could go ahead and start tossing that money into whatever investments you choose.

You'd be saving 42% of your gross income, plus whatever % of your income your employer matches for the 401k-- and that is BEFORE you start to make any adjustments regarding food, driving, insurance, dropping Equifax, etc., AND before taking into account those two "extra" paychecks a year.  Definitely, definitely a no-brainer.

For further tweaking:

1) You need to cook. If a future wife is on your mind, think of this as an investment in lady-finding, because women love men who can cook. I know you're exhausted at the end of the day-- aren't we all!-- so you'll need to find some time that isn't in the midst of driving-- doing all the prep work in the morning before you leave for work, or making a bunch of meals on the weekend that you freeze for heat-and-eat on weeknights, or even just stocking up on cheap frozen pizzas.

2) Start tracking your expenses. Just trust me on this one.

3) See if you can find alternatives to driving for car trips that aren't your commute.

4) While there's no improving on your living situation from a financial standpoint, the other end of the commute question is where you work. Start a long-term research project to get a feel for what the jobs are like within a five-mile radius of your mom's house. Keep an eye on this, via Indeed searches or something similar. Between the gas, the EZ-Tags, and the awful drain on your time/energy/quality of life, your current commute is not something you'll want to keep forever.

Good luck!
Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: ooeei on November 11, 2015, 07:56:41 AM
Hey Emergo, I'm a 26 year old engineer in Houston, so I can kind of see where you're coming from.  As much as the commute sucks, it's probably financially better than moving close to work (due to your really low rent at home).  It sounds like you've got a good grasp of English, but maybe not an "advanced" grasp required to talk about all of this financial stuff at the moment. 

Since you don't know exactly what you're doing yet, I'd recommend boosting up your 401k to about 10% of your pay (someone at HR should be able to help) and put it in one of the funds someone above recommended.  In the meantime, read up on what an Traditional IRA, Roth IRA, and 401k are and how they work.  Google is your friend!  Once you've read up more you can come back here with more detailed questions and get some helpful advice.  I like 20somethingfinance.com and getrichslowly.org for info on stuff like that.

The basic rule for retiring is that whatever you have invested you can withdraw 4% per year without the investment decreasing (the gains in the investment offset what you're taking out).  That means you can take your yearly expenses and multiply them by 25 to find out what you need invested to live off your investments.

If you live off $20,000/year, you need $20,000*25= $500,000 invested to "retire."  If you live off $30,000 you need $750,000.  If it's you and a family, and you're taking care of a parent or family member, and donating to a church, you're probably going to be spending over $40,000/year ($1,000,000 needs to be invested)

From the sounds of it, you want to retire early, but also want to help out family and your church.  While that is admirable, those goals are working against each other for the most part.  For example, that $440/month you tithe adds up over time.  If you invested that money every month for 10 years you'd have $76,000 (assuming 7% interest).  That's enough to buy your dad a house.  If you invested it every month for 20 years you'd have $230,000.  If you invested it every month for 40 years you'd have over $1,000,000. http://www.moneychimp.com/calculator/compound_interest_calculator.htm is what I used for the calculation.

As for buying your dad a house, I know it's a cultural difference.  My girlfriend is Chinese and there is a bit of an expectation that the kids take care of the old parents.  There are all sorts of arguments as to whether that is beneficial overall, but it is what it is.  You have the unfortunate position of being in the "bridge" generation where you're considered responsible for your dad's retirement, but will also be responsible for your own.  I recommend having a talk with your dad about what he expects, and before making any promises run all of the numbers and see what's doable/worth it to you. 

Caring for your aging parent and supporting the church will move back your retirement date significantly.  If you get married and have kids, your future spouse will have a large impact as well.  If she's the type who likes big houses, fancy clothes, and nice cars, you'll probably be working until you're in your 60's.  If she's frugal and your dad doesn't have any large expenses (which he very well might), you can probably quit in your 40's.

Also, don't discount things like restaurants as not being a big deal financially.  Small expenses add up over time.  http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2011/04/15/getting-started-3-eliminate-short-termitis-the-bankruptcy-disease/

Title: Re: CASE STUDY: Houston, 27 male,New to MMM. saving slowly - UPDATED with QUESTIONS
Post by: Emergo on November 11, 2015, 05:12:52 PM
Thanks again for everyones input. I'm working on it.

Question: does anyone recommend a podcast i can listen to? MMM doesnt have one, as far as i know? Podcast for beginners or one that will share useful info. I like to listen in my car on the way to work. (50 min commute)
Title: Re: Houston, single male, 27 y.o., 65k slry, 0 debt, MMMnewb,podcast question update
Post by: Emergo on November 11, 2015, 08:03:50 PM
Also, i know MMM provided a list of his favorite books, but is there an end all, be all MMM book? Would be useful on my vacation train ride coming up next week.
Title: Re: Houston, single male, 27 y.o., 65k slry, 0 debt, MMMnewb,podcast question update
Post by: ooeei on November 11, 2015, 08:11:48 PM
Also, i know MMM provided a list of his favorite books, but is there an end all, be all MMM book? Would be useful on my vacation train ride coming up next week.

You could always start from the beginning on the blog :P
Title: Re: Houston, single male, 27 y.o., 65k slry, 0 debt, MMMnewb,podcast question update
Post by: Emergo on November 11, 2015, 08:36:20 PM
Also, i know MMM provided a list of his favorite books, but is there an end all, be all MMM book? Would be useful on my vacation train ride coming up next week.

You could always start from the beginning on the blog :P

I don't have a tablet to view his blog, only my phone. And i dont want to be on my phone during the whole ride. Otherwise... thats a lot of pages to print lol
Title: Re: Houston, single male, 27 y.o., 65k slry, 0 debt, MMMnewb,podcast question update
Post by: norabird on November 11, 2015, 08:43:45 PM
Your Money or Your Life and the Millionaire Next Door are good general books to start with about expenses and attitudes towards money. You could probably read Warren Buffett bios or David Swensen's books for a general investing take.
Title: Re: Houston, single male, 27 y.o., 65k slry, 0 debt, MMMnewb,podcast question update
Post by: MDM on November 11, 2015, 08:48:18 PM
Also, i know MMM provided a list of his favorite books, but is there an end all, be all MMM book? Would be useful on my vacation train ride coming up next week.

Another list of three "starter" books you might be able to borrow from your local library:
A Random Walk Down Wall Street by Burton Malkiel
The Millionaire Next Door by Thomas Stanley/William Danko
The Four Pillars of Investing by William Bernstein
Title: Re: Houston, single male, 27 y.o., 65k slry, 0 debt, MMMnewb,podcast question update
Post by: Emergo on November 12, 2015, 09:32:46 AM
Cool, any podcasts?
Title: Re: Houston, single male, 27 y.o., 65k slry, 0 debt, MMMnewb,podcast question update
Post by: AmandaS1989 on November 12, 2015, 09:35:50 AM
Maybe Listen Money Matters podcasts would be to your liking. I think they're on iTunes as well as their website
Title: Re: Houston, single male, 27 y.o., 65k slry, 0 debt, MMMnewb,podcast question update
Post by: Emergo on November 13, 2015, 04:48:17 AM
Did a lot of one on one counseling with my friend on the terms mentioned in this thread, and i feel more enlightened now. Im still struggling to decide which IRA is best for me though. Boarder says ira roth because of my income post tax... but im not sure what that means. I looked at madfientists method of go traditional now and convert to roth ira later, which makes sense. But im still on the bubble.

My friend also didnt know anything about HSA, which i read is the ultimate retirement account because its tax free all the way and you can pay it anytime and get reimbursed for it pre tax. And it grows... ahhh i dont understand that.

Im getting there guys! Slowly but surely. Understanding everything now.
Title: Re: Houston, single male, 27 y.o., 65k slry, 0 debt, MMMnewb,podcast question update
Post by: Emergo on November 13, 2015, 06:02:08 AM
Me and my friend just dissected HSA a bit from the mad fientist website. And i get it kinda..

So i put in 3000 every year, and for every medical expense i do i can get reimbursed at any time i want, so i can keep that in my HSA and at my retirement, all the reimbursements I have will likely equal or outweigh the tax from when i withdraw all the money i had that was growing in HSA
 Correct? So it sounds like a loophole, and the only way anyone who does this will get screwed is if they change the rule to doing reimbursements allowable up til one year on the receipts.
Title: Re: The Emergo Zero to Hero Progress Thread... Thanks to YOU!
Post by: boarder42 on November 13, 2015, 06:41:38 AM
You're good to go Traditional IRA.  you're income after maxing a 401k and HSA will put you in the ballpark to go traditional. 
Title: Re: The Emergo Zero to Hero Progress Thread... Thanks to YOU!
Post by: Emergo on November 13, 2015, 10:41:19 AM
Turns out my company does not have HSA. Bummer. I guess thats a huge loss for me, huh?
Title: Re: The Emergo Zero to Hero Progress Thread... Thanks to YOU!
Post by: Emergo on November 13, 2015, 10:42:09 AM
You're good to go Traditional IRA.  you're income after maxing a 401k and HSA will put you in the ballpark to go traditional.

Now that I dont have an option for HSA, dont go traditional? Thanks boarder. Youre the bomb.com.
Title: Re: The Emergo Zero to Hero Progress Thread... Thanks to YOU!
Post by: boarder42 on November 13, 2015, 11:39:11 AM
You're good to go Traditional IRA.  you're income after maxing a 401k and HSA will put you in the ballpark to go traditional.

Now that I dont have an option for HSA, dont go traditional? Thanks boarder. Youre the bomb.com.

your company doesnt  have to have an HSA option.  you can do your own HSA as long as youre on the high deductible health plan at work.

You should and still can go Trad IRA you're only making 4k above the max so if you put 18k in your 401k you can still go trad IRA, regardless of if you setup an HSA or not
Title: Re: The Emergo Zero to Hero Progress Thread... Thanks to YOU!
Post by: Emergo on November 13, 2015, 12:05:01 PM
You're good to go Traditional IRA.  you're income after maxing a 401k and HSA will put you in the ballpark to go traditional.

Now that I dont have an option for HSA, dont go traditional? Thanks boarder. Youre the bomb.com.

your company doesnt  have to have an HSA option.  you can do your own HSA as long as youre on the high deductible health plan at work.

You should and still can go Trad IRA you're only making 4k above the max so if you put 18k in your 401k you can still go trad IRA, regardless of if you setup an HSA or not

Okay, i'm on a high deductible plan and i just now checked this website on how to get my own HSA

https://personal.vanguard.com/us/whatweoffer/overview/healthsavings

They recommend a certain company and I go there and use HSA and invest in Vanguard. Seems like everything I invest in is Vanguard. Hmm.
Title: Re: The Emergo Zero to Hero Progress Thread... Thanks to YOU!
Post by: boarder42 on November 13, 2015, 12:12:12 PM
its not "in vanguard" its "with" vanguard.  their funds are conglomerations of different stocks in the stock market.
Title: Re: Houston, single male, 27 y.o., 65k slry, 0 debt, MMMnewb,podcast question update
Post by: rubybeth on November 16, 2015, 01:51:47 PM
Me and my friend just dissected HSA a bit from the mad fientist website. And i get it kinda..

So i put in 3000 every year, and for every medical expense i do i can get reimbursed at any time i want, so i can keep that in my HSA and at my retirement, all the reimbursements I have will likely equal or outweigh the tax from when i withdraw all the money i had that was growing in HSA
 Correct? So it sounds like a loophole, and the only way anyone who does this will get screwed is if they change the rule to doing reimbursements allowable up til one year on the receipts.

If I'm reading your summary right, no, that's not how it works. :)

The current maximum for a single HSA is $3,350: http://www.shrm.org/hrdisciplines/benefits/articles/pages/2016-hsa-limits.aspx

It's money set aside pre-tax (or, if you fund it yourself and not through your employer, you get a tax deduction on your taxes). You can only fund it if you have a High Deductible Health Plan (HDHP).

You can use it to reimburse yourself for qualifying medical expenses, at any time (even if you don't have a HDHP at some point). So if you get a prescription for $20 and want it to be paid for tax-free, you can reimburse yourself right away (or use the HSA debit card to pay for it outright; I prefer putting medical expenses on my credit card for the rewards, then reimbursing myself later). Or you can wait and total up all your receipts for as long as you want (hold onto the documentation; this can be audited by the IRS so you must keep receipts to show legitimate qualifying medical expenses). You could save receipts for many years until you decide to retire early, and then reimburse yourself as a way to get tax-free money. It's not taxed, ever, as long as it's used for medical expenses.

Funds in an HSA can also be invested, so the funds can grow like funds in an IRA, 401k, or taxable investment account. It helps if you can get your funds into a low-fee index fund. Some HSAs may require you to keep some of the funds in cash to be readily accessible to pay for a medical cost. For mine, that's the first $2,000. If my cash amount drops below that, some of the investment will be sold to make up the difference so I always have $2,000 in 'cash.'

If you use the HSA funds for expenses other than qualifying medical expenses, you will be taxed.
Title: Re: Latest post: max in 401k done, emergency savings 10k, 5.5k to ira to max 2015?
Post by: Emergo on December 01, 2015, 09:01:19 PM
Hey guys,

So my maxing of 401k has begun. Im living off 1700ish a month now. I have an emergency savings of 10k, should i go ahead and put 5.5k of that to IRA before the year ends? So it can grow faster? And then whatever leftover i have to a non retirement account through vanguard and get an etf? Since i probably wont be able to buy much?

I called vanguard and asked questions. It was very helpful. Still debating traditional ira to roth... all i know is that i can convert traditional to roth later on and maximize my savings that way....

Btw when next year starts, its gonna be difficult to put in 500 a month to my ira account with just 1700 leftover from maxing my 401k. Because from that 1700, subtract my monthly payments and its only 800? Minus the 500 from ira account... ouch!

But after maxing my 401k thats me having 50% saving rate. Which is pretty good...
Title: Re: Latest post: max in 401k done, emergency savings 10k, 5.5k to ira to max 2015?
Post by: boarder42 on December 02, 2015, 05:15:43 AM
300 a month depending what you have in those 900 dollars worth of monthly payments is tons of spending money.
Title: Re: Latest post: max in 401k done, emergency savings 10k, 5.5k to ira to max 2015?
Post by: boarder42 on December 02, 2015, 05:16:46 AM
Also you're an engineer. You should be seeing dramatic raises over the first few years of your career.
Title: Re: Latest post: max in 401k done, emergency savings 10k, 5.5k to ira to max 2015?
Post by: Emergo on December 02, 2015, 06:47:52 AM
Ill only get 5k per year raises and probably cap off at 90k. Unless i do something major career wise.
Title: Re: Latest: put 5.5k of savings into traditional or roth ira before yr ends?
Post by: boarder42 on December 02, 2015, 07:07:50 AM
You have until tax day in April to fund your IRA for 2015 just an FYI
Title: Re: Latest: put 5.5k of savings into traditional or roth ira before yr ends?
Post by: Emergo on December 02, 2015, 07:18:09 AM
So my ira and my non retirement accounts all will be invested in vtsax eventually right?
Title: Re: Latest: put 5.5k of savings into traditional or roth ira before yr ends?
Post by: boarder42 on December 02, 2015, 08:43:35 AM
thats where i would put it.
Title: Re: Latest: put 5.5k of savings into traditional or roth ira before yr ends?
Post by: DK on December 02, 2015, 08:54:35 AM
ha, "only" 5K/yr raises...

I'd rec looking and reading through fool.com as well, they gave me a lot of good general investing/tax advice.
Title: Re: Latest: put 5.5k of savings into traditional or roth ira before yr ends?
Post by: boarder42 on December 02, 2015, 09:12:47 AM
you're in houston.  you just jump ship to the company that will pay you the most.  and 5k a year is nothing to frown out either.  Houston is a hired gun city for engineering.
Title: Re: Latest: put 5.5k of savings into traditional or roth ira before yr ends?
Post by: Malum Prohibitum on December 07, 2015, 03:24:58 PM
You have until tax day in April to fund your IRA for 2015 just an FYI
Emergo, I just wanted to make sure you did not miss this deadline.  You get until April 15, 2016 to fully fund your IRA for the prior year (2015).
Title: Re: 1st post. New to MMM. Started with 0. Feels like I'm saving too slow, Need help
Post by: MoonShadow on December 07, 2015, 03:36:51 PM


Why do you want a $10,000 emergency fund?


In case I get laid off or any emergency event in my life or family. I thought this was the common thing people do?

It's a common thing that undisciplined savers do.  It's not really necessary for most of us here.  But since you can take your contributions out of a Roth IRA if you need too, put some money into a Roth IRA for a few years, till your contributions are at least $10K, and don't worry about an e-fund.  Max out that 401K, and leave it that way.  Let the rest of the details come to you as you learn more about investing.
Title: Re: Latest: put 5.5k of savings into traditional or roth ira before yr ends?
Post by: MDM on December 07, 2015, 03:40:30 PM
You have until tax day in April to fund your IRA for 2015 just an FYI
Emergo, I just wanted to make sure you did not miss this deadline.  You get until April 15, 2016 to fully fund your IRA for the prior year (2015).

And for the procrastinators in the audience, you get 3 (4 if you live in Maine or Massachusetts) extra days this time.  From https://www.irs.gov/Retirement-Plans/Traditional-and-Roth-IRAs:
Quote
Your tax return filing deadline (not including extensions). For example, you have until April 18, 2016, to make your 2015 contribution.

See http://www.irs.com/articles/tax-deadline-alert-2015-tax-returns-are-due-april-18-2016 for details.
Title: Re: Latest: put 5.5k of savings into traditional or roth ira before yr ends?
Post by: davef on December 08, 2015, 04:23:42 PM
I didn't read the whole thread but 10,000 is way too much for an emergency fund for a single guy that lives with mom. lets face it if you lost your job you living expenses would fall to about 1k per month. 6k is the most you need. Realistically in your situation I'd be comfortable with 3-5k. Especially if you have other non-liquid funds accessible to you.