I am a huge fan of glass top electric ranges, especially in small kitchens. They are easier to clean, provide useful counter space when not in use, generate no fumes, and don't pump moisture into your house. And incidentally, are potentially carbon neutral if that sort of thing is important to you.
Everyone else in my family prefers gas, I think mostly for aesthetic reasons. Mom claims she gets better heat control on gas burners, which I don't understand at all. I think she's doing it wrong. Sister is a total hipster and thinks gas is "more authentic" whatever that means.
Gas is currently cheaper to operate in most parts of the country, which is why I think gas water heaters still make more sense than electric water heaters. It all depends on your local fee structure, though. If you're paying $30/mo just for that gas hookup connection fee for a single appliance, then it makes sense to replace that appliance with an electric one that costs up to $30/mo more to operate, and the cost difference on a stove isn't anywhere near that much (but a water heater might be, if you have lots of people in your house).
In some cases, it makes sense to convert to full electric and stop paying the gas bill. Electric heat pumps are already cheaper to operate than gas furnaces. Stoves too, and sometimes water heaters. Dryers are evil. Maybe if you have a gas fireplace that you really enjoy?