I agree with you about high-deductible health plans. Most of the plans on the market these days go way beyond my definition of "insurance."
I was looking at Washington's health exchange website out of curiosity and found there were a couple of options at the bronze level (and one at the silver level!) that all qualified as HDHPs with HSA eligibility. If I were moving into the individual health insurance market I would be very likely to pick one of those. I'm sorry to hear nothing like that would be available for you in Massachusetts.
From what I've read, even though you're young enough to buy one of the "catastrophic" health plans, you would probably only want to do it if your income is too high for one of the subsidies. The catastrophic plans don't qualify for subsidies, and you would probably find a better overall deal with one of the bronze plans if your income qualifies.